• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

When an anti-racism campaign is racist

Status
Not open for further replies.

bluebell

Very Well-Known
Member
Serie A anti-racism campaign: Monkey artwork condemned by AC Milan and Roma


Sharethis page
_110191132_monkey.jpg

Serie A chief executive Luigi de Siervo (left) and artist Simone Fugazzotto reveal the artwork at a news conference on Monday
AC Milan say they "strongly disagree" with and were not consulted about the use of monkeys in artwork for a Serie A anti-racism campaign.
The 'No To Racism' posters show three monkeys with painted faces.
It comes less than three weeks after clubs pledged to combat Italian football's "serious problem".
"Art can be powerful, but we strongly disagree with the use of monkeys as images in the fight against racism," said an AC Milan statement.
The club added they were "surprised by the total lack of consultation" over the artwork, which will be displayed at Serie A headquarters in Milan.
AS Roma also expressed their "surprise", adding: "We understand the league wants to tackle racism but we don't believe this is the right way to do it."
AC Milan​
@acmilan​
Art can be powerful, but we strongly disagree with the use of monkeys as images in the fight against racism and were surprised by the total lack of consultation. @SerieA_EN

2,273 people are talking about this


Report
Former Premier League defender Sylvain Distin says he does not understand "how you can fight racism with something that looks like racism".
"It just doesn't make any sense to me, to the point that I went and tried to read as many interviews with the artist as I could," Distin told BBC Radio 5 Live.
"It's true that he did a lot of portraits and painting and art around monkeys for five or six years and, from what the artist was saying, it was just his way to say that we are all monkeys - but it just doesn't look right.
"I just really don't get it. Are they trying to make things so big that all the little incidents that happen every weekend in Italy just look normal? I don't understand what they expect, what kind of reaction do you expect with this kind of act? I just don't get it, I don't see the point."
At a news conference on Monday, artist Simone Fugazzotto, who always uses monkeys in his work, said: "For an artist there is nothing more important than trying to change the perception of things through his own work.
"I decided to portray monkeys to talk about racism because they are the metaphor for human beings. Last year I was at the stadium to see Inter v Napoli [a match in which Napoli defender Kalidou Koulibaly was racially abused] and I felt humiliated, everyone was shouting 'monkey' at Koulibaly, a player I respect.
"I've always been painting monkeys for five to six years, so I thought I'd make this work to teach that we're all apes. I made the western monkey with blue and white eyes, the Asian monkey with almond-shaped eyes and the black monkey positioned in the centre, where everything comes from.
"The monkey becomes the spark to teach everyone that there is no difference, there is no man or monkey, we are all alike. If anything we are all monkeys."
AS Roma English​
@ASRomaEN​
#ASRoma was very surprised to see what appears to be an anti-racist campaign from Serie A featuring painted monkeys on social media today. We understand the league wants to tackle racism but we don’t believe this is the right way to do it.​

3,561 people are talking about this


Report
Anti-discriminatory body Fare said it was left "speechless" and the campaign looked like a "sick joke", while Kick It Out added the use of monkeys was "completely inappropriate".
Serie A chief executive Luigi de Siervo said the league's commitment against all forms of prejudice was "strong and concrete".
He added: "We know that racism is an endemic and very complex problem, which we will tackle on three different levels: the cultural one, through works like that of Simone; the sporting one, with a series of initiatives together with clubs and players; and the repressive one, thanks to collaboration with the police."
In November, Brescia's Mario Balotelli called fans who shouted racist abuse at him "small-minded" and "imbeciles".
Inter Milan's Romelu Lukaku said the abuse he suffered in September, when Cagliari fans made monkey noises after the Belgian scored a penalty against their team, showed the game was "going backwards".
The Sardinian club were later cleared of racist chanting, leading the head of Fare to say that Italian football authorities and their disciplinary systems to combat racism were "not fit for purpose".
This month Italian newspaper Corriere dello Sport was criticised for the headline 'Black Friday' alongside images of Roma defender Chris Smalling and Inter striker Lukaku prior to a match between the sides.
 
Last edited:
Uncle Donnie across the pond would have been proud of them. Calling them a bunch of dumbasses would have been an ultimate understatement of the year.
 
Just about everything can get fucked so fucking hard right now. The nineties never happened. We're back where we started. Fuck this shit.
 
I don't think anybody is attending to the words of the artist in all this, where there is actually an interesting rationale along the lines of apes are a metaphor for all people of all races and creeds, and thus the artist is attempting to explode any power of a simple-minded association of monkeys with people of certain races. His motivations are certainly anti-racist. However, given footy fans and pundits have never shown any signs of being capable of thinking deeply about art, and that there is the long standing association of monkeys with racism (which he is trying to deconstruct), this was obviously very, very ill-advised as a commission.
 
I think it's beyond ill advised. When the guys in the boardroom realised they were under pressure to do something and someone suggested they get the monkey guy in, I'm sure there were laughs and high fives all round.
 
I think it's beyond ill advised. When the guys in the boardroom realised they were under pressure to do something and someone suggested they get the monkey guy in, I'm sure there were laughs and high fives all round.
Hmmm, you might be right.
 
Just think about it. Any rational sane non racist involved in that decision making process would have vetoed it on day one. If it had landed on my desk as a proposal I'd have bollocked whichever dick thought it was funny. It's not just ill advised at all
 
This is fucking terrible. If it was in Dave Basset England or Goal I’d think it was stupidly unrealistic.

How the fuck did it get past a brain storming session?
 
I don't think anybody is attending to the words of the artist in all this, where there is actually an interesting rationale along the lines of apes are a metaphor for all people of all races and creeds, and thus the artist is attempting to explode any power of a simple-minded association of monkeys with people of certain races. His motivations are certainly anti-racist. However, given footy fans and pundits have never shown any signs of being capable of thinking deeply about art, and that there is the long standing association of monkeys with racism (which he is trying to deconstruct), this was obviously very, very ill-advised as a commission.
Never mind the media .....
 
Not to be the pedantic one, but, the artwork looks more like apes than monkeys to me...

Not that that makes it any better. I don't think the artist intended his work to be offensive... And it probably shouldn't be, this is a case of "stupid humans" giving non offensive things offensive meanings. We are all equally closely related to our ape ancestors and are all apes.



* Italian may not have separate words for Ape and Monkey, not all languages do.
 
Hahahahahahahahahahahaha!

I'm not sure if I'd be more astounded and dismayed if it had been done on purpose, or was genuinely a catastrophic, multiple and embarrassing error of judgement
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom