[quote author=Ryan link=topic=36858.msg976862#msg976862 date=1257113713]
Hmmm, it's an interesting one alright. But, as you've both done extremely well, making an ultimate decision on GlenJo and Aquilani as summer signings after 2 and a half months is the correct way to form an analysis.
[/quote]
It isn't really an analysis of either player, to be fair. I haven't made any sort of judgment on Aquilani yet, but if both players end up incremental improvements on their predecessors, and Johnson doees, it already looks to be something that would pay off next year, rather than this. Rafa shouldn't have been forced to gamble in that way, especially after that year, but nevertheless he gambled on his confidence in Lucas-Mascherano as a CM partnership, and gambled on a level of patience for development which as we've seen, amongst most is in short supply.
As I said, it's difficult to evaluate Rafa's decision, when we simply don't know what he knew when, but something doesn't add up.