Podolski is clearly better. To not fit into Bayern Munichs bunch of psychopats doesn't proof your mentally weak does it? Podolski is a star signing and one we should have done. Fantastic player with a killer instinct. And with almost 1000 games for Germany, and being club idol and captian in Cologne I can't see that Dempseys experience is worth more? Maybe he is better in the air. So is Andy Carrol. I wouldn't rate Andy better than Podolsky based on that one.
Bayern has never been the easiest of clubs to fit into, but plenty have managed it. In any case the problem wasn't so much Bayern itself but the fact that Podolski was lost away from 1.FC Koln. I'm far from convinced that he's any better equipped for the move to the Arse now.
Let's agree to differ about whether Podolski's better than Dempsey. Leaving aside the fact that 1000 games for Germany would mean he must have won his first cap somewhere around the time of the First World War 😉, his becoming club captain and idol in familiar surroundings doesn't seem to me to mean much at all, especially when his only previous attempt to move elsewhere came to grief - in contrast to Dempsey who's made a success of things in a totally different country. Dempsey's also better out on the left, where Podolski's never done anything worthwhile - his left foot's for shooting, not crossing. Dempsey's also a lot less one-footed. I'm confident Dempsey will score more goals per game played than Podolski if he signs for us for next season.