• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

sack Rafa

Status
Not open for further replies.
[quote author=Delinquent link=topic=38437.msg1033749#msg1033749 date=1263477315]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=38437.msg1033744#msg1033744 date=1263477144]
[quote author=Stu link=topic=38437.msg1033727#msg1033727 date=1263476206]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=38437.msg1033723#msg1033723 date=1263476099]
A top 4 finish or a Ufea cup win should be enough keep Rafa in his job.
[/quote]

I think it ALL comes down to a top four finish mate.
Even if we win the tin pot and finish 5th, he'll be offski.
[/quote]

Thats probably true Stu.

I still think people need to seriously consider who we're likely to end up with as a replacement though. Its all well and good shouting "Rafa out", but the viable alternatives are very limited.
[/quote]

Someone who has a basic understanding of how this league works and how to motivate his team would be an improvement right now. I'd take a number of Premier League managers over Rafa. Sure, we should try to get the best replacement necessary but we shouldn't settle for mediocrity out of a fear of failure. We're failing in every department right now.
[/quote]

Who are all of these Premier League Managers you'd take then Del?
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033746#msg1033746 date=1263477176]
[quote author=Stu link=topic=38437.msg1033740#msg1033740 date=1263476909]
Rebel, stop all the bullshit and tell us what Rafa would have to do to get fired.
Simple question.
[/quote]

he needs to show that he can turn it around and I think he will not just now but in the long term

[/quote]

No, he needs to show that we can compete from day one of the season, not show that he can dig us a hole and then climb out of it. He's managed it once in six years, and that's just not good enough I'm afraid.
 
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=38437.msg1033752#msg1033752 date=1263477418]
[quote author=Delinquent link=topic=38437.msg1033749#msg1033749 date=1263477315]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=38437.msg1033744#msg1033744 date=1263477144]
[quote author=Stu link=topic=38437.msg1033727#msg1033727 date=1263476206]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=38437.msg1033723#msg1033723 date=1263476099]
A top 4 finish or a Ufea cup win should be enough keep Rafa in his job.
[/quote]

I think it ALL comes down to a top four finish mate.
Even if we win the tin pot and finish 5th, he'll be offski.
[/quote]

Thats probably true Stu.

I still think people need to seriously consider who we're likely to end up with as a replacement though. Its all well and good shouting "Rafa out", but the viable alternatives are very limited.
[/quote]

Someone who has a basic understanding of how this league works and how to motivate his team would be an improvement right now. I'd take a number of Premier League managers over Rafa. Sure, we should try to get the best replacement necessary but we shouldn't settle for mediocrity out of a fear of failure. We're failing in every department right now.
[/quote]

Who are all of these Premier League Managers you'd take then Del?
[/quote]
That's a very good question indeed.

Roy Hodgson? Redknapp?
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033750#msg1033750 date=1263477321]

So 5 seasons in the CL is failure, a European cup is a failure, this is delusion on a scale of Newcastle United and since we can't give our current european cup winning manager the resources to do the job, we should sack him and hire someone with a worse record and expect him to do the job. I'm sure with an attitude like that we'll be where Newcastle is before long



[/quote]

I have been deliberately staying out of the footy forum this season, because it's too fucking grim, but this angers me too much to stay schtum.

"Delusion on a scale of Newcastle"?

Rebel, this isn't the first time I've had to remind you of this.

We are LIVERPOOL FUCKING FOOTBALL CLUB.

*THE* most successful team this country has *ever* produced.

FUCK OFF YOU FUCKING LOSER
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033750#msg1033750 date=1263477321]
[quote author=Niall K link=topic=38437.msg1033743#msg1033743 date=1263477115]
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033737#msg1033737 date=1263476763]
[quote author=Niall K link=topic=38437.msg1033721#msg1033721 date=1263476048]
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033709#msg1033709 date=1263475328]
[quote author=Le Chacal link=topic=38437.msg1033699#msg1033699 date=1263475051]
Any old managers?
I like it when Rebel assumes the yanks would hire someone like Curbishley.

Mourinho, Rijkard are not that old you know.

Rebel and KHL defending our manager after that debacle.
6 years in charge and worst season.

Not sacking Rafa would be another mistake on both football and business perspective from the board.
They should never have given him such a good contract in the first place but I'd rather lose £15M now
Keeping Rafa could cost us £50M next season
[/quote]

Losing £15m would be a disaster and if you believe Mourinho would take a massive paycut and come and work for two broke yanks then more fool you. The actions you and your fellow kneejerkers are advocating could sink the club

[/quote]

Your constant use of the word "kneejerkers" is annoying.

He'd have been sacked at any other club bar ours now given that HIS group of players bear no resemblance to a top level side this season. Our performances and results have been shocking and the only thing that can be taken from them is that they are actually getting worse instead of improving. Yes players have to take their share of the blame but he's paid to get the most he can out of them and he is getting precisely nothing.

We're a mess on the field and the buck stops with him
[/quote]

THIS SEASON, THIS SEASON

Last season we were title contenders, so what is evaluations based on just a season worth? You have to look at what;s best for the club and the overall record of the manager, not just a result or a season in isolation. Though with the way the media are and some fans this is difficult you have to have belief in the caliber of the man, most of the managers they could appoint wouldnt last minutes in the job with the pressure and no resources so the continual sacking and hiring of managers would seriously damage us further and could see us sunk into the abyss like Newcastle, Leeds etc.
[/quote]

Since you dont want to evaluate our performances based upon this season alone allow me to put this forward.

We've gone close to winning the league once under him which was indeed last season.

So when our league performances are evaluated over all the seasons he's been here one word comes up.... FAIL.
[/quote]

So 5 seasons in the CL is failure, a European cup is a failure, this is delusion on a scale of Newcastle United and since we can't give our current european cup winning manager the resources to do the job, we should sack him and hire someone with a worse record and expect him to do the job. I'm sure with an attitude like that we'll be where Newcastle is before long



[/quote] The way your fucking hero is going about things we may get there sooner than you think
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033741#msg1033741 date=1263477035]


if the players cant be motivated then he needs to root them out and they're ones who need to be sacked/replaced, replacing the manager with a lesser caliber one is not the best thing for the club
[/quote]

Okay, so on one hand you are saying that these owners are a disgrace because they apparently won't give the manager funds from player sales, yet on the other hand you are saying that the manager should sell all the players because they are not performing for him?

So what would be left in that case then? Benitez as sole player/manager taking on all teams himself?

Not thought this through have you really?
 
Oh and Rebel, Istanbul was 5 years ago and the peak of his time here. He hasnt matched it since and spent millions in the meantime
 
[quote author=singlerider link=topic=38437.msg1033756#msg1033756 date=1263477713]
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033750#msg1033750 date=1263477321]

So 5 seasons in the CL is failure, a European cup is a failure, this is delusion on a scale of Newcastle United and since we can't give our current european cup winning manager the resources to do the job, we should sack him and hire someone with a worse record and expect him to do the job. I'm sure with an attitude like that we'll be where Newcastle is before long



[/quote]

I have been deliberately staying out of the footy forum this season, because it's too fucking grim, but this angers me too much to stay schtum.

"Delusion on a scale of Newcastle"?

Rebel, this isn't the first time I've had to remind you of this.

We are LIVERPOOL FUCKING FOOTBALL CLUB.

*THE* most successful team this country has *ever* produced.

FUCK OFF YOU FUCKING LOSER
[/quote]

and we have two broke yanks at the helm with clubs like City and Chelsea spending like no tomorrow, we have no right to success and shouldnt be deluded like Newcastle and make short term decisions because it's what seems best

So fuck you back
 
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=38437.msg1033752#msg1033752 date=1263477418]
[quote author=Delinquent link=topic=38437.msg1033749#msg1033749 date=1263477315]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=38437.msg1033744#msg1033744 date=1263477144]
[quote author=Stu link=topic=38437.msg1033727#msg1033727 date=1263476206]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=38437.msg1033723#msg1033723 date=1263476099]
A top 4 finish or a Ufea cup win should be enough keep Rafa in his job.
[/quote]

I think it ALL comes down to a top four finish mate.
Even if we win the tin pot and finish 5th, he'll be offski.
[/quote]

Thats probably true Stu.

I still think people need to seriously consider who we're likely to end up with as a replacement though. Its all well and good shouting "Rafa out", but the viable alternatives are very limited.
[/quote]

Someone who has a basic understanding of how this league works and how to motivate his team would be an improvement right now. I'd take a number of Premier League managers over Rafa. Sure, we should try to get the best replacement necessary but we shouldn't settle for mediocrity out of a fear of failure. We're failing in every department right now.
[/quote]

Who are all of these Premier League Managers you'd take then Del?
[/quote]

I'm not saying there's a lot. But there's the obvious ones at the top clubs plus MON and even Roy Hodgson. None of which I'm endorsing by the way, but all of which I would prefer here over Rafa. Which is a measure of how little confidence I have in the man.

And it wouldn't come to that anyway. Whatever anyone says, we are still a very attractive proposition for aspiring managers. I think we'd get a top manager if the position was made available.
 
[quote author=the_khl link=topic=38437.msg1033755#msg1033755 date=1263477644]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=38437.msg1033752#msg1033752 date=1263477418]
[quote author=Delinquent link=topic=38437.msg1033749#msg1033749 date=1263477315]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=38437.msg1033744#msg1033744 date=1263477144]
[quote author=Stu link=topic=38437.msg1033727#msg1033727 date=1263476206]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=38437.msg1033723#msg1033723 date=1263476099]
A top 4 finish or a Ufea cup win should be enough keep Rafa in his job.
[/quote]

I think it ALL comes down to a top four finish mate.
Even if we win the tin pot and finish 5th, he'll be offski.
[/quote]

Thats probably true Stu.

I still think people need to seriously consider who we're likely to end up with as a replacement though. Its all well and good shouting "Rafa out", but the viable alternatives are very limited.
[/quote]

Someone who has a basic understanding of how this league works and how to motivate his team would be an improvement right now. I'd take a number of Premier League managers over Rafa. Sure, we should try to get the best replacement necessary but we shouldn't settle for mediocrity out of a fear of failure. We're failing in every department right now.
[/quote]

Who are all of these Premier League Managers you'd take then Del?
[/quote]
That's a very good question indeed.

Roy Hodgson? Redknapp?
[/quote]

You could add MON to that list too i guess mate, but none of them are an improvement on Rafa.
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033764#msg1033764 date=1263478185]
Get MON in, sell Torres and bring Heskey and Petrov, we'll be back to world class performances in no time


[/quote]

And why in heaven's name would he do that?

I'm not a huge fan of MON either but I would take him now over Benitez
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033764#msg1033764 date=1263478185]
Get MON in, sell Torres and bring Heskey and Petrov, we'll be back to world class performances in no time


[/quote]

A manager does his best with the resources available to him so that's a ridiculous suggestion. MON has managed Villa with a fraction of the resources that Rafa has had.
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033764#msg1033764 date=1263478185]
Get MON in, sell Torres and bring Heskey and Petrov, we'll be back to world class performances in no time


[/quote]

And you wonder why you get shit left right and centre.

You're almost as bad as Rage for twisting peoples arguments to suit an agenda. People are pissed off with Rafa, and not without good reason, and his position has now rightly become questionable. It'll be hard to attract a top manager under current circumstances, but as you were reminded a few posts ago, we are LIVERPOOL FC, and that in itself holds attraction. The circumstances surrounding finances may only be temporary anyway, infact the current owners may only be temporary, as could be the current financial climate too. It's all ifs and buts, it's not a case of us being in a situation where the only person we can attract is a UEFA Cup place manager and no one has alluded to that either.
 
[quote author=Delinquent link=topic=38437.msg1033768#msg1033768 date=1263478452]
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033764#msg1033764 date=1263478185]
Get MON in, sell Torres and bring Heskey and Petrov, we'll be back to world class performances in no time


[/quote]

A manager does his best with the resources available to him so that's a ridiculous suggestion. MON has managed Villa with a fraction of the resources that Rafa has had.
[/quote]

you have to be kidding, he spent the best part of 50 million net in the last 18 months while Benitez has spent a few million and his team plays hoofball and is still average. I'm not kidding when I say if someone like MON was appointed he would want to bring the likes of Heskey and Petrov, that's what managers do
 
[quote author=mark1975 link=topic=38437.msg1033769#msg1033769 date=1263478521]
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033764#msg1033764 date=1263478185]
Get MON in, sell Torres and bring Heskey and Petrov, we'll be back to world class performances in no time


[/quote]

And you wonder why you get shit left right and centre.

You're almost as bad as Rage for twisting peoples arguments to suit an agenda. People are pissed off with Rafa, and not without good reason, and his position has now rightly become questionable. It'll be hard to attract a top manager under current circumstances, but as you were reminded a few posts ago, we are LIVERPOOL FC, and that in itself holds attraction. The circumstances surrounding finances may only be temporary anyway, infact the current owners may only be temporary, as could be the current financial climate too. It's all ifs and buts, it's not a case of us being in a situation where the only person we can attract is a UEFA Cup place manager and no one has alluded to that either.
[/quote]

Agree with all mark....but unfortunately i think rebels just being ignorant and wont listen to anyone because hes too damn proud!! Pity that!!
 
[quote author=The Slugmonster link=topic=38437.msg1033775#msg1033775 date=1263478853]

Agree with all mark....but unfortunately i think rebels just being ignorant and wont listen to anyone because hes too damn proud!! Pity that!!
[/quote]

Proud? What's rebel got to be proud about?

I suppose 'most deluded, repetitive, boring and laughable poster on the entire Internet' is an achievement of sorts
 
I have consistently said the same thing and i'm not going to change my mind based on short term results, neither should the board of LFC. It's ironic that Richey eulogises Ferguson who is probably the best example of the the approach I advocate
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033772#msg1033772 date=1263478751]
[quote author=Delinquent link=topic=38437.msg1033768#msg1033768 date=1263478452]
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033764#msg1033764 date=1263478185]
Get MON in, sell Torres and bring Heskey and Petrov, we'll be back to world class performances in no time


[/quote]

A manager does his best with the resources available to him so that's a ridiculous suggestion. MON has managed Villa with a fraction of the resources that Rafa has had.
[/quote]

you have to be kidding, he spent the best part of 50 million net in the last 18 months while Benitez has spent a few million and his team plays hoofball and is still average. I'm not kidding when I say if someone like MON was appointed he would want to bring the likes of Heskey and Petrov, that's what managers do
[/quote]

Rebel old lad, far be it from me to argue a case for MON, I hate the twat, but that is just plain daft.
O'niel has changed Villa from a mid table mediocrity team to a team that is challenging for a top four place, and has had to rebuild in doing so, and therefore not a bad return for £50m. To say Rafa has spent a few million in 18 months is masking things a little. What has Rafa spent in five years to get us to the stage we are now - two points behind Villa, dumped out of three cups at the first stage of asking, and not a hope in hell of qualifying for the CL?

regards
 
Thing is if we wait to may to sack him when we don't make the champions league, the club is less attractive to the top managers as a result. The best option is to sack him now and give us a fighting chance of getting fourth.

I'm worried without it we might find ourselves heading in the direction of Leeds united, the yanks will destroy this club and make themselves a few hundred million in the process. No champions league gives them an excuse to sell torres mascher and riena make a few million. They know the prestige of the Liverpool name will attract a buyer no matter what state we are in when they have squeezed every last penny they can out of their business venture.
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033783#msg1033783 date=1263479288]
I have consistently said the same thing and i'm not going to change my mind based on short term results, neither should the board of LFC. It's ironic that Richey eulogises Ferguson who is probably the best example of the the approach I advocate

[/quote]

You made that same badly worded point on another thread already. Didn't really work then either though did it?
 
Just because Ferguson managed to take 6 years to win the league, doesn't mean that you should always keep your manager in case he will win it. We should never have gotten rid of Houllier if you're going down that line of thinking.
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033761#msg1033761 date=1263478001]
[quote author=singlerider link=topic=38437.msg1033756#msg1033756 date=1263477713]
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033750#msg1033750 date=1263477321]

So 5 seasons in the CL is failure, a European cup is a failure, this is delusion on a scale of Newcastle United and since we can't give our current european cup winning manager the resources to do the job, we should sack him and hire someone with a worse record and expect him to do the job. I'm sure with an attitude like that we'll be where Newcastle is before long



[/quote]

I have been deliberately staying out of the footy forum this season, because it's too fucking grim, but this angers me too much to stay schtum.

"Delusion on a scale of Newcastle"?

Rebel, this isn't the first time I've had to remind you of this.

We are LIVERPOOL FUCKING FOOTBALL CLUB.

*THE* most successful team this country has *ever* produced.

FUCK OFF YOU FUCKING LOSER
[/quote]

and we have two broke yanks at the helm with clubs like City and Chelsea spending like no tomorrow, we have no right to success and shouldnt be deluded like Newcastle and make short term decisions because it's what seems best

So fuck you back

[/quote]

You really are a pitifully inept clown, aren't you?

We may not have a right to success as you put it, but we have a right to demand certain standards - standards which are patently not being met.

And had Rafa spent more wisely, or made more intelligent decisions - rather than sticking stubbornly to 'his way' when it was completely fucking obvious to all and sundry that have a functioning brain cell in their head (which seemingly is a clique you're not a part of) that 'his way' was a) fucking stupid, b) never gonna work, c) a shit idea born out of his need to prove he was right all along and d) bad for the club - then we probably wouldn't be in this fucking pickle.

In fact, we'd probably have *another* European Cup, because at the time it was fucking obvious that playing Kuyt as the lone striker wasn't working, and any sensible motherfucker would have stuck Crouch up top as the target man and moved Dirk either back or onto the bench.

We wouldn't have lost games where anyone could see that playing Crouch and Voronin as wing-forwards was not gonna work.

We may well have actually won the fucking thing last year if he hadn't made the sort of mystifying decisions that saw Lucas played as a bloody left mid.

And yet here you are saying that nothing he does is bad enough to warrant sacking him.

For fuck's sake, just shut up. Do yourself a favour. Do all of us a favour. In fact, do the fucking world a favour and just shut yourself off in a dark room with enough supplies to last you the next 30 years, because frankly your stupidity is so fucking immense I'm starting to worry it might go airborne.

It's one of the footballing clichés to say that no player is bigger than the team, but equally true is that neither is any manager, and the manager is being detrimental to the team as a whole, then they've gotta go.

I said it 2 seasons ago, and we had a strong finish and I thought he might just have figured it out, so I said I'd give him a chance. Then he pulled that Lucas at left mid shit and I said enough's enough - and he made me look like a cunt by going closer than we've ever been in ages. So this year we all expect big things and it's all gone to shit.

And that's just going to keep on happening. Rafa is not gonna be the one who takes us all the way, because he's limited. Limited by his own stubbornness and inflexibility, as much as he makes a big deal about [the team] being able to adapt to different things, it's something he himself is unable to do.

So it's not a short term decision. Not by any stretch of the imagination. In fact, it's the long term view - we could stick with Rafa and see how he does next year, when we've (maybe) got a bit more money and (maybe) got some better players - or we could appoint somebody who actually knows how to get the best out of what they've got, who can help draw all of that potential out of them, instead of buying 'talent' and turning it to shit.

I'm gonna lay my nuts on the chopping board here and now and say that Rafa will *never* win the league, and if he does then I'll run round Liverpool in crotchless panties and fishnet stockings and you can post it on youtube and everything.

He's not the one.

So, do you stick with something in the short term that doesn't work in the hope that it might come good? Or do you look to the future?

Or do you ponce about like "I know best, you're all deluded, everyone else will be shit, you'll see" and generally act all sanctimonious and (laughably) superior.

You mug
 
What have MON achieved that would give anyone the indication that he'd do a better job right now in the Anfield hotseat?

I just can't see it.

Besides Ferguson and Wenger I can't see anyone outthere on Rafa's level to be honest in the League.
 
[quote author=the_khl link=topic=38437.msg1033791#msg1033791 date=1263479603]
What have MON achieved that would give anyone the indication that he'd do a better job right now in the Anfield hotseat?

I just can't see it.

Besides Ferguson and Wenger I can't see anyone outthere on Rafa's level to be honest in the League.
[/quote]

To be fair Ancelotti isn't too shabby mate

Other than that though you're right (imo).
 
[quote author=Vlads Quiff link=topic=38437.msg1033786#msg1033786 date=1263479382]
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033772#msg1033772 date=1263478751]
[quote author=Delinquent link=topic=38437.msg1033768#msg1033768 date=1263478452]
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=38437.msg1033764#msg1033764 date=1263478185]
Get MON in, sell Torres and bring Heskey and Petrov, we'll be back to world class performances in no time


[/quote]

A manager does his best with the resources available to him so that's a ridiculous suggestion. MON has managed Villa with a fraction of the resources that Rafa has had.
[/quote]

you have to be kidding, he spent the best part of 50 million net in the last 18 months while Benitez has spent a few million and his team plays hoofball and is still average. I'm not kidding when I say if someone like MON was appointed he would want to bring the likes of Heskey and Petrov, that's what managers do
[/quote]

Rebel old lad, far be it from me to argue a case for MON, I hate the twat, but that is just plain daft.
O'niel has changed Villa from a mid table mediocrity team to a team that is challenging for a top four place, and has had to rebuild in doing so, and therefore not a bad return for £50m. To say Rafa has spent a few million in 18 months is masking things a little. What has Rafa spent in five years to get us to the stage we are now - two points behind Villa, dumped out of three cups at the first stage of asking, and not a hope in hell of qualifying for the CL?

[/quote]

You see vladders my dear friend, Benitez's success has been a boon for the club in that in those 5 consecutive seasons in the CL he has brought in hundreds of millions in prize money, kept our name up there, pushed our club on probably to the detriment of it long term and into the hands of Gillette and Hicks who if it wasn't for Benitez would still think Liverpool was just where the Beatles came from, also let me ask you vlad if you think the likes of Standard Chatered would be signing 20 million sponsorship agreements on the back of the exciting and lumbering hoofball regularly served up by O'Neill and if you think he would have done a better job over the last 5 years?
 
[quote author=the_khl link=topic=38437.msg1033791#msg1033791 date=1263479603]
What have MON achieved that would give anyone the indication that he'd do a better job right now in the Anfield hotseat?

I just can't see it.

Besides Ferguson and Wenger I can't see anyone outthere on Rafa's level to be honest in the League.
[/quote]

How many others took over a club already in the top 4? Managers have to work with the resources and expectations that they have.

Benitez took over a big club with a strong squad and has been allowed to spend a decent amount of money. Other managers have made better relative progress.
 
Hahaha, oh Rebel. Why anyone bothers with you is beyond me.

I think Benitez should do the honourable thing and walk away from our club. He won't, though. I know he loves the club and is a decent man, but he has a history of looking after his own self-interests - sometimes at the expense of the club. There is no reason why this situation will be any different.

The thought of Benitez pocketing millions of pounds right now makes me furious, but, as a few of us could see at the time, offering him such a secure contract was nothing more than reactionary, short-sighted bollocks from the owners.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom