[quote author=Fabio link=topic=47619.msg1433486#msg1433486 date=1322429208]
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=47619.msg1433483#msg1433483 date=1322429126]
Do, cos if they're not counting things correctly you'd have to query the value of the stats, Go back and watch his tackle on Silva in the first 15 mins, where he gave away a foul and didn't win the ball.
If they missed that, can you count them as reliable ?
[/quote]
If the stats have no worth, whats the point in arguing over if they're reliable
Did you think lucas was worth the shirt today?
[/quote]
What does a shirt cost these days ? about 50 quid ? Yeah I'd buy him for that.
Why does everyone misinterpret my statements , I didn't say they had no worth. It's too early in the game of stats in football to figure out what stats are useful guides. And to go back to the ones posted earlier in this thread if the stats show Karl Henry as similar to the best DM's in the league, is Henry massively undervalued and underrated or are the stats not counting what makes a good DM (if such things are quantifiable) ?
I think it's the latter.