Shaw should be in the squad but Hodgson likes his "oldies" and his Fulham boy Smalling apparently.
Can't blame him if he takes Cole though. By all accounts I've read, Cole did well yesterday (I didn't watch the game), so he seems to still be able to perform at this level. And as long as he does that, his experience will give him an edge. It's easy to say play the youngsters, but facing a crunch elimination game, would fans really feel comfortable with an 18-year-old leftback in his first major tournament in a cauldron of fire? As long as the "oldie" is still capable of playing at a very good level, he'd be as good a pick as a fresher youngster, if not better, because of his experience.