Would you?
- Thread starter Y1
- Start date
- Latest activity Latest activity:
- Status
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=47904.msg1442985#msg1442985 date=1323787590]
The "I'd take him on a 6 month loan deal" is a proper cop out. You could make an argument to sign anybody on a 6 month loan deal given how little risk you're taking on.
[/quote]
Yeah agree - he is in the dunno quiffers camp!
The "I'd take him on a 6 month loan deal" is a proper cop out. You could make an argument to sign anybody on a 6 month loan deal given how little risk you're taking on.
[/quote]
Yeah agree - he is in the dunno quiffers camp!
Can we have '6 month loan deal' added to the poll please?
[quote author=LadyRed link=topic=47904.msg1442981#msg1442981 date=1323787129]
In truth I'm in the 'why on earth do we do this to ourselves camp?'
[/quote]
Lol.
Salt. Injury. Nuff said. :'(
In truth I'm in the 'why on earth do we do this to ourselves camp?'
[/quote]
Lol.
Salt. Injury. Nuff said. :'(
Update #7
Yes
Y1, Anita, Themn, Mystic, KHL, Peterhague,Spidey (only for 6 month loan deal), Gerry (if it is 15m for 15m, IT is a GOOD deal), Refugee (15 is the max bag of potatoes you can get), Mistabolina
No
Fabio, El Pistol, St George, Mama, Rosco, Binny, Asbo, StevieM
Dunno (Indecisive quiffers and uncommitted campers)
Avvy, K4PM, FFF, spidey
Yes
Y1, Anita, Themn, Mystic, KHL, Peterhague,
No
Fabio, El Pistol, St George, Mama, Rosco, Binny, Asbo, StevieM
Dunno (Indecisive quiffers and uncommitted campers)
Avvy, K4PM, FFF, spidey
S
Squiggles
Guest
[quote author=Gerry_A_Trick link=topic=47904.msg1442706#msg1442706 date=1323769346]
[quote author=refugee link=topic=47904.msg1442704#msg1442704 date=1323769111]
[quote author=Gerry_A_Trick link=topic=47904.msg1442695#msg1442695 date=1323768480]
Carroll is worth maybe 20m.
[/quote]
Do you really think so? I hate to think how much we'd get back for him.
[/quote]
And he's doubtlessly worth more than Torres is.
[/quote]
That's just absolutely mental. Torres is a European Cup winner, World Cup winner, and for a while was one of the best players on the planet.
The other is Andy Carroll - who once scored some goals in the Championship.
Torres is still worth £17-18M and possibly a bit more if the buyers are stupid enough. I can't think of anyone who would pay that for Andy Carroll right now.
[quote author=refugee link=topic=47904.msg1442704#msg1442704 date=1323769111]
[quote author=Gerry_A_Trick link=topic=47904.msg1442695#msg1442695 date=1323768480]
Carroll is worth maybe 20m.
[/quote]
Do you really think so? I hate to think how much we'd get back for him.
[/quote]
And he's doubtlessly worth more than Torres is.
[/quote]
That's just absolutely mental. Torres is a European Cup winner, World Cup winner, and for a while was one of the best players on the planet.
The other is Andy Carroll - who once scored some goals in the Championship.
Torres is still worth £17-18M and possibly a bit more if the buyers are stupid enough. I can't think of anyone who would pay that for Andy Carroll right now.
[quote author=Squiggles link=topic=47904.msg1443003#msg1443003 date=1323788322]
[quote author=Gerry_A_Trick link=topic=47904.msg1442706#msg1442706 date=1323769346]
[quote author=refugee link=topic=47904.msg1442704#msg1442704 date=1323769111]
[quote author=Gerry_A_Trick link=topic=47904.msg1442695#msg1442695 date=1323768480]
Carroll is worth maybe 20m.
[/quote]
Do you really think so? I hate to think how much we'd get back for him.
[/quote]
And he's doubtlessly worth more than Torres is.
[/quote]
That's just absolutely mental. Torres is a European Cup winner, World Cup winner, and for a while was one of the best players on the planet.
[/quote]
So was Ronaldo(Luiz), what's your point?
[quote author=Gerry_A_Trick link=topic=47904.msg1442706#msg1442706 date=1323769346]
[quote author=refugee link=topic=47904.msg1442704#msg1442704 date=1323769111]
[quote author=Gerry_A_Trick link=topic=47904.msg1442695#msg1442695 date=1323768480]
Carroll is worth maybe 20m.
[/quote]
Do you really think so? I hate to think how much we'd get back for him.
[/quote]
And he's doubtlessly worth more than Torres is.
[/quote]
That's just absolutely mental. Torres is a European Cup winner, World Cup winner, and for a while was one of the best players on the planet.
[/quote]
So was Ronaldo(Luiz), what's your point?
[quote author=Squiggles link=topic=47904.msg1443003#msg1443003 date=1323788322]
[quote author=Gerry_A_Trick link=topic=47904.msg1442706#msg1442706 date=1323769346]
[quote author=refugee link=topic=47904.msg1442704#msg1442704 date=1323769111]
[quote author=Gerry_A_Trick link=topic=47904.msg1442695#msg1442695 date=1323768480]
Carroll is worth maybe 20m.
[/quote]
Do you really think so? I hate to think how much we'd get back for him.
[/quote]
And he's doubtlessly worth more than Torres is.
[/quote]
That's just absolutely mental. Torres is a European Cup winner, World Cup winner, and for a while was one of the best players on the planet.
The other is Andy Carroll - who once scored some goals in the Championship.
Torres is still worth £17-18M. I can't think of anyone who would pay that for Andy Carroll right now.
[/quote]
I take that as a yes.
[quote author=Gerry_A_Trick link=topic=47904.msg1442706#msg1442706 date=1323769346]
[quote author=refugee link=topic=47904.msg1442704#msg1442704 date=1323769111]
[quote author=Gerry_A_Trick link=topic=47904.msg1442695#msg1442695 date=1323768480]
Carroll is worth maybe 20m.
[/quote]
Do you really think so? I hate to think how much we'd get back for him.
[/quote]
And he's doubtlessly worth more than Torres is.
[/quote]
That's just absolutely mental. Torres is a European Cup winner, World Cup winner, and for a while was one of the best players on the planet.
The other is Andy Carroll - who once scored some goals in the Championship.
Torres is still worth £17-18M. I can't think of anyone who would pay that for Andy Carroll right now.
[/quote]
I take that as a yes.
I'd swap him for a 28 year old Ronaldo. Can I have that added to the poll. With a buy back clause.
Update #8
Yes
Y1, Anita, Themn, Mystic, KHL, Peterhague, Gerry (if it is 15m for 15m, IT is a GOOD deal), Refugee (15 is the max bag of potatoes you can get), Mistabolina, squeaky
No
Fabio, El Pistol, St George, Mama, Rosco, Binny, Asbo, StevieM
Dunno (Indecisive quiffers and uncommitted campers)
Avvy, K4PM, FFF, spidey
Yes
Y1, Anita, Themn, Mystic, KHL, Peterhague, Gerry (if it is 15m for 15m, IT is a GOOD deal), Refugee (15 is the max bag of potatoes you can get), Mistabolina, squeaky
No
Fabio, El Pistol, St George, Mama, Rosco, Binny, Asbo, StevieM
Dunno (Indecisive quiffers and uncommitted campers)
Avvy, K4PM, FFF, spidey
S
Squiggles
Guest
[quote author=FoxForceFive link=topic=47904.msg1442855#msg1442855 date=1323780595]
The owners bought carroll to put fans ease regards them selling a fans favourite. Had they not have done many fans would have questioned their motives behind the sale and where the money would end up.
[/quote]
This is right and worrying in equal measure. It was as obvious at the time as it was it now that we should have waited until the Summer. Appeasing the fans should never be the priority and especially not before wise footballing decisions.
The owners bought carroll to put fans ease regards them selling a fans favourite. Had they not have done many fans would have questioned their motives behind the sale and where the money would end up.
[/quote]
This is right and worrying in equal measure. It was as obvious at the time as it was it now that we should have waited until the Summer. Appeasing the fans should never be the priority and especially not before wise footballing decisions.
I do still think we could get 18 million for Carroll. He's 22 and English. Scored loads in the right team. Even Darren Bent was 20 odd. Even downing and Henderson...wait I won't add more salt.
[quote author=Mistadobalina link=topic=47904.msg1443012#msg1443012 date=1323788810]
I do still think we could get 18 million for Carroll. He's 22 and English. Scored loads in the right team. Even Darren Bent was 20 odd. Even downing and Henderson...wait I won't add more salt.
[/quote]
Me too.
I do still think we could get 18 million for Carroll. He's 22 and English. Scored loads in the right team. Even Darren Bent was 20 odd. Even downing and Henderson...wait I won't add more salt.
[/quote]
Me too.
Should give city a ring, they would probably pay us 40 for him, just to give it the big 'I am'.
Update #9
Yes
Y1, Anita, Themn, Mystic, KHL, Peterhague, Gerry (if it is 15m for 15m, IT is a GOOD deal), Refugee (15 is the max bag of potatoes you can get), Mistabolina, Squeaky
No
Fabio, El Pistol, St George, Mama, Rosco, Binny, Asbo, StevieM, Hansern
Dunno (Indecisive quiffers and uncommitted campers)
Avvy, K4PM, FFF, spidey
Yes
Y1, Anita, Themn, Mystic, KHL, Peterhague, Gerry (if it is 15m for 15m, IT is a GOOD deal), Refugee (15 is the max bag of potatoes you can get), Mistabolina, Squeaky
No
Fabio, El Pistol, St George, Mama, Rosco, Binny, Asbo, StevieM, Hansern
Dunno (Indecisive quiffers and uncommitted campers)
Avvy, K4PM, FFF, spidey
[quote author=Y1 link=topic=47904.msg1443029#msg1443029 date=1323790670]
Update #9
Yes
Y1, Anita, Themn, Mystic, The Man from Del Monte, KHL, Peterhague, Gerry (if it is 15m for 15m, IT is a GOOD deal), Refugee (15 is the max bag of potatoes you can get), Mistabolina, Squeaky
No
Fabio, El Pistol, St George, Mama, Rosco, Binny, Ulster, Asbo, StevieM, Hansern
Dunno (Indecisive quiffers and uncommitted campers)
Avvy, K4PM, FFF, spidey
[/quote]
Added a couple...
Update #9
Yes
Y1, Anita, Themn, Mystic, The Man from Del Monte, KHL, Peterhague, Gerry (if it is 15m for 15m, IT is a GOOD deal), Refugee (15 is the max bag of potatoes you can get), Mistabolina, Squeaky
No
Fabio, El Pistol, St George, Mama, Rosco, Binny, Ulster, Asbo, StevieM, Hansern
Dunno (Indecisive quiffers and uncommitted campers)
Avvy, K4PM, FFF, spidey
[/quote]
Added a couple...
[quote author=StevieM link=topic=47904.msg1443030#msg1443030 date=1323790924]
[quote author=Y1 link=topic=47904.msg1443029#msg1443029 date=1323790670]
Update #9
Yes
Y1, Anita, Themn, Mystic, The Man from Del Monte, KHL, Peterhague, Gerry (if it is 15m for 15m, IT is a GOOD deal), Refugee (15 is the max bag of potatoes you can get), Mistabolina, Squeaky, Anyone with a Brain
No
Fabio, El Pistol, St George, Mama, Rosco, Binny, Ulster, Asbo, StevieM, Hansern
Dunno (Indecisive quiffers and uncommitted campers)
Avvy, K4PM, FFF, spidey
[/quote]
Added a couple...
[/quote]
Made some additions too.
[quote author=Y1 link=topic=47904.msg1443029#msg1443029 date=1323790670]
Update #9
Yes
Y1, Anita, Themn, Mystic, The Man from Del Monte, KHL, Peterhague, Gerry (if it is 15m for 15m, IT is a GOOD deal), Refugee (15 is the max bag of potatoes you can get), Mistabolina, Squeaky, Anyone with a Brain
No
Fabio, El Pistol, St George, Mama, Rosco, Binny, Ulster, Asbo, StevieM, Hansern
Dunno (Indecisive quiffers and uncommitted campers)
Avvy, K4PM, FFF, spidey
[/quote]
Added a couple...
[/quote]
Made some additions too.
[quote author=Mystic link=topic=47904.msg1443039#msg1443039 date=1323791845]
[quote author=StevieM link=topic=47904.msg1443030#msg1443030 date=1323790924]
[quote author=Y1 link=topic=47904.msg1443029#msg1443029 date=1323790670]
Update #9
Yes
Y1, Anita, Themn, Mystic, The Man from Del Monte, KHL, Peterhague, Gerry (if it is 15m for 15m, IT is a GOOD deal), Refugee (15 is the max bag of potatoes you can get), Mistabolina, Squeaky, Anyone with a Brain
No
Fabio, El Pistol, St George, Mama, Rosco, Binny, Ulster, Asbo, StevieM, Hansern
Dunno (Indecisive quiffers and uncommitted campers)
Avvy, K4PM, FFF, spidey
[/quote]
Added a couple...
[/quote]
Made some additions too.
[/quote]
tut tut italicised
[quote author=StevieM link=topic=47904.msg1443030#msg1443030 date=1323790924]
[quote author=Y1 link=topic=47904.msg1443029#msg1443029 date=1323790670]
Update #9
Yes
Y1, Anita, Themn, Mystic, The Man from Del Monte, KHL, Peterhague, Gerry (if it is 15m for 15m, IT is a GOOD deal), Refugee (15 is the max bag of potatoes you can get), Mistabolina, Squeaky, Anyone with a Brain
No
Fabio, El Pistol, St George, Mama, Rosco, Binny, Ulster, Asbo, StevieM, Hansern
Dunno (Indecisive quiffers and uncommitted campers)
Avvy, K4PM, FFF, spidey
[/quote]
Added a couple...
[/quote]
Made some additions too.
[/quote]
tut tut italicised
S
Squiggles
Guest
I'd swap Torres for Carroll right now.
El Judas
Appaz Chelsea are looking to defo get rid in January.. Article in the papers tomorrow, they will listen to offers come January..
Twitter is mad on it at the mo, 20 mill. ? Surely not... ???
At that price, I'd defo have him back.. However its more likely he will go abroad me thinks..
Appaz Chelsea are looking to defo get rid in January.. Article in the papers tomorrow, they will listen to offers come January..
Twitter is mad on it at the mo, 20 mill. ? Surely not... ???
At that price, I'd defo have him back.. However its more likely he will go abroad me thinks..
Re: El Judas
Buy him, sell Carroll back to Newcastle for 15 mill, happy days..
Chelsea lose, we win despite being robbed by Newcastle... lol
Still I Wrekon the Judas is homesick, however only 2 clubs in Spain that could afford him... Neither would want him...
Buy him, sell Carroll back to Newcastle for 15 mill, happy days..
Chelsea lose, we win despite being robbed by Newcastle... lol
Still I Wrekon the Judas is homesick, however only 2 clubs in Spain that could afford him... Neither would want him...
- Status
