• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

James Lawton Article

Status
Not open for further replies.
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=39473.msg1075969#msg1075969 date=1269456631]
[quote author=darkstarexodus link=topic=39473.msg1075966#msg1075966 date=1269456159]
Who signed those underperforming and unappreciative players?
[/quote]

yep and it's a scandal that they underperform and 'need an arm around the shoulder', many of these sulking players owe Benitez a lot, including their fat and rising contracts while he has been starved of money to invest in the team and bring them better players to play with. So maybe it's not all the managers fault, maybe the players should look at themselves and offer to take a paycut, many of them will have to contractually if we're not in the CL, that will sort out the men from the boys


[/quote]

Well said mate. Whilst Rafa has to take his share of the blame, several of the playing staff have let their boss down massively.

Not only have they let Rafa down, they've also let the Club down.

It's a shame one or two our higher profile players seem to think they're invincible hence there's no effort or hunger in their performances.
 
One thing I will agree on, is bollocks to the players not wanting to play for Rafa. They are meant to be professionals. They are paid by the Yanks (ok, their loans and what not) via Purslow. Not by Rafa.

Yeah Rafa must go, but the players should take a look at themselves too. Twats.
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=39473.msg1075885#msg1075885 date=1269446228]
Benitez has revamped the squad, he's bought a players for 20 million that are is worth 80 million.
[/quote]

Excuse my minor adjustment. If Torres was sold, Benitez would recoup some £60m odd, granted. Which would go some way to recouping the tens of millions that he's squandered in his time here.

It's all about balance really.
 
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1075934#msg1075934 date=1269450996]
chelsea and manu's squad is PATENTLY better, so if rafa was spending a comparable amount of money (which he wasn't) how is he supposed to overtake the above teams?
[/quote]

Magic?
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=39473.msg1075964#msg1075964 date=1269455581]
so the nitpickers want to talk about players signed like Keane
[/quote]

Meanwhile, you're pinpointing success on the fact that Torres is now worth £80m! Go you!
 
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=39473.msg1075977#msg1075977 date=1269459242]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1075934#msg1075934 date=1269450996]
chelsea and manu's squad is PATENTLY better, so if rafa was spending a comparable amount of money (which he wasn't) how is he supposed to overtake the above teams?
[/quote]

Magic?
[/quote]

johnson is good but he isnt THAT good 😉
 
basically,

if you think rafa should be fucked off because he is too cautious - I can respect that
if you think rafa should be fucked off because you feel he has no 'plan b' I can respect that
if you think rafa should be fucked off because he can't get the best out of the squad - I can respect that

but, if you think rafa should be fucked off because our squad strength is inferior to our title rivals, or he should be fucked off because we don't have enough world class players despite being in charge 5 years I think that is totally unfair
 
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1075987#msg1075987 date=1269461223]
basically,

if you think rafa should be fucked off because he is too cautious - I can respect that
if you think rafa should be fucked off because you feel he has no 'plan b' I can respect that
if you think rafa should be fucked off because he can't get the best out of the squad - I can respect that

but, if you think rafa should be fucked off because our squad strength is inferior to our title rivals, or he should be fucked off because we don't have enough world class players despite being in charge 5 years I think that is totally unfair
[/quote]

Can't speak for the others but it's the three "respectable" reasons you've listed that have me thinking it's time for a change.
 
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1075987#msg1075987 date=1269461223]
but, if you think rafa should be fucked off because our squad strength is inferior to our title rivals, or he should be fucked off because we don't have enough world class players despite being in charge 5 years I think that is totally unfair
[/quote]

title rivals hahahaha. are you still with us? i'm afraid our squad strengh is inferior to 4/5/6th place rivals

world class players hahahaha. i doubt people are critical of lucas and insua becuase they're not world class. benitez definately can fuck off because our non-world class players are also non-premier league class, and regularly get beaten or held to draws by bottom of the table teams.

trying to say woe is benitez he can't compete for the title and world class players is like saying...
woe is spider-neil he can't outscore robbie fowler
 
The market value of a player is of no relevance unless you're selling him. Torres being worth 80m isn't worth a fiddler's fart to us unless we sell him at that price.

However, if we use this sort of metric to assess the quality of rafa's investments in the squad, we should balance the excellent judgement shown in signing Torres with the fact that:

1. There is not a single left-back at the club who has any discernible market value (except maybe 1m or 2m).
2. We don't have a single winger at the club worth more than 10m (by winger I mean left or right side midfield player)
3. After Torres, we don't have a striker at the club worth more than 5m (or 10m if you count Babel). I'm being generous valuing Ngog at 5m.
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=39473.msg1075969#msg1075969 date=1269456631]
[quote author=darkstarexodus link=topic=39473.msg1075966#msg1075966 date=1269456159]
Who signed those underperforming and unappreciative players?
[/quote]

yep and it's a scandal that they underperform and 'need an arm around the shoulder', many of these sulking players owe Benitez a lot, including their fat and rising contracts while he has been starved of money to invest in the team and bring them better players to play with. So maybe it's not all the managers fault, maybe the players should look at themselves and offer to take a paycut, many of them will have to contractually if we're not in the CL, that will sort out the men from the boys


[/quote]

See, I don't see a lot of players sulking, Riera, Torres and Gerrard excepted. I do, however, see a lot of players underperforming and a couple players who just aren't ready for the roles they've been thrust into. Certainly it's up to each player to give his all on the field but it's up to the manager (and captain) to maintain morale and have a plan that the players can buy into. The lack of success of said plan has eaten away at the morale. It's been mentioned umpteen times how many leaders and former/present captains we have on our team. We have a lot of players with supposed character and leadership. And yet we look lost and forlorn. How do you reconcile this?
 
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=39473.msg1075977#msg1075977 date=1269459242]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1075934#msg1075934 date=1269450996]
chelsea and manu's squad is PATENTLY better, so if rafa was spending a comparable amount of money (which he wasn't) how is he supposed to overtake the above teams?
[/quote]

Magic?
[/quote]

If we were four points behind a team last year, then spent double what they did during the summer (gross) and 60m more than them net, is it reasonable to suggest that being 18 points behind them now represents abject failure ?

Or is that magic too ?
 
Dear me. You know a thread is going to go a bit wrong once Rebel arrives in it.
So basically we've heard that Benitez has done a good job because he has players whose value has increased. Well so he should! Buying players for a top club and giving them CL experience for example should increase their value. The question is why has he not done that more?

Then we hear that Benitez had no chance because he's had no money, which is clearly not true. It might have hindered him in moving us up from 4th (IMO not the case but can see the argument) but how does it explain us losing the Wigan and Pompey?

Then when faced with the fact other clubs are not spending money we are told that they have massive wage bills and
we don't. Also bullshit given that the reason we couldn't spend money last summer was because we handed fat contracts to half our squad.

Finally we are told it's the players' fault, not Benitez's, and those players are highly paid. Well surely that contradicts the last point?

Rebel = mad
 
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=39473.msg1076110#msg1076110 date=1269470401]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=39473.msg1075977#msg1075977 date=1269459242]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1075934#msg1075934 date=1269450996]
chelsea and manu's squad is PATENTLY better, so if rafa was spending a comparable amount of money (which he wasn't) how is he supposed to overtake the above teams?
[/quote]

Magic?
[/quote]

If we were four points behind a team last year, then spent double what they did during the summer (gross) and 60m more than them net, is it reasonable to suggest that being 18 points behind them now represents abject failure ?

Or is that magic too ?
[/quote]

I'm not suggesting that this season is anything other than a disaster but those figures are distorted because of the sale of ONE player.
 
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1076187#msg1076187 date=1269497633]
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=39473.msg1076110#msg1076110 date=1269470401]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=39473.msg1075977#msg1075977 date=1269459242]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1075934#msg1075934 date=1269450996]
chelsea and manu's squad is PATENTLY better, so if rafa was spending a comparable amount of money (which he wasn't) how is he supposed to overtake the above teams?
[/quote]

Magic?
[/quote]

If we were four points behind a team last year, then spent double what they did during the summer (gross) and 60m more than them net, is it reasonable to suggest that being 18 points behind them now represents abject failure ?

Or is that magic too ?
[/quote]

I'm not suggesting that this season is anything other than a disaster but those figures are distorted because of the sale of ONE player.
[/quote]

They also don't take into account the wage bill. The assertion then goes from distorted to irrelevant, as known and explained elsewhere. Including fees and wages we stand sixth in the spend League.

Having said that, I too wish a change of Manager, simply because we've become stale and need a change of focus. I'd like Mourinho to take charge.

As regards the article, James Lawton is a cut and paste tosser.
 
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1076187#msg1076187 date=1269497633]
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=39473.msg1076110#msg1076110 date=1269470401]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=39473.msg1075977#msg1075977 date=1269459242]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1075934#msg1075934 date=1269450996]
chelsea and manu's squad is PATENTLY better, so if rafa was spending a comparable amount of money (which he wasn't) how is he supposed to overtake the above teams?
[/quote]

Magic?
[/quote]

If we were four points behind a team last year, then spent double what they did during the summer (gross) and 60m more than them net, is it reasonable to suggest that being 18 points behind them now represents abject failure ?

Or is that magic too ?
[/quote]

I'm not suggesting that this season is anything other than a disaster but those figures are distorted because of the sale of ONE player.
[/quote]

They aren't distorted. They're simply the facts.

The only reason I included it is because when people are faced with the proposition of a manager that they want to defend spending 40m and not improving the team they then revert to the net spend argument, and then the wage bill argument. Then after that you get into the Rebel territory where the "value of the squad" and all sorts of chaotic and irrelevant arguments come in.

The fact is if Benitez wasn't a failure none of those arguments would need to be contorted and disfigured so badly. But as Lawton said in the article there's a bit of a cult of Benitez going on and too many people are taken in by it and it's definitely evidence that we can no longer be seen as an intelligent bunch of fans.

Jexy did an about face recently from his "no manager can be expected to win when he can't spend more than everyone else" when he admitted Mourinho could probably do it (and has never provided any evidence for the figures he mentions). It was also pointed out to him that United have three league titles on the trot while spending less on transfers than about 6 other clubs and less on wages than Chelsea and Man City. There's a certain amount of money that needs to be spent for a club to have a chance to be successful, but above and beyond that money isn't as big a factor as people think (Otherwise Real would be still in the CL). After that the management side of things becomes more important. We've patently failed in the transfer market in the past two years, we've sold too many players and replaced them with players who aren't as good. You bring up whatever spending figures you like, but there's no way you can argue that Benitez spent that 80m well in the last two years. The real difference between us and the likes of Arsenal and United is that they have managers who are quite simply a lot better than ours. They know how to build a squad, work with it and get the best out of it. Rafa doesn't.

The time for excuses isn't now. We are currently outside the top four and we will most likely finish outside of it this year. For the second time under Benitez. Last time it was only Everton that finished above us and we knew it was a one off, this time it's City, Villa and Spurs. They aren't going to fall away anytime soon. We need to decide what direction this club is going long term this summer.
 
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=39473.msg1076197#msg1076197 date=1269503918]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1076187#msg1076187 date=1269497633]
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=39473.msg1076110#msg1076110 date=1269470401]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=39473.msg1075977#msg1075977 date=1269459242]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1075934#msg1075934 date=1269450996]
chelsea and manu's squad is PATENTLY better, so if rafa was spending a comparable amount of money (which he wasn't) how is he supposed to overtake the above teams?
[/quote]

Magic?
[/quote]

If we were four points behind a team last year, then spent double what they did during the summer (gross) and 60m more than them net, is it reasonable to suggest that being 18 points behind them now represents abject failure ?

Or is that magic too ?
[/quote]

I'm not suggesting that this season is anything other than a disaster but those figures are distorted because of the sale of ONE player.
[/quote]

They aren't distorted. They're simply the facts.

The only reason I included it is because when people are faced with the proposition of a manager that they want to defend spending 40m and not improving the team they then revert to the net spend argument, and then the wage bill argument. Then after that you get into the Rebel territory where the "value of the squad" and all sorts of chaotic and irrelevant arguments come in.

The fact is if Benitez wasn't a failure none of those arguments would need to be contorted and disfigured so badly. But as Lawton said in the article there's a bit of a cult of Benitez going on and too many people are taken in by it and it's definitely evidence that we can no longer be seen as an intelligent bunch of fans.

Jexy did an about face recently from his "no manager can be expected to win when he can't spend more than everyone else" when he admitted Mourinho could probably do it (and has never provided any evidence for the figures he mentions). It was also pointed out to him that United have three league titles on the trot while spending less on transfers than about 6 other clubs and less on wages than Chelsea and Man City. There's a certain amount of money that needs to be spent for a club to have a chance to be successful, but above and beyond that money isn't as big a factor as people think (Otherwise Real would be still in the CL). After that the management side of things becomes more important. We've patently failed in the transfer market in the past two years, we've sold too many players and replaced them with players who aren't as good. You bring up whatever spending figures you like, but there's no way you can argue that Benitez spent that 80m well in the last two years. The real difference between us and the likes of Arsenal and United is that they have managers who are quite simply a lot better than ours. They know how to build a squad, work with it and get the best out of it. Rafa doesn't.

The time for excuses isn't now. We are currently outside the top four and we will most likely finish outside of it this year. For the second time under Benitez. Last time it was only Everton that finished above us and we knew it was a one off, this time it's City, Villa and Spurs. They aren't going to fall away anytime soon. We need to decide what direction this club is going long term this summer.
[/quote]

all of that are fair points and the buck does indeed stop with the manager, there are plenty of things that rafa does that I don't like but a key point for me is when we finished 2nd in the league THAT was the time to consolidate that position, that was the time to back the manager to the best of your ability but there was no money forthcoming, all the money was generated by sales and THAT is what is fucking me off.

its like when jose wanted money in jan and none was forthcoming when a mere 10m for a CB would probably have seen chelsea win the league. its like you (the owners) don't WANT the manager to succeed, sure you have given the manager money in the past and the manager should probably have dont better with the funds recieved but withholding that money smacks of biting off your nose to spite your face.

I can definately see why a lot of fans want rid but I have my reasons for wanting him to be given another season, were going to have to agree to disagree what I dont take to kindly to is the accusation that if you dont want rid of benitez you are stupid which is basically what the open article is saying.
 
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=39473.msg1076197#msg1076197 date=1269503918]

They aren't distorted. They're simply the facts.

The only reason I included it is because when people are faced with the proposition of a manager that they want to defend spending 40m and not improving the team they then revert to the net spend argument, and then the wage bill argument. Then after that you get into the Rebel territory where the "value of the squad" and all sorts of chaotic and irrelevant arguments come in.

The fact is if Benitez wasn't a failure none of those arguments would need to be contorted and disfigured so badly. But as Lawton said in the article there's a bit of a cult of Benitez going on and too many people are taken in by it and it's definitely evidence that we can no longer be seen as an intelligent bunch of fans.

Jexy did an about face recently from his "no manager can be expected to win when he can't spend more than everyone else" when he admitted Mourinho could probably do it (and has never provided any evidence for the figures he mentions). It was also pointed out to him that United have three league titles on the trot while spending less on transfers than about 6 other clubs and less on wages than Chelsea and Man City. There's a certain amount of money that needs to be spent for a club to have a chance to be successful, but above and beyond that money isn't as big a factor as people think (Otherwise Real would be still in the CL). After that the management side of things becomes more important. We've patently failed in the transfer market in the past two years, we've sold too many players and replaced them with players who aren't as good. You bring up whatever spending figures you like, but there's no way you can argue that Benitez spent that 80m well in the last two years. The real difference between us and the likes of Arsenal and United is that they have managers who are quite simply a lot better than ours. They know how to build a squad, work with it and get the best out of it. Rafa doesn't.

The time for excuses isn't now. We are currently outside the top four and we will most likely finish outside of it this year. For the second time under Benitez. Last time it was only Everton that finished above us and we knew it was a one off, this time it's City, Villa and Spurs. They aren't going to fall away anytime soon. We need to decide what direction this club is going long term this summer.
[/quote]

For someone who at one time believed in Rafa, a lot of that makes painful reading Ross.

Then again, the truth can indeed sometimes hurt!
 
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=39473.msg1076110#msg1076110 date=1269470401]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=39473.msg1075977#msg1075977 date=1269459242]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1075934#msg1075934 date=1269450996]
chelsea and manu's squad is PATENTLY better, so if rafa was spending a comparable amount of money (which he wasn't) how is he supposed to overtake the above teams?
[/quote]

Magic?
[/quote]

If we were four points behind a team last year, then spent double what they did during the summer (gross) and 60m more than them net, is it reasonable to suggest that being 18 points behind them now represents abject failure ?


[/quote]

As it stands of right now he's failed this season Rosco.

When judging him I tend to look at his whole career with us though.

1. We've progressed steadily under him up until this season.
2. This has taken place whilst being out spent by all of our rivals (as Jexy has rightly pointed out) + having a much weaker squad than them all to start off with.

Unless we can some how manage to attract one of a very small group of managers (highly unlikely), then personally i don't think it's the right move for us to be replacing Rafa.
 
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=39473.msg1076241#msg1076241 date=1269510060]
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=39473.msg1076110#msg1076110 date=1269470401]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=39473.msg1075977#msg1075977 date=1269459242]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1075934#msg1075934 date=1269450996]
chelsea and manu's squad is PATENTLY better, so if rafa was spending a comparable amount of money (which he wasn't) how is he supposed to overtake the above teams?
[/quote]

Magic?
[/quote]

If we were four points behind a team last year, then spent double what they did during the summer (gross) and 60m more than them net, is it reasonable to suggest that being 18 points behind them now represents abject failure ?


[/quote]

As it stands of right now he's failed this season Rosco.

When judging him I tend to look at his whole career with us though.

1. We've progressed steadily under him up until this season.
2. This has taken place whilst being out spent by all of our rivals (as Jexy has rightly pointed out) + having a much weaker squad than them all to start off with.
Unless we can some how manage to attract one of a very small group of managers (highly unlikely), then personally i don't think it's the right move for us to be replacing Rafa.
[/quote]

that was me, give me my due blast you!! ;D
 
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=39473.msg1076241#msg1076241 date=1269510060]
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=39473.msg1076110#msg1076110 date=1269470401]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=39473.msg1075977#msg1075977 date=1269459242]
[quote author=spider-neil link=topic=39473.msg1075934#msg1075934 date=1269450996]
chelsea and manu's squad is PATENTLY better, so if rafa was spending a comparable amount of money (which he wasn't) how is he supposed to overtake the above teams?
[/quote]

Magic?
[/quote]

If we were four points behind a team last year, then spent double what they did during the summer (gross) and 60m more than them net, is it reasonable to suggest that being 18 points behind them now represents abject failure ?


[/quote]

As it stands of right now he's failed this season Rosco.

When judging him I tend to look at his whole career with us though.

1. We've progressed steadily under him up until this season.
2. This has taken place whilst being out spent by all of our rivals (as Jexy has rightly pointed out) + having a much weaker squad than them all to start off with.

Unless we can some how manage to attract one of a very small group of managers (highly unlikely), then personally i don't think it's the right move for us to be replacing Rafa.
[/quote]

NO. HE. HASN'T.

Jesus Fuck! When will people stop repeating this garbage?
 
Yes he has Del.

If G&H think it's acceptable to include wages when it comes to our transfer kitty, then i thinks it's fair to do the same when we are doing a comparison with our rivals.

Taking into account transfer fees + our wage bill, then the gooners, chavs and Utd all continue to spend more than us (+Spurs and City for that matter).
 
[quote author=KopKing link=topic=39473.msg1075911#msg1075911 date=1269448089]


I have to interject here. There's a correlation between silverware and wage bills even more so over the last 5 years. Also there's no evidence to suggest that Rafa would 'spunk' anything up any wall. We used to have the 2nd highest capacity stadium in the country. We used to regularly smash the transfer record. If you are suggesting that any manager could come in with a net spend of zero and improve us, you're in Cloud Cuckoo land.
[/quote]

That post is a veritable microcosm of the polarised debate about Rafa on here. It seems that SCM finds it too unbearable to hold in tension the opposing truths that Rafa has been working within a stricter financial budget than his rivals (Wenger aside) with an originally weaker squadand a new manager at this moment in time could probably improve the performances of the squad we have (I'm sure Mourinho, for instance, would get more out of our current side).
 
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=39473.msg1076274#msg1076274 date=1269515320]
Yes he has Del.

If G&H think it's acceptable to include wages when it comes to our transfer kitty, then i thinks it's fair to do the same when we are doing a comparison with our rivals.

Taking into account transfer fees + our wage bill, then the gooners, chavs and Utd all continue to spend more than us (+Spurs and City for that matter).


[/quote]

I have provided figures to the contrary to before, as I'm sure has Ross.

What's interesting, is that those who continue to oppose or ignore those figures, have absolutely no evidence to back themselves up.

Funny that.
 
Great post above Ross.

This may stick in the craw and I may take some pelters for this, but I personally don't think that Rafa is in the same league (right now) as Fergie, Wenger or indeed Mourinho when it comes to managing a team over a season (consistently). He's up there (otherwise he wouldn't be managing us) don't get me wrong, but they're just clearly better at their jobs all round.

In management terms, he's still young(ish) and may one day get up there, but his personality and stubbornness suggests it will take a lot of time.
 
[quote author=Delinquent link=topic=39473.msg1076289#msg1076289 date=1269517762]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=39473.msg1076274#msg1076274 date=1269515320]
Yes he has Del.

If G&H think it's acceptable to include wages when it comes to our transfer kitty, then i thinks it's fair to do the same when we are doing a comparison with our rivals.

Taking into account transfer fees + our wage bill, then the gooners, chavs and Utd all continue to spend more than us (+Spurs and City for that matter).


[/quote]

I have provided figures to the contrary to before, as I'm sure has Ross.

What's interesting, is that those who continue to oppose or ignore those figures, have absolutely no evidence to back themselves up.

Funny that.
[/quote]

I'm just going on the figures produced by Deloitte's annual review of football finance's Del

"Chelsea, with wage costs of £172m remains the
highest spender by some distance, over £50m above
the next highest club, Manchester United, who spent
£121m. The other top five wages spenders in 2008 are, for the sixth season in succession, Arsenal £101m,
Liverpool £90m, Newcastle United £75m".

Looking at those figures it's clear to see that the Scum, chavs and now City (from what we already clearly know) easily out spend us.

The Gooners wage bill is only £11m more a season than ours, so on that score i stand corrected.
 
[quote author=ibromurph link=topic=39473.msg1076298#msg1076298 date=1269518516]
Great post above Ross.

This may stick in the craw and I may take some pelters for this, but I personally don't think that Rafa is in the same league (right now) as Fergie, Wenger or indeed Mourinho when it comes to managing a team over a season (consistently). He's up there (otherwise he wouldn't be managing us) don't get me wrong, but they're just clearly better at their jobs all round.

In management terms, he's still young(ish) and may one day get up there, but his personality and stubbornness suggests it will take a lot of time.
[/quote]

He's simply too defensively-minded to amass enough points over the course of the season to win the Premier League. Last season, just like in most games, Rafa seemed intent on protecting our lead once we were out in front in the premiership, before throwing caution to the wind when our title challenge was all but over. Then this season we struggle and what does he do? Persist with a compact, inhibited side with two defensive midfielders and no creativity, with our 20m creative midfielder on the bench.

Conclusion: When we're leading the pack Rafa's instinct is to keep things tight and compact. When we're falling apart Rafa's instinct is to keep things tight and compact. Compare with Ferguson/Wenger/Mourinho.
 
[quote author=rebel23 link=topic=39473.msg1075885#msg1075885 date=1269446228]
Fans like you find hard to understand that the club has to be on a sound footing, that clubs like Man Utd and Chelsea are double our wage budget and that you need to be patient with LFC which is nearly a constant rebuilding job and with the thin resources available especially over the last 2 years when the taps have been turned off every signing has to be a success or shipped out quickly and money recovered, which is not easy. YOU have to accept that there are certain pressures and limits evident at LFC which are not prevelent at other clubs and that this will breed the inconsistency or lead to a poor season. [/quote]

Firstly, it shouldn't have to be a constant rebuilding job - do it right in the first place and you won't have to rebuild. To steal a familiar phrase from a building site "buy cheap, buy twice" - and that's exactly what Rafa has done, time and time again. Initially in his first couple of seasons it was excusable, because he did have a big rebuilding job on his hands, and the large sums of money he spent, he spent well.

However, there's only so long you can live off the same excuses, and I'm afraid time has been called on those ages ago. Mediocre players have been coming in and out season after season and Rafa still hasn't learnt his lesson - and he can't use the excuse that he hasn't had the money any more - the same summer we signed Robbie Keane for £19M, we also signed Riera for £8M and Dossena for £7M.

Now, given that Robbie Keane's ostensible position is either as an out-and-out striker, or as a second striker - and given that we'd just seen the devastating partnership of Gerrard-Torres really start to bloom, was it *really* necessary to spend £19M on that position? Especially considering we haven't had a proper decent winger on either side since the beginning of Rafa's tenure?

We'll write off Dossena and just consider Keane and Riera - for that money, a combined £27M are you seriously trying to tell me that we couldn't have bought two decent wingers and restored Dirk to his rightful position as a striker (backup to Torres).

Seriously?

I mean, the fact that we haven't had a decent wide player since Rafa joined, and this is *still* something that has not been addressed is cause for concern enough surely? Just in case you've forgotten, this is what we've had to put up with since he arrived:

Nunez (not his problem granted) - £1.5M
Garcia - £6M
Zenden - free
Gonzalez - £1.5M
Pennant - £6.7M
Leto (does he even count?) - £1.8M
Riera - £8M
Maxi - free

And those are the genuine widemen that he's bought (although Zenden is debatable as I believe he was playing CM/AM for Boro before he joined us). Of them, the only one that comes away with even the slightest amount of respectability is Lil Luis, and even as a fan of his I'd still admit that his talent was somewhat *ahem* 'mercurial'. Riera showed moments, and Maxi isn't a lost cause yet, but other than that they've all been pretty much shit.

Then we've got the non widemen who've been stuck in to 'do a job' - Kuyt - £9M, Babel - £11.5M and Yossi - £5M. Dirk and Yossi have been honest grafters and done their best, and sometimes they've done very well and sometimes they've been brutal. Babel has shown glimpses of talent and potential, but very little heart and generally made little impression.

So in all that time, he still hasn't addressed one of, if not our biggest problem areas - quality on the wings. He's has the opportunity to do so, and the money - but he hasn't done it. And this is one of the problems with Rafa - he seems to lose all perspective and the ability to prioritise correctly. This summer, when it was patently obvious we needed back up for Torres what did he do? Spent £17.5M on a right back and another £17M on an injured CM that he's refused to play all season. Admittedly, both of those positions needed addressing - but did we *need* to spend £17.5M on a right back (and don't get me wrong, I think Magic is great) - but is that not the sort of position that can be dealt with for half, a third or even a quarter of the cost? Okay, maybe a quarter is pushing it, but you can pick up a reasonable right back for less. Decent strikers tend to cost more, but we've had one costing £1.5M leading the line for us far too often this season. £17M on an injured player - is that wise?

And in seasons before he's been spending a couple of million here, a couple of million there on centre backs and goalies, bulking out the squad with players that will never see a first team game. If his money is so fucking tight then he should fuck the ressies off and concentrate on getting someone decent who will actually be on the pitch.

[quote author=Rebel]Benitez has revamped the squad, he's bought players for 20 million that are worth 80 million. This is not running the club down the tubes, this is doing a good job in my eyes and he ought to be backed and allowed to repeat the trick. If our revenue doubles and the value of the club increases again over the next 5 years like it has in the previous, Benitez will not only have paid for the yanks takeover but we'll probably be starting on a new stadium which will set us up for the next 30 years, so you need to be patient with a manager like Benitez and allow for stability because over time he's done a good job for the club AND the bastard owners. [/quote]

Fuck the money, there's only one way we're going to get a new stadium and that is new owners. It doesn't matter what profit Rafa turns on the odd player here and there, it's not going to be enough to pay for a whole fucking stadium on it's own. Not unless we had a team of Fernandos, and even then we'd be pushing it.

The *only* way we'll get a new stadium is new owners. The best way to make ourselves an attractive proposition is by winning stuff. We haven't won anything in a while, and don't look like doing so any time soon. Rafa is no longer looking like somebody who knows how to win with the squad he has, and while he was tearing it up in Europe and making progress in the league his idiosyncrasies could be forgiven. Now it looks like he's forgotten how to win in Europe, the league looks further away than ever (disappointingly, as once again last season he looked like he'd finally figured it out, only to draw frustratingly again and again against teams we should have been destroying) and his tactics and post match interviews resemble Ged's more and more each week.

His time has been and gone, we need new everything, including a manager.

[quote author=Rebel]it is a crime that he hasn't had more money to invest in players and has to wheel and deal and take chances. In addition, he has rebuilt the youth setup and brought in Barce coaches over the last year, give that a few years and we'll have our own factory of talent that will have you singing again[/quote]

This is the only sensible thing you've said in all of this. In fact it might be the most sensible thing you've ever said.

Yes - it is a crime the owners didn't give him more money. They're short-sighted money grabbing cunts that need a good shoeing, because this season really was our chance to capitalise on last years performance. Losing Xabi, Sami, and even Arbeloa has had a much bigger impact than any of us could have imagined, but it can't be said that Rafa wasn't backed to replace them.

Xabi - £30M
Sami - free
Arbeloa - £3.5

Aqualani - £17M
Magic - £17.5M
Kyrgiakos - £2M

So - sold £33.5M, bought £36.5M. He was backed, he had money to spend - he was the one who chose to spend it on an injured player he then decided couldn't hack the league, and if you were gonna really go all out character assassination then you could ask questions as to why those three players wanted to go in the first place - Sami is understandable, but given the amount that Kyrgiakos has played he actually would have still had a big role to play. Xabi had Lucas as competition and Arbeloa had . . . err . . . Darby? Okay, it's Real Madrid, but we're Liverpool - could another manager have talked them in to staying on, winning the league, winning the Champions League again and knocking those scummy cunts off their fucking perch? Surely that's the sort of challenge professional footballers thrive on?

Granted, the owners have a lot to answer for, but ultimately nowhere near as much as Rafa - and he's been here longer than them. I could go on in many other ways justifying this, but ultimately you just won't listen because you're a particularly special breed of mentalist the likes of which is rarely come across unless you meet those nutty Rapture folks who believe that one day all the sinners will burn in hell and some magic cloud will take them off to Heaven or some shit.

And that's exactly how you are with Rafa. Blind, brainwashed and utterly impervious to common sense. What's more you have this impregnable belief that you are the only person that can really see the truth, and that this unshakable belief in all things Rafa somehow makes you better than everyone else.

In other words, you're a sanctimonious cunt, the like of which make me avoid the fucking football forum. It's bad enough having a team that plays like a lepers eleven, but then having superfans like you bleat on about "Oh, it's not his fault" make me realise how Americans end up going postal and killing everyone.

You make me want to kick small defenceless animals in the head
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom