[quote author=Rosco link=topic=36552.msg967463#msg967463 date=1256107110]
[quote author=Ryan link=topic=36552.msg967351#msg967351 date=1256080420]
To me, these threads don't exemplify the pressure Rafa's under, they just highlight the amount of plastic, fly-by-night fans that are out there. There's a reason why a lot of the Forum's better posters are either offline tonight, or not bothering to post. What's the fucking point in getting caught up in this maelstrom? It's just thread after thread of kneejerk, zero objectivity, and short-sighted support.
Rafa's not become a bad manager overnight. He's not all of a sudden 'shit'. He's won La Liga twice, taken a balls team to two Champions League Finals, and finished last season with 86 points and 2 defeats despite having to play the majority of the season without his best striker. He's clearly capable of constructing a side that can go out and win, so to get all uppity after losing some games on the bounce in October doesn't really promote your nous, it just highlights you as a kneejerking fool with no real bigger picture perspective.
He lost his 2 best players to injuries sustained on International duty. 3 if you include Mascherano's fatigue. Does anyone really think we'd have lost those games had Gerrard and Torres been in the side? How's it Rafa's fault if Gerrard sustains an injury against Sweden? Similarly, when a ball canoons in off a beach ball, it'd be natural to suspect that you're not really getting the rub of the green eh? Not a jot of it, "he's lost the dressing room!" Far be it from me to question the shrinks that masquerade on this forum as posters, who am I to question their expert insight when despite Gerrard, Carragher and Torres queuing up to laud Bentiez's skills as a manager, the fucking experts on here know that that's all bullshit, and really "no one in the squad actually likes Rafa!"
As per usual; the louder you shout, the more capitals you put in your thread, the uglier the picture you present - the further from the truth you actually get. Do carry on.
[/quote]
Is he ?
The Valencia team he succeeded with was largely there before him, so was the team he won the CL with here.
Our problem is that over the past few years the players he's sold seem to be better than the ones he's replaced them with and that's why we have a piss poor squad right now. Add to the fact that he seems to have a penchant for signing injury prone players (Aurelio, Degen, Agger, Aquilani) and it's no surprise that we're struggling.
[/quote]
I think so, yeah. I'm not sure I altogethor agree with your assertion that "the players he's sold seem to be better than the one's he's replaced them with" either. I suppose you could break it down to position by position, player by player, but i can't be arsed and I'm sure you couldn't either. After briefly thinking about it I'd say, he has (for the most part) got one significantly better player in some positions (Torres over Cisse, Kuyt over Pennant, Johnson over Finnan / Arbeloa, Alonso over Murphy, Reina over Dudek) then he's replaced some older players with similarly good ones (Mascherano replacing Hamman, Riera replacing Kewell, Skrtel/Agger to take over from Sami, etc etc). Obviously some positions he hasn't improved upon, but by and large he's done ok. The problem with all of this, and probably where you're coming from is that yes he's added quality, but not quality in depth. After Torres, we've got fuck all, whereas maybe a few years ago we had Cisse, Crouch, Bellamy, Morientes, etc.
As for signing "injured players" well, every manager does. Some get lucky with them, some don't. Ferguson signed Van Nistelrooy when he was fucked, Hargreaves, gambled on Owen, has persevered with the perenially injured Brown, Neville, Scholes, etc. Wenger's bought players with a dodgy injury reputation too; Rosicky, Silvestre, Diaby, etc It happens to most clubs and all Managers, it just gets highlighted with us more because we don't have good enough depth to cover, and because we scrutinise it to a greater degree obviously.
Oh, and have you read David Conn's articles in the Guardian on the Leeds United ownership issue. You really should, very interesting and right up your street.