• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Yeeha

Status
Not open for further replies.
Apparently XenForo is one of the best out there.

I don't know enough about them, but guess it depends on what you want on what's best. I think we want one that is hassle free and not necessarily flexible or cheap. Maybe it's best for that, but given we basically need one persons expertise I'd hope theres something else out there that doesn't need any tech expertise at all.
 
It's probably worth putting together some options and then having a discussion / poll to see what the majority prefers.

I think I still prefer the forum format (maybe I'm just old).
I'm with Keni., The site is a little antiquated but still functions well with good functionality.

A quick look at the options mentioned (Discord and XenForo) and Discord doesn't look anything like a forum, more like Twitter ! XenForo is probably too expensive (£1,000 a year without extras or migration fees).
 
I'm with Keni., The site is a little antiquated but still functions well with good functionality.

A quick look at the options mentioned (Discord and XenForo) and Discord doesn't look anything like a forum, more like Twitter ! XenForo is probably too expensive (£1,000 a year without extras or migration fees).
SCM currently uses XenForo I think?
 
Is there something blocking a xenforo upgrade? I know the guys in work use nagios to monitor applications for disk space, certificate expiry and the like.
 
I'm with Keni., The site is a little antiquated but still functions well with good functionality.

A quick look at the options mentioned (Discord and XenForo) and Discord doesn't look anything like a forum, more like Twitter ! XenForo is probably too expensive (£1,000 a year without extras or migration fees).
I had the same concerns about discord. I've actually managed to make it look and feel a lot like this place.
 
My concern with discord is the barrier to entry, i.e. that the core users on here, myself included will move over, but not everyone would, and the site already feels like a bit of a closed shop, for better and worse.

Perhaps that's being antiquated though, the average age of this place is half dead. Discord might give it an occasional half-term vibe, as the kids don't say.
 
I had the same concerns about discord. I've actually managed to make it look and feel a lot like this place.
Yeh i looked at that with my effort. Was playing more than anything else.

Created forums. Liked they should be.. And added channels for match days..

Sent from my 2201122G using Tapatalk
 
Discord will basically mean - 6CM will be banished to a deep hidden treacherous cave up in some remote mountains far, far away.

And only the most courageous, hardcore, diehard fan will be able to find us. And by fan i mean new members.

I don't want to be locked up with the loons for the rest of my life. We've already lost so many good posters and hardly had any new people join in the last few years.
 
My concern with discord is the barrier to entry, i.e. that the core users on here, myself included will move over, but not everyone would, and the site already feels like a bit of a closed shop, for better and worse.

Perhaps that's being antiquated though, the average age of this place is half dead. Discord might give it an occasional half-term vibe, as the kids don't say.
Is there really a barrier to entry? If anything it could drive more users if that's what we wanted. You can make public and tag it accordingly.

The downside is obviously discord has a much younger market if you open it up to the public. You are talking tweens upwards.
 
I think discord could work with forum channels..
It a marmite solution.. You either love it or hate it .

You may attract kids to the site, Which is fine for all you groomers that post here anyway. [emoji6]. [emoji102][emoji490][emoji135][emoji3553][emoji2539]

To note any spamming can be a royal pain in the arse, if your site becomes popular

Though discord has got better managing this over the years .
 
Exactly. Public is only public within discord.

But you won't get any traffic coming into discord from the rest of the internet e.g. if any fan google search 6CM, they won't find us. Unless you leave a webpage with a discord link on there, but even then you'd have to spend a bit on SEO to bump the site up to at least the first 2-3 pages of Google.

Also, there's no guarantee they will click to join your discord link. There are many who don't even have an account.
 
I think discord could work with forum channels..
It a marmite solution.. You either love it or hate it .

You may attract kids to the site, Which is fine for all you groomers that post here anyway. [emoji6]. [emoji102][emoji490][emoji135][emoji3553][emoji2539]

To note any spamming can be a royal pain in the arse, if your site becomes popular

Though discord has got better managing this over the years .
Yes security bots are a must. They call them raids.
 
Exactly. Public is only public within discord.

But you won't get any traffic coming into discord from the rest of the internet e.g. if any fan google search 6CM, they won't find us. Unless you leave a webpage with a discord link on there, but even that you'd have to spend a bit on SEO to bump the site up to at least the first 2-3 pages of Google.

Also, there's no guarantee they will click to join your discord link. There are many who don't even have an account.
Yes that's one thing some have suggested for now. Put the discord link as a redirect if the forum falls over.

Realistically. How many people will actively search for 6CM as a new member? Very very few.

How many new members will search for a new forum? Probably only if theirs falls over I.e. a RAWK or a est1982 for example.
 
Last edited:
Yeah but where are you going to put the link ?

Even if you create a simple page with the same domain name (6CM) with the discord link on it, why would any new fan want to visit us, assuming he/she hasn't got a clue who we are in the first place ?

Unless maybe the page is littered with screenshots of memorable posts/discussions from the Vault as part of the marketing ploy. Not sure that'll work though.
 
just to add.. Tapatalk is not supported on the new xenforo

It's not needed anyway. As the be xenforo is far more mobile freindly then the existing set up
 
Last edited:
Yeah but where are you going to put the link ?

Even if you create a simple page with the same domain name (6CM) with the discord link on it, why would any new fan want to visit us, assuming he/she hasn't got a clue who we are in the first place ?

Unless maybe the page is littered with screenshots of memorable posts/discussions from the Vault as part of the marketing ploy. Not sure that'll work though.
You would use social media to advertise it . Tiktok, Facebook etc etc..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom