• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Skittles skiddaddling?

Status
Not open for further replies.
But he's better than Evans who is a manure regular which makes him good enough for manure. He played better than Kompany last season which makes him good enough for city as well. Not to mention Mertezacker(sp?) which makes him good enough for arsenal as well.
Opinions...with which I don't agree. I'd swap Skrtel for any of the players you've listed there.
 
John Aldridge ✔@Realaldo474
Need to get skrtel signed-not a massive fan!but he's the best of what we've got at the back!!

[article=http://www1.skysports.com/football/news/11669/9875239/james-milner-should-be-given-a-central-role-at-liverpool-says-phil-thompson?]Meanwhile, Martin Skrtel has reportedly labelled Liverpool’s latest offer of a contract extension as “unacceptable,” and Thompson believes the club must now focus on tying the Slovakian down.

“The deal just needs to be done correctly – it seems strange how it’s being done,” he said.

“Skrtel has been one of Liverpool’s most important players and the club should be moving things on as soon as possible.”[/article]
 
So even if we can improve on him it would be pointless to let him go?

Yeah, because if the other defenders aren't up to standard and he's the best of the bunch, then it makes sense that as far as pecking orders go, he's the last one to be replaced, on current form anyway. I'd rather have Skrtel as an option than any of the others, he's a good defender.

Argue whether he's good enough, but when he played alongside Hyypia he was, we've nearly won the title with him in the side twice, so he's clearly good enough with the right players around him. Last season we were poor defensively, but he wasn't a big culprit and at the other end of the pitch he was the top scoring defender in the league.

He needs the right partner and at the same time, we need a quality leader at the back. Lovren is poor, Sakho has looked good in fits and starts, Toure is neither here nor there, good for the dressing room and the odd game.
 
All of our defenders will look better if they are unburdened of this need to' play out from the back' and have a competent DM in front of them. I don't think they're bad defenders they just tend to be busier than they should be as they are unprotected, The more work they have to do the more likely the mistakes. They are being made to play in ways that don't suit them. Few of them are good passers or visionary, so bypass them, just let them concentrate on defending if they need to.
 
He's not going to get any better so if he doesn't sign this contract it'll not be any loss.


My feelings more or less. I think it will be a loss in the short-term because he is our most dependable defender and for that reason it's probably better to keep him but if he ends up going you'd like to think that we could get someone in to replace him and that that someone will be younger and cheaper.;
 
He's a reactive defender. Pretty much the polar opposite to the likes of Ferdinand, Terry, Hyypia, Hansen, etc, all of whom commuted about 10 last ditch slide tackles in their career.

Skrtel does that in the first half.
He's not going to get any better so if he doesn't sign this contract it'll not be any loss.



I hope your not going to turn this into a campain re Suarez. We need him desperately at the moment and he knows it .
If we lose Skirtel now. ..... ... ... .. We will not make fourth.

How much will that cost us.
 
[article]“I am still waiting for the new contract,” he told Slovakian media agency Aktualne ahead of Slovakia’s European Qualifier against Macedonia.

“I think a contract like this is offered to players who are much older than me or to players who have had some health complications. But I feel good and not so old to sign this contract.

“Also I think my health is OK. The contract offered is unacceptable for me. This is the reason why I didn’t sign it.

“I still have a contract running with the club. There was some speculation about interest from other clubs but that is not coming from me. Now I am with the national team and will be going on holiday after that.”[/article]
 
All of our defenders will look better if they are unburdened of this need to' play out from the back' and have a competent DM in front of them. I don't think they're bad defenders they just tend to be busier than they should be as they are unprotected, The more work they have to do the more likely the mistakes. They are being made to play in ways that don't suit them. Few of them are good passers or visionary, so bypass them, just let them concentrate on defending if they need to.

Wouldn't even say it's the play out from the back lark, it's the play out from the back while the nearest players to you are 30 yards in every direction. There's nothing wrong with playing out from the back (but punting when you need to), it's the sheer stretching of our defense which is the real crux of our fuck ups.
 
I think its madness to loose a leading figure of a fragile defence.... He is a good rolemodell and a good pro and must be valuable to the squad. We cant defend as a unit but Skrtel is not afraid to dig in when needed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom