[quote author=Vlads Quiff link=topic=38446.msg1033519#msg1033519 date=1263464497]
Anyone who writes him off is a fool, I think he does have potential, but I also think people can have concerns about his future ability to cope with the premier league. I think we can also question the wisdom in buying a player for a key position who partly due to buying as damaged goods was always going to take at least a season to settle in.
For that I don't even think "the worst signing of the summer " tag is particularly unreasonable.
regards
[/quote]
To be honest the statement of "Worst signing of the summer" came from a thread where Rednapp (I think) named him as the worst. As many posters in the thread pointed out, it had nothing to do with how good he is or how much quality he has and everything to do with the fact he cost nearly 20m and didn't play a game in the first half of the season - you can't get much worse than that.
The Midfield Morientes, as brendan says, could stick and that would be unfair because he hasn't had the time to present what he can do. However, even if he is an utter star next season and becomes a Kop legend down through the ages, he's still the worst or close to the worst signing for this season. You don't sell an outstanding player who sits in an absolutely pivotal role for your playing style, replace him with a long term injured player and not expect serious repercussions.
I for one did not expect them to be as serious as we've had but I was not alone in the summer saying that Xabi's departure without an immediate playing replacement is going to cause some real issues.