True, well maybe.
When a miracle occurs in a manager's first season the way it did in 2005 you automatically get afforded time unless you're Chelsea.
I enjoyed us being feared more than most in Europe. We didn't have that since the eighties, and nor have we had it since Rafa's final season.
We can always use the domestic league to critcise Rafa (and Gerard) but he gave us something we didn't imagine possible and for that he deserves more credit than any other manager since Kenny's first reign. At least for me. Vlad?
Well there's the crux of the answer about Ged, he didn't get 5 years just because he said he had a 5 year plan. He got it because he put us back on the map, won silverware and finished 2nd. And he deserves credit for that, not mocking because it wasn't the Champions League. Similar to the way Bob continued and eclipsed the good work and foundations that Shankly started, they both deserve the credit in helping stabilise the club and establishing it's reputation again in Europe. Neither without their faults, which like with many managers, eventually became their undoing. They're the best two managers we've had at the club since Kenny's original stint and about as close as we've got, all be it fleetingly, to getting back near the top of the pack.