so what's the text book answer ? Does it not depend on alot more factors than them just playing 4-5-1 ...like how far up are their wide players playing , how are the middle 3 setup , how fast is their main striker etc etc .
Well there is no textbook answer. That said there are still more wrong things to do than right things, but you've got to be able to stand up, present your case as to what you'd do, and argue it rationally. If you don't know what you're talking about or propose something absurd, you'll fail.
There are though about half a dozen things that you absolutely must do in that situation, and if you don't point them out you're largely fucked.
- Notice the clues in the scenario; 1)15 mins to go to half-time, so get your side set up to handle the 15 minutes, and then you can get them in, talk to them, re-set the side, etc. 2) They're playing 5 in the middle so when you do get the ball, attack down the wings. Shift the pacier of your two strikers to the wing and instruct him to gain yardage everytime you attack.
- Narrow the gaps between your 3 (or 4) lines. Effectively condense the space between your lines of defenders, forwards, midfielders, so you're one tight block shifting around the pitch.
- Let their defenders have the ball and let them pass it around at the back. No point in expanding the little energy you'll have.
- Slow the game down. Take an age over throw-in's, goalkicks, etc.
- Play your striker in the hole. Waste of time having him up on the last line of defenders because your midfield will be deep, and you're just increasing the gap.
- Break the game into 15-20 minute gaps, all that usual shit.
After that, you can argue the case for whatever formation you like, but if you don't get components of the above in place, you're done.