Our worst signing from the Bundesliga

[Dreambeliever]

Because its food for the troll. And any fool knows that the answer is Sean "I'm faster than Michael Owen" Dundee. He was OK because he was only £2m? He was that shit they should have been paying us to take him off their hands

2m wasn’t small money back then either.

 

[Rosco]

Pity we've got those nonsensical retards Klopp and Edwards making transfer decisions eh

It's not really a black and white situaiton is it ?

People who are good at their job make mistakes, it's because they make more good decisions than bad ones that they can be considered good even if they make a few clangers.

 

[Mamma Mia]

It's not really a black and white situaiton is it ?

People who are good at their job make mistakes, it's because they make more good decisions than bad ones that they can be considered good even if they make a few clangers.

Well yeah, obviously.

 

[StevieM]

Thiago isn’t one of those “clangers” though.

Kieta has been disappointing, particularly given his cost.

But, Karius arguably cost as more financially and in terms of results from his actual “clangers” than anyone else we’ve signed from Germany.

I’d like to say Sean Dundee was shite - but I never actually saw any of his 3 sub appearances - so I couldn’t tell you how shite he was.

Degen was already dead when we bought him.

 

[Halmeister]

You've gotta look at overall impact and factor in various different criteria. While Keita has been massively disappointing and cost a lot, he has talent and has won a shit load while at us. Karius was shit and cost us games - one of them being singlehandedly losing us the Champions League final.

Karius gets my vote.

 

[mark1975]

Thiago isn’t one of those “clangers” though.

Kieta has been disappointing, particularly given his cost.

But, Karius arguably cost as more financially and in terms of results from his actual “clangers” than anyone else we’ve signed from Germany.

I’d like to say Sean Dundee was shite - but I never actually saw any of his 3 sub appearances - so I couldn’t tell you how shite he was.

Degen was already dead when we bought him.

I remember Dundee coming on against Blackburn (I think) and running clear on goal but getting caught up by someone shite like Darren Peacock (citation needed), before falling over. This was after him giving it large about being faster than Michael Owen. My Nan was faster.

 

[Grjt2]

I remember Dundee coming on against Blackburn (I think) and running clear on goal but getting caught up by someone shite like Darren Peacock (citation needed), before falling over. This was after him giving it large about being faster than Michael Owen. My Nan was faster.

I think I was there! Didn’t he get hit in the back of the head by the ball?! Totally awful.

 

[mark1975]

I think I was there! Didn’t he get hit in the back of the head by the ball?! Totally awful.

I remember it being a total comedy moment where even our fans were pissing themselves laughing. I've tried to find footage of it but it doesn't seem to exist, I don't recall it being a televised game?

 

[Dirty Sanchez]

Voronin or Yesil.

 

[rurikbird]

Voronin or Yesil.

That’s preposterous; Yesil will come good any moment now.

 

[Dirty Sanchez]

That’s preposterous; Yesil will come good any moment now.

@gkmacca any updates?

 

[Shay_K]

Yup. Any Thiago bashing is ridiculous at this stage. He’s supposed to be the icing on the cake but the cake is a bit smashed up at the moment.

Keita on the other hand is one of the biggest disappointments since Kewell.

Alberto Aquilani (yes I know they didn't come from German clubs, we've deviated and gone off on a tangent)

 

[Markeh]

Alberto Aquilani (yes I know they didn't come from German clubs, we've deviated and gone off on a tangent)

First name on the made from chocolate XI team sheet

 

[StevieM]

First name on the made from chocolate XI team sheet

Second name behind Matip more like.