• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Who wins?

Status
Not open for further replies.
That team with Hyppia, Mascherano, Alonso, peak Gerrard and Torres would absolutely destroy them. If it weren't for injuries and the lack of a bench we would have won the league.
People tend to forget that Torres and Gerrard missed like 10 league games that season.
Edit: Torres 14, Gerrard 7.

That team was ridiculous. No depth but that first 11. Wow.
 
klopps team.
id love to see. Rodgers side cope with the pressing and movement of this side . Sure Suarez would make and score a goal out of the blue but it wouldn't be enough
 
It's hard to say. This side doesn't have a big goal scorer, Rodgers side had Suarez AND a peak Sturridge. It's tough to label that side a one man team because Sturridge, Henderson, Coutinho, Gerrard and even the likes of Enrique chipped in with goals. We pressed then too as a team.

Someone said that team had to win by clear margins, isn't that the case with this team? Both sides had their share of narrow results but also many games like the one at the weekend. As for Suarez carrying us, we can argue that Mane has been a catalyst for this side too. Goals against isn't too far off being the same, but I do feel we're a bit better defensively organised in open play, while our inability to defend set pieces continues to hinder us - we're just less likely to get caught on the break, as Rodgers's side often did.

One obvious like for like in both sides is Gerrard for Milner, both are worth their weight in gold for pens and set pieces.
 
Suarez versus Klopp.

I reckon the game would be a coin toss but I'm happy we're moving forward with the current set up.

Imagine Suarez in a Klopp team though......

*drools*
 
A one off head to head game could go either way. I'd probably bet on a 4-4.

A more interesting question is which team would you rather have for a league campaign.

It remains to be seen if Klopp can go as close (or better) than Rodgers team. However I'd still put my money on Klopp.

Suarez was as likely to do something stupid and be banned as he was to do something brilliant. Likewise Sturridge was as likely to be injured.
 
I would give my right arm to get Suarez back, I'd go with Rodgers' team purely for the Suarez effect.

On a side note that 08/09 first 11 was un-fucking real.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom