That's not strictly true. He had some very impressive seasons for us and was voted player of the year one season.
He never was the most assured and could be nervy as fuck. When the whole team defended badly he wasn't able to steady it and only added to the chaos, but I do not think it's fair for anyone's worst performances to define their legacy.
He had a couple of good seasons. One of those he did his cruciate in halfway through.
The rest of the time he was horribly inconsistent and rash. It was no wonder we never really had any success while he (and Lucas) were here.