• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Lucas

Status
Not open for further replies.
I wonder if Rodgers took/still takes the view put forward by quite a few posters on here, namely that a DM as such shouldn't be necessary if you have good midfielders who are mobile and skilful enough to do a bit of everything. When the subject's come up on here, my take on it has been - and it remains - that that's OK in principle but, in the modern game, not many teams will have enough top midfield quality to make it work in practice.
 
Also, please remind me, my short term memory is pretty shit due to my smoking habit, who won another trophy yesterday?
 
Mission accomplished. 😗


Also, if you think the 100m didn't improve us then you really need to look again.

Short of getting Ronaldo or Messi we weren't going to get any player to replace Suarez - even they'd have been up against it. But we've got better players at the club this season than last season.
 
Mission accomplished. 😗


Also, if you think the 100m didn't improve us then you really need to look again.

Short of getting Ronaldo or Messi we weren't going to get any player to replace Suarez - even they'd have been up against it. But we've got better players at the club this season than last season.

It didn't improve us.

It made us stronger in some positions, but weaker overall.

I'm hoping we'll be stronger when players like Markovic settle fully, but there's no doubt that we're a lesser team than last year.
 
Also, please remind me, my short term memory is pretty shit due to my smoking habit, who won another trophy yesterday?

ha ha ... you should read what the Napoli fans are saying on their boards ...

(You're also being a tad bit hypocritical considering about 'money' and 'improvement' considering how much money he's spent with no improvement ... I mean Athelitco Bilbao!!!)
 
Mission accomplished. 😗


Also, if you think the 100m didn't improve us then you really need to look again.

Short of getting Ronaldo or Messi we weren't going to get any player to replace Suarez - even they'd have been up against it. But we've got better players at the club this season than last season.

Oh I've looked.

Yeah Suarez was impossible to replace. So we buy Labert and Balotelli instead. Great!

This is what Athletico did:

Torres -> Aguero -> Falcao -> Diego Costa -> Mandzukic
 
That again raises the question of whose choice Balotelli was, and I'd lay heavy odds it wasn't Rodgers, given that he'd told the press Balotelli would not play for LFC less than a week before we bought him. Lambert was clearly intended as a third or fourth choice only, so isn't really relevant to this point.
 
Oh I've looked.

Yeah Suarez was impossible to replace. So we buy Labert and Balotelli instead. Great!

This is what Athletico did:

Torres -> Aguero -> Falcao -> Diego Costa -> Mandzukic

How did Raf replace Xabi Alonso? How did he replace our problem of no legitimate winger? 🙂

He won't be at Napoli next year it seems regardless ... Marcotti says ambition but he's wasted a shit load of money and taken the team nowhere (and supposedly his best striker wants out). He'll managed Atleti next season once Simeone moves to Arsenal! 😉
 
How did Raf replace Xabi Alonso? How did he replace our problem of no legitimate winger? 🙂

He won't be at Napoli next year it seems regardless ... Marcotti says ambition but he's wasted a shit load of money and taken the team nowhere (and supposedly his best striker wants out). He'll managed Atleti next season once Simeone moves to Arsenal! 😉


Yes, did he have £100 million to spend though?
 
Mission accomplished. 😗


Also, if you think the 100m didn't improve us then you really need to look again.

Short of getting Ronaldo or Messi we weren't going to get any player to replace Suarez - even they'd have been up against it. But we've got better players at the club this season than last season.


seriously debatable....

The league table does not lie.. we are no way improved team at all over last season.. and saying we have better players at the club than last season is seriously open for debate.. Moreno, other than the goal seems not much better than Aly Cissokho, Mingolet has declined, we let Agger go for Lovren.. Balotelli in for the departed Suarez.. Lambert for Aspas (not much differance imho).. Skrtel & Gerrard have declined further.. Johnson is shocking and looks even more like he cannot be arsed.. Manquillio although I rate, is not better than Flannagan.. Allen shouldn't even be at the club..

The 100m spent has made us a much worse team.. No Balance, no structure and no rhythm and we are now playing a 'botched' formation to address the holes the new signings have created..

The only shining light from the new signings is Lallana, and the sudden rise of Markovic..

Their is no denying we did a spurs with the transfers, we tried to add squad players without signing players that could walk into the first team..
 
Yes, did he have £100 million to spend though?

You're terrible at this - remind me how much he spent the year after we finished 2nd ... Aquilani ... Keane ... Dossena etc ... He just couldn't get us over the hump ... You should ask yourself if Rafa could have rebuilt Liverpool had he sold Gerrard after 2005 like Rodgers is attempting to do after selling the best player in the league.
 
You're terrible at this - remind me how much he spent the year after we finished 2nd ... Aquilani ... Keane ... Dossena etc ... He just couldn't get us over the hump ... You should ask yourself if Rafa could have rebuilt Liverpool had he sold Gerrard after 2005 like Rodgers is attempting to do after selling the best player in the league.


We wouldn't be lingering in 13th place in the league that's for sure.
 
Like they'd sanction that.

Who knows?

Essentially both managers have spent roughly what they've made in most windows plus about 20m(was less, getting more and more) at the most. It's never varied too much from that. We've never had a huge amount to go and improve the team, we've just rejigged it based on who we can get rid of or who wants to leave.
 
I think Skrtel saved Rodgers Bacon at the weekend..

If we had lost that game, I think his position would have become untenable....


the next few games are crucial.. He needs to stop dicking about and stick with Lucas in midfield if he wants to keep this job...
 
seriously debatable....

The league table does not lie.. we are no way improved team at all over last season.. and saying we have better players at the club than last season is seriously open for debate.. Moreno, other than the goal seems not much better than Aly Cissokho, Mingolet has declined, we let Agger go for Lovren.. Balotelli in for the departed Suarez.. Lambert for Aspas (not much differance imho).. Skrtel & Gerrard have declined further.. Johnson is shocking and looks even more like he cannot be arsed.. Manquillio although I rate, is not better than Flannagan.. Allen shouldn't even be at the club..

The 100m spent has made us a much worse team.. No Balance, no structure and no rhythm and we are now playing a 'botched' formation to address the holes the new signings have created..

The only shining light from the new signings is Lallana, and the sudden rise of Markovic..

Their is no denying we did a spurs with the transfers, we tried to add squad players without signing players that could walk into the first team..
We've created over 40 chances in two games with this 'botched' formation.
What's your logic for this?
 
We've created over 40 chances in two games with this 'botched' formation.
What's your logic for this?

Look.. this formation has only come about as a last roll of the dice.. we failed to win two of the games.. so other than the '40 chances' nothing great has improved on the results side of things.. Although I can bare to watch us now..

It is evident we miss a natural goal scorer.. that could of made the differance, I agree. But the age old issue still needs addressing, the defence..

We could go into the next game create a stupid amount of chances, but lose.. thats how it is.. No improvement overall..

You dont get points on the board for outplaying the opposition..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom