Just been reading the possible punishments and none was to forfeit the titles they won while cheating.
When Australian Rugby League team Melbourne Storm, who had dominated the game in Australia, were found to have breached salary cap regulations, they were stripped of the titles they won.
I don’t follow the sport closely enough or care whether the runners up got the titles.
It didn’t really stop Storm being very successful - but it’s also a closed league, so no relegation.
For me there have to be past and future consequences if they’re found guilty - otherwise, make it what it is - a business with no sporting integrity.
If they’re really smart, the Premier League have a chance to stop the league becoming the same as every other major league in Europe - dominated by 1 or 2 teams or just corrupt like Italy.
I’d love to see more teams with a realistic chance of winning the league, even if meant we didn’t.
I think I’ve come up with a fair punishment. This should also include an investigation into the seasons after 2018 to see whether any further breach have occurred.
- forfeit of every trophy win during the period with trophies represented to runners up.
- fine of £1m for every point gained in the League during the period, to be distributed amongst all clubs that played against them in the league based on amount of games played against Mancheatster Shitty.
- additional fine of 100% of all Premier League, FA Cup & League Cup prize money earned in the total period to be distributed to the FA & Premier League and used to fund grass roots initiatives.
- barred from playing in the Premier League, FA Cup & League Cup for 1 season for each season they committed an offence.
- Barred from signing any players or renewing any contracts of existing players for one season for every season they were found to have committed an offence.
- All current players to be allowed to leave on a free if they so desire.
- expulsion from the Premier League, in addition to the 3 teams expected to be relegated with a one-off play-off between the team finishing 17th in the Premier League & the losing Championship play-off finalist.
- Emptyiad stadium lease to be cancelled with immediate effect and where ever they are allowed to play games, no too ket charges for away fans for one season for every season they committed an offence.
- Shirt sponsorship to be cancelled with immediate effect to be replaced with the slogan “CHEATERS NEVER PROSPER” for one year for each season they have committed an offence.
- the lyrics of Hey Jude played before every game to be changed to :
“Hey Jurg, you’re right, we were bad.
We need a sad song where we’re a cheater.
Remember only when we’re sorry from our heart,
Then we can start to make it better.”
That’ll do for starters.
To be fair City have already handed back every trophy they won in Europe over the period of their cheating - to their credit.
They’d be setting a precedent for everyone to do the same and if caught still keep their spoils.Closer to home and more recently, Saracens breached the cap 3 times in a row, won 4 out of 5 titles similar to City..
They were relegated, but kept their titles.
I expect a similar 'deal' may be reached with City, back to the Championship for a year.
Tainted titles... yes... Will it make a difference? No.
Saracens were back up within a year.
Only way it'd work would be to have a Juve style sanction, and the Premier League won't have the bollocks for that.
One of the possible punishments is that the they can decide a punishment... So nothing is off the table as suchJust been reading the possible punishments and none was to forfeit the titles they won while cheating.
There’s a clause that allows the commission to hand out whatever punishment they believe is appropriate (the sanctions mentioned are basically indicative). Also worth noting that even if the commission doesn’t eject them from the League, the other teams can vote to chuck them out (think it needs 15 teams to agree, from memory - I looked at it over the Superleague fiasco).Just been reading the possible punishments and none was to forfeit the titles they won while cheating.
You Expained it better 😉There’s a clause that allows the commission to hand out whatever punishment they believe is appropriate (the sanctions mentioned are basically indicative). Also worth noting that even if the commission doesn’t eject them from the League, the other teams can vote to chuck them out (think it needs 15 teams to agree, from memory - I looked at it over the Superleague fiasco).
EDIT - whooshed by @Irishanfield - sorry mate!
I know some fans would be jumping around and having a wank if we were given retrospective titles but they would bring me no joy... Just void the winnersIt's very unlikely we'll be given any retrospective titles should they be found guilty.
But at a minimum I would want to see their titles stripped from them and the season considered void.
Otherwise, you basically just green light cheating, if you get to keep your ill-gotten gains.
To think, if City have indeed cheated. They've effectively cheated us out of 3 titles, 100+pts potentially and an unbeaten season.
Relegation and title stripping is the minimum expected punishment.
Lol. I'm just trying to do the whole "innocent until proven guilty", but it's been obvious, hasn't it?If they cheated? We know they cheated. We just don't know whether they'll get away with it again.
To think, if City have indeed cheated. They've effectively cheated us out of 3 titles, 100+pts potentially and an unbeaten season.
Relegation and title stripping is the minimum expected punishment.
There's no way he doesn't know what's happening here ...
And they also have to buy us Bellingham.