Newbies.
- Thread starter Oncy
- Start date
- Latest activity Latest activity:
- Status
Agree with every rating.
Kinda obv that I would though, cos we share the same cranium 95% of the time.
Kinda obv that I would though, cos we share the same cranium 95% of the time.
It's impressive how quickly they've all settled in. We hear the "it's not football manager, you can't make so many changes so soon" type stuff, but it seems Kenny actually can.
Adam needs to show he can turn thing around by himself. Currently he looks great when the rest are doing well but goes quiet when others are a bit shit.
[quote author=SaintGeorge67 link=topic=46631.msg1388823#msg1388823 date=1314472005]
It's impressive how quickly they've all settled in. We hear the "it's not football manager, you can't make so many changes so soon" type stuff, but it seems Kenny actually can.
[/quote]
'Premier League Proven', that's why!
It's impressive how quickly they've all settled in. We hear the "it's not football manager, you can't make so many changes so soon" type stuff, but it seems Kenny actually can.
[/quote]
'Premier League Proven', that's why!
ha ha
who else thought oncy was talking about new members on 6CM? be honest 😉
who else thought oncy was talking about new members on 6CM? be honest 😉
[quote author=Herr Onceared link=topic=46631.msg1388858#msg1388858 date=1314472977]
[quote author=Modo link=topic=46631.msg1388855#msg1388855 date=1314472893]
aren't we forgetting someone. Especially since Carroll is labelled a "newbie".
[/quote]Carroll missed most of last season. Suarez has been integral to our team for 6 months.
[/quote]
OK.
[quote author=Modo link=topic=46631.msg1388855#msg1388855 date=1314472893]
aren't we forgetting someone. Especially since Carroll is labelled a "newbie".
[/quote]Carroll missed most of last season. Suarez has been integral to our team for 6 months.
[/quote]
OK.
Adam was top top class today, hes going to be a big big player for us this season.
Suarez - 10
Enrique - 9
Adam - 8.5
Downing - 8.5
Henderson - 7
Carroll - 7
Enrique - 9
Adam - 8.5
Downing - 8.5
Henderson - 7
Carroll - 7
[quote author=Gary25 link=topic=46631.msg1388936#msg1388936 date=1314475987]
[quote author=barrymac20 link=topic=46631.msg1388916#msg1388916 date=1314475200]
Adam was top top class today, hes going to be a big big player for us this season.
[/quote]
True. He's had a big impact.
[/quote]
He can only get better and, unlike Alonso, he will never want to leave LFC. Great buy.
[quote author=barrymac20 link=topic=46631.msg1388916#msg1388916 date=1314475200]
Adam was top top class today, hes going to be a big big player for us this season.
[/quote]
True. He's had a big impact.
[/quote]
He can only get better and, unlike Alonso, he will never want to leave LFC. Great buy.
[quote author=Wilko link=topic=46631.msg1388945#msg1388945 date=1314476424]
[quote author=barrymac20 link=topic=46631.msg1388916#msg1388916 date=1314475200]
Adam was top top class today, hes going to be a big big player for us this season.
[/quote]
I agree agree.
[/quote]
ha, just noticed the double ups!!
[quote author=barrymac20 link=topic=46631.msg1388916#msg1388916 date=1314475200]
Adam was top top class today, hes going to be a big big player for us this season.
[/quote]
I agree agree.
[/quote]
ha, just noticed the double ups!!
[quote author=Dylan link=topic=46631.msg1388920#msg1388920 date=1314475332]
Carroll 6 but it will come good for him
Enrique - 9 he looks like a Liverpool player in every respect
Adam & Henderson - 7 both will have done themselces the world of good today
Downing - 8 i said my piece in the 'thoughts' thread
[/quote]
I'll go with this but maybe Downing with a 9. Now, I don't think this performances have been '9' but his impact on the team (width, ability to create off the dribble and being able to be very effective on either wing) has been fantastic.
Carroll 6 but it will come good for him
Enrique - 9 he looks like a Liverpool player in every respect
Adam & Henderson - 7 both will have done themselces the world of good today
Downing - 8 i said my piece in the 'thoughts' thread
[/quote]
I'll go with this but maybe Downing with a 9. Now, I don't think this performances have been '9' but his impact on the team (width, ability to create off the dribble and being able to be very effective on either wing) has been fantastic.
[quote author=LeTallecWiz link=topic=46631.msg1388949#msg1388949 date=1314476560]
[quote author=Dylan link=topic=46631.msg1388920#msg1388920 date=1314475332]
Carroll 6 but it will come good for him
Enrique - 9 he looks like a Liverpool player in every respect
Adam & Henderson - 7 both will have done themselces the world of good today
Downing - 8 i said my piece in the 'thoughts' thread
[/quote]
I'll go with this but maybe Downing with a 9. Now, I don't think this performances have been '9' but his impact on the team (width, ability to create off the dribble and being able to be very effective on either wing) has been fantastic.
[/quote]
You not think Adam has had as much an impact?
[quote author=Dylan link=topic=46631.msg1388920#msg1388920 date=1314475332]
Carroll 6 but it will come good for him
Enrique - 9 he looks like a Liverpool player in every respect
Adam & Henderson - 7 both will have done themselces the world of good today
Downing - 8 i said my piece in the 'thoughts' thread
[/quote]
I'll go with this but maybe Downing with a 9. Now, I don't think this performances have been '9' but his impact on the team (width, ability to create off the dribble and being able to be very effective on either wing) has been fantastic.
[/quote]
You not think Adam has had as much an impact?
Suarez, no words or ratings can justify his performances.
Enrique looks like he's been at Liverpool for years.
Downing has been surprisingly superb for us. Changed my opinion of him fairly quickly from average to very good. He'll be outstanding once he starts scoring goals.
I said Henderson needed time to settle because he has talent. His finish today was fantastic. More of the same please.
Adam's performances are improving with his fitness. Took his goal well and is doing better from set pieces.
Carroll is the odd man out and has to rapidly improve or be left watching the game from the game from the bench. He has it all to do!
Enrique looks like he's been at Liverpool for years.
Downing has been surprisingly superb for us. Changed my opinion of him fairly quickly from average to very good. He'll be outstanding once he starts scoring goals.
I said Henderson needed time to settle because he has talent. His finish today was fantastic. More of the same please.
Adam's performances are improving with his fitness. Took his goal well and is doing better from set pieces.
Carroll is the odd man out and has to rapidly improve or be left watching the game from the game from the bench. He has it all to do!
Suarez 10/10 - I actually think he's played comparatively poorly so far this season and he's still great!
Carroll 4/10 - He just doesn't look like he's playing in the right division, nevermind for a top team, but if anyone can help him it's KD.
Downing 7/10 - I don't get all the lavish praise he seems to be getting but he's certainly improved our left side a lot. I hope he can play better over the coming months
Enrique 8/10 - so far he looks like a bargain but i think he's played it a bit safe in matches like today's when he could have helped the attack more.
Henderson 9/10 - He hasn't grabbed the headlines until today but for me he's been a brilliant signing. Incredibly mature and considered in his use of the ball - I think he's gonna be one of our best players over the next decade.
Adam 6/10 - I admit it seems odd to rate his so lowly when he's scored and had two assists but I still think he looks a bit slow and immobile for the top level. He also gives the ball away a lot more than I expected.
Carroll 4/10 - He just doesn't look like he's playing in the right division, nevermind for a top team, but if anyone can help him it's KD.
Downing 7/10 - I don't get all the lavish praise he seems to be getting but he's certainly improved our left side a lot. I hope he can play better over the coming months
Enrique 8/10 - so far he looks like a bargain but i think he's played it a bit safe in matches like today's when he could have helped the attack more.
Henderson 9/10 - He hasn't grabbed the headlines until today but for me he's been a brilliant signing. Incredibly mature and considered in his use of the ball - I think he's gonna be one of our best players over the next decade.
Adam 6/10 - I admit it seems odd to rate his so lowly when he's scored and had two assists but I still think he looks a bit slow and immobile for the top level. He also gives the ball away a lot more than I expected.
[quote author=barrymac20 link=topic=46631.msg1388951#msg1388951 date=1314476648]
[quote author=LeTallecWiz link=topic=46631.msg1388949#msg1388949 date=1314476560]
[quote author=Dylan link=topic=46631.msg1388920#msg1388920 date=1314475332]
Carroll 6 but it will come good for him
Enrique - 9 he looks like a Liverpool player in every respect
Adam & Henderson - 7 both will have done themselces the world of good today
Downing - 8 i said my piece in the 'thoughts' thread
[/quote]
I'll go with this but maybe Downing with a 9. Now, I don't think this performances have been '9' but his impact on the team (width, ability to create off the dribble and being able to be very effective on either wing) has been fantastic.
[/quote]
You not think Adam has had as much an impact?
[/quote]
He has but I don't think it's been as impressive as Downing or Enrique.
[quote author=LeTallecWiz link=topic=46631.msg1388949#msg1388949 date=1314476560]
[quote author=Dylan link=topic=46631.msg1388920#msg1388920 date=1314475332]
Carroll 6 but it will come good for him
Enrique - 9 he looks like a Liverpool player in every respect
Adam & Henderson - 7 both will have done themselces the world of good today
Downing - 8 i said my piece in the 'thoughts' thread
[/quote]
I'll go with this but maybe Downing with a 9. Now, I don't think this performances have been '9' but his impact on the team (width, ability to create off the dribble and being able to be very effective on either wing) has been fantastic.
[/quote]
You not think Adam has had as much an impact?
[/quote]
He has but I don't think it's been as impressive as Downing or Enrique.
[quote author=gene hughes link=topic=46631.msg1388960#msg1388960 date=1314477891]
Suarez 10/10 - I actually think he's played comparatively poorly so far this season and he's still great!
Carroll 4/10 - He just doesn't look like he's playing in the right division, nevermind for a top team, but if anyone can help him it's KD.
Downing 7/10 - I don't get all the lavish praise he seems to be getting but he's certainly improved our left side a lot. I hope he can play better over the coming months
Enrique 8/10 - so far he looks like a bargain but i think he's played it a bit safe in matches like today's when he could have helped the attack more.
Henderson 9/10 - He hasn't grabbed the headlines until today but for me he's been a brilliant signing. Incredibly mature and considered in his use of the ball - I think he's gonna be one of our best players over the next decade.
Adam 6/10 - I admit it seems odd to rate his so lowly when he's scored and had two assists but I still think he looks a bit slow and immobile for the top level. He also gives the ball away a lot more than I expected.
[/quote]
i'd bump downing to an 8 but i agree, especially for the reasoning. Adam has done well, but he seems haphazard at times and tries too many hollywood balls. I think he's got the potential, but i'm waiting until he dominates a game.
Hendo will be a big player for us. For me, him and shelvey over the next 10 years
FTW
Suarez 10/10 - I actually think he's played comparatively poorly so far this season and he's still great!
Carroll 4/10 - He just doesn't look like he's playing in the right division, nevermind for a top team, but if anyone can help him it's KD.
Downing 7/10 - I don't get all the lavish praise he seems to be getting but he's certainly improved our left side a lot. I hope he can play better over the coming months
Enrique 8/10 - so far he looks like a bargain but i think he's played it a bit safe in matches like today's when he could have helped the attack more.
Henderson 9/10 - He hasn't grabbed the headlines until today but for me he's been a brilliant signing. Incredibly mature and considered in his use of the ball - I think he's gonna be one of our best players over the next decade.
Adam 6/10 - I admit it seems odd to rate his so lowly when he's scored and had two assists but I still think he looks a bit slow and immobile for the top level. He also gives the ball away a lot more than I expected.
[/quote]
i'd bump downing to an 8 but i agree, especially for the reasoning. Adam has done well, but he seems haphazard at times and tries too many hollywood balls. I think he's got the potential, but i'm waiting until he dominates a game.
Hendo will be a big player for us. For me, him and shelvey over the next 10 years
FTW
I can't do the numbers thing but Enrique, Suarez and Downing have walked into our side and become instant 'can't drop' for their positions. Adam has been okay but I suspect will be on the bench when Stevie and Ming are both fit. Henderson I've not made my mind up about.
I was expecting Carroll to be Shearer II, not because of his origins but because of his style. Difference is Carroll looks like he doesn't give a shit. I'm looking for a big improvement in effort and output from him.
I was expecting Carroll to be Shearer II, not because of his origins but because of his style. Difference is Carroll looks like he doesn't give a shit. I'm looking for a big improvement in effort and output from him.
[quote author=LeTallecWiz link=topic=46631.msg1388964#msg1388964 date=1314478989]
[quote author=barrymac20 link=topic=46631.msg1388951#msg1388951 date=1314476648]
[quote author=LeTallecWiz link=topic=46631.msg1388949#msg1388949 date=1314476560]
[quote author=Dylan link=topic=46631.msg1388920#msg1388920 date=1314475332]
Carroll 6 but it will come good for him
Enrique - 9 he looks like a Liverpool player in every respect
Adam & Henderson - 7 both will have done themselces the world of good today
Downing - 8 i said my piece in the 'thoughts' thread
[/quote]
I'll go with this but maybe Downing with a 9. Now, I don't think this performances have been '9' but his impact on the team (width, ability to create off the dribble and being able to be very effective on either wing) has been fantastic.
[/quote]
You not think Adam has had as much an impact?
[/quote]
He has but I don't think it's been as impressive as Downing or Enrique.
[/quote]
Adam will be mosterous for us this year, believe me!
[quote author=barrymac20 link=topic=46631.msg1388951#msg1388951 date=1314476648]
[quote author=LeTallecWiz link=topic=46631.msg1388949#msg1388949 date=1314476560]
[quote author=Dylan link=topic=46631.msg1388920#msg1388920 date=1314475332]
Carroll 6 but it will come good for him
Enrique - 9 he looks like a Liverpool player in every respect
Adam & Henderson - 7 both will have done themselces the world of good today
Downing - 8 i said my piece in the 'thoughts' thread
[/quote]
I'll go with this but maybe Downing with a 9. Now, I don't think this performances have been '9' but his impact on the team (width, ability to create off the dribble and being able to be very effective on either wing) has been fantastic.
[/quote]
You not think Adam has had as much an impact?
[/quote]
He has but I don't think it's been as impressive as Downing or Enrique.
[/quote]
Adam will be mosterous for us this year, believe me!
- Status
