Mediocre team with no goalscorers and a shite goalkeeper in home defeat shocker!
Klopp is working with players he didn't buy, but he does select them. So far he's lost as many Premiership games as he has won. Anyone can do that, and so far he's done nothing to be overly excited about, despite me actually feeling more excited by him.
He selected the wrong team and lots of us feared the worst, because with Lucas, Can, Milner, Lallana, Henderson and Firmino all on the pitch together, you have a midfield and attack who have scored a total of 7 goals between them all fucking season. Seven. Lucas has scored about one in his entire career. Lallana has ZERO all season. Firmino has managed a total of three in 20 games - two of which came last week. That is startling enough, but when you ally that with a defence as porous as ours, it's no wonder we have an embarrassing minus GD.
We played well enough in the first half, and De Gea made one outstanding save, but we didn't create enough good chances, and we wasted lots of good positions with wild shooting, or poor passing. United improved after halftime - they could hardly be worse - and our laughable ineptitude at set-pieces cost us again. Nobody has conceded as many goals from corners as us. That lump Feillani easily out jumped the defence, Mignolet was lost again, and nobody was anywhere near Rooney who had plenty of time to smash it high into the goal from 6 yards. After that you couldn't see us scoring, even with the mysteriously delayed introduction of Benteke and Ibe, who both should have started.
Mignolet (5) Didn't have much to do, but almost visibly shits himself when crosses come into the box, and his kicking was predictably shite as usual.
Toure (6) There are times his lack of speed and mobility resort in a somewhat unorthodox style of defending, but he was typically whole-hearted. But the fact he's even playing in a game like this for Liverpool says it all.
Sakho (6) A huge, HUGE improvement from his recent displays. When partnered with the equally ragged Toure it's sometimes rather hard to watch, but he made several good clearances and great tackles Still some very silly and careless passing though.
Clyne (6) He was overloaded a couple of times on that side of the pitch, which meant he wasn't able to get forward as much as we needed in the second half, Martial kept him busy.
Moreno (6) Boundless energy and one of the few players we had on the pitch who has genuine pace, but wasted possession and good chances with some slack crossing and decision-making.
Lucas (6) Looked very comfortable and secure in the first half, as he had little to do, but he won the battle with Feillani in the middle. Got a little more flustered in the second as United actually started moving forward and running at him. Didn't really need to be on the pitch and was a mistake to play him with Milner, Can and Henderson all also playing, but he made one super chance with a clever pass to lallana, who obviously wasted it
Henderson (5) Lots of energy, but barndoor shooting and a few too many aimless hoiks up the pitch to nobody at all. Lacked real quality and couldn't dictate the game in any way, but that's never been a real asset of his anyway.
Can (6) Looked the best midfield player on the pitch at times, and also the worst. Forced a superlative stop from the outstanding De Gea. He still manages to look clumsy at times and he does make some strange choices, but he's been in a decent run of form and if he can improve his decision-making, passing and shooting we'll have a player.
Milner (5) He never gives less than a full shift of hard work, but he's not at his best played in this position and he had little attacking threat, bar one or two crosses. Ordinary.
Lallana (4) Another who works hard, without ever actually doing anything that might result in us scoring a goal. He's slow, weak and can't shoot. In fact, he's like that kid in the school playground who looks dead skilful juggling the tennis ball, doing Cruyff turns and 'megging you in the 20-a-side morning break matches, but actually on a pitch, with a proper sized ball and 11v11, is fucking useless. I don't like him at all, and his record for an attacking player is the worst in the ENTIRE division.
Firmino (6) Blah blah "false 9" blah blah. I hate that fucking bollocks. It's accurate in this case, though, because despite what Klopp says, Firmino is very clearly a false 9. i.e. not a striker. He has no pace and isn't a good enough finisher; he lacks the instincts of a goalscorer, and the presence. His touch is nice and he works hard, but he will never get you goals reliably and needs to play with an ACTUAL 9.