For those that rate him and think he will be a good player for us. Where do you think he should play and in what formation. Is he going to get games as an attacking mid ahead of Coutinho Firmino and Lallana? Probably not.
There are clearly some concerns about his work ethic and stamina. I think to make it with us he would have to up his game by about 25% and I don't think hes capable of that. It wasnt the physicality of the league that intimidated him when he started with us, it was how much higher the standard was.
I don't think he'll get games, that's the main reason I'm open to a loan. The worst thing for him and us is just letting him rot for a season.
Your criticisms almost seem to be generated at random. Poor work ethic? Do you have evidence? I'd have thought his eager attempts to adapt to an unfamiliar and unglamorous position suggest otherwise. Lack of stamina? Possibly but again not the first thing I'd notice. He looks a naturally fit person to me, so any current deficit is bound to be rectified as he matures. However, I'm not convinced that it is actually a problem. I don't particularly remember him tiring in lots of games - what examples are there?
Why don't you think he's capable of upping his game? Laziness? If so, why?
Why do you think the standard rather than the physicality or pace of the league so troubled him? Particularly given your criticisms suggesting a belief in his poor physical condition? For me his worst performance was probably in the Derby at Anfield, and that's not a game renowned for its relentless footballing quality! Moreover, in his very first appearance for us, as a sub against Man City at the Etihad (probably the best football team in the league) he looked immediately comfortable.