• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Biggest Flop of the Season

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rosco

Worse than Brendan
Member
The Guardian have a few suggestions:

Queens Park Rangers


In fairness, they were so lavishly bad that they became quite entertaining. Who could fail to be amused by their relentlessly inventive self-destruction, from misguided signings and tactics to slapstick own goals and majestically needless red cards? The owners goofed, both managers goofed and most of the players goofed. Impressive uniformity for a club riven by rifts.
Cheik Tioté


There were many reasons for Newcastle's stuttering campaign, some of them excusable. But while injuries and fixture congestion took a toll, some players just plain flunked their season. Cheik Tioté's regression from one of the signings of last season to nigh-on a liability this term was strange. Whereas last season he helped Newcastle establish a sturdy platform in midfield, this season his positive influence declined alarmingly and he was noticeable only for the consistency with which he mistimed tackles.
Tony Pulis


This season Stoke were supposed to make a great leap forward. Or was that last season? Pulis has been promising for a while that he would add a new dimension to his team's play, adding a little more unpredictability to their admirable ruggedness. But you get the feeling that he never really meant it or just couldn't bring himself to loosen up enough to create or attack, especially away, where Stoke were routinely contemptibly negative. To have a greater net spend on transfers than anyone other than Chelsea and Manchester City over the past five years and end up with a right flank manned by Andy Wilkinson and Ryan Shotton is to confess to an extraordinarily limited vision.
Roberto Mancini


There are professors who got PhDs from a slot machine in Butlins who could mount better defences of their title than Manchester City managed this season. So many non-performances, so many ill-conceived tactics and substitutions. And, while we're at it, so little clue in Europe.
Adam Johnson

Freed from the clutches of the unappreciative Mancini, the winger was supposed to fly to new heights at Sunderland. But he just didn't. He seemed inhibited by the responsibility thrust upon him following his £10m transfer and rather than bring sparkle to the Stadium of Light, he helped spread the gloom that engulfed it for most of the campaign. He may have been even worse than we think, but we just didn't realise it because Sunderland were rarely worth paying attention to.
 
Tony Pulis
To have a greater net spend on transfers than anyone other than Chelsea and Manchester City over the past five years and end up with a right flank manned by Andy Wilkinson and Ryan Shotton is to confess to an extraordinarily limited vision.
Ross, explain to me the theory behind managers not making any difference, and money being the all important factor?🙂

Anyway, flop of the season - At Liverpool - for me was Glen Johnson. Particularly in the second half of the season. I've never seen him be so sloppy with the ball, ever.
Wingers got past him with ease on many occasions with crosses being allowed to get whipped in, while seeing him give the ball away cheaply in an attacking position was just exasperating.

A lot of people don't rate Enrique, and there are genuine concerns about him, but at least you hardly ever see any winger getting past him throughout a season, and he created quite a few goals for the team too. He's also the scorer of one of the best team goals we've scored in years.
Would much rather keep him than Johnson.
 
For us - I don't really think we had 'great flops' - maybe Borini, but he barely stayed healthy.

I wouldn't call Borini a flop - just too soon to make such a call, surely, but he hasn't proved himself value for money, when compared with the likes of Coutinho and Sturridge. The two, and our last two, signings, must be the yardstick to measure all future signings by.
 
I wouldn't call Borini a flop - just too soon to make such a call, surely, but he hasn't proved himself value for money, when compared with the likes of Coutinho and Sturridge. The two, and our last two, signings, must be the yardstick to measure all future signings by.
Hello. I agree.
 
I think Allen was poor, at least with Borini you can sort of see the potential there, but I wouldn't write either of them off by any means. Last season many of us thought Henderson was a dud and Shelvey was destined for greatness, 12 months makes alot of difference and another 12 could swiftly change opinion again. Sterling was a God-send 8 months ago, now he's barely mentioned. They're all young and they need time, not every one of them is going to come good, but we've alot of youngsters who have the potential to be first teamers, that's a big step in the right direction.
 
I think Allen was poor, at least with Borini you can sort of see the potential there, but I wouldn't write either of them off by any means. Last season many of us thought Henderson was a dud and Shelvey was destined for greatness, 12 months makes alot of difference and another 12 could swiftly change opinion again. Sterling was a God-send 8 months ago, now he's barely mentioned. They're all young and they need time, not every one of them is going to come good, but we've alot of youngsters who have the potential to be first teamers, that's a big step in the right direction.

I wouldn't write them off either. But I was expecting a lot more from both(when they actually played) for the money paid for them. Injuries obviously didn't help either of them, but neither were worth the money we paid on what we saw.
 
I wouldn't write them off either. But I was expecting a lot more from both(when they actually played) for the money paid for them. Injuries obviously didn't help either of them, but neither were worth the money we paid on what we saw.

Same with Hendo last season. I agree though with one of the previous posts, Sturridge and Coutinho should be a benchmark of sorts.
 
I wouldn't call Borini a flop - just too soon to make such a call, surely, but he hasn't proved himself value for money, when compared with the likes of Coutinho and Sturridge. The two, and our last two, signings, must be the yardstick to measure all future signings by.

Yah - hence I said 'maybe' as I do like Borini, and think he can be a very good player for us.

Gerry mentioned Allen - and it's harsh too ... He wasn't healthy the last few months, but there was a lot of positive stuff in the first 10 appearances.
 
Yah - hence I said 'maybe' as I do like Borini, and think he can be a very good player for us.

Gerry mentioned Allen - and it's harsh too ... He wasn't healthy the last few months, but there was a lot of positive stuff in the first 10 appearances.

Players I expected more from given their price tag, for me is a flop. Doesn't mean they can't turn it around, but when you look at the return we got from other players, you can't help but be a little disappointed with them. Yeah, they've had injuries, and the excuse of it being their first season with us. But I'm still disappointed with the return we've had.
 
Players I expected more from given their price tag, for me is a flop. Doesn't mean they can't turn it around, but when you look at the return we got from other players, you can't help but be a little disappointed with them. Yeah, they've had injuries, and the excuse of it being their first season with us. But I'm still disappointed with the return we've had.

So Disappointment of the Year ... They didn't flop ... Flop is more like Downing last year.
 
Allen played with an injury since October, right when his form dipped.
I think he'll get back to his best next season
 
I thought Javi Garcia was shite whenever I saw him £16m, Marin at Chelsea what happened to him?

for us Sahin was a huge disappointment and I don't see what Borini has that warranted £10m.
 
David Silva for me.
Fair enough that he set the bar for himself fairly high but I thought he was awful all season long.
 
1. Borini was out mostly due to injury but he showed some potential. Whether we are the right club for him is left to be seen.
2. Allen was a disappointment. Started well enough and slid into mediocrity.
3. Skrtel never recovered from Carra getting into the team ahead of him. The lads confidence was shaken.
4. Shelvey, Jonjo who?
5. Jose was good in spurts but still dwells on the ball too long. He may have dreamt that he is Messi.
6. Magic started off poorly, picked up his form at LB then was anonymous at RB bar a few outstanding games.
7. Lucas never hit the heights after his injury. Needs to improve massively.
8. Pepe lost his hunger and seems to have got a taste again.

Henderson was a shining light this season and improved his mentality, confidence and goal tally.
Since December Downing has come good but whether its enough only time will tell.
Gerrard was ever present and was largely injury free. We managed him well this season.
Suarez, Coutinho and Sturridge gave me hope. Looking forward to the new season with them spearheading our attack.
 
Skrtel. Terrible disappointment. And collectively the young players - for all the hype about giving youth a chance, Sterling was depressingly overplayed until he was a waste of space, Suso was messed around after a promising start and Pacheco never seemed to be fancied even though he played well enough in the reserves and showed a great commitment.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom