I dont think anyone is suggesting that.So people can't react to negativity by arguing the toss, but posters can be as negative as they want cos its freedom of speech?
Anyway, Macca's Guardian article says that Bellamy wants to return to his family, something a few people have said of late, and that Agger's contract talks haven't gone anywhere, so while we're getting concerned about what's apparent, it might be worth considering these 'apparent' underlying reasons too, before we hang Rodgers.
I think the issue is that we need to stop talking about wether the opinion is negative or positive and debate the issue.