VaR is rubbish...
Crystal Palace v Liverpool - Match Thread
- Thread starter FoxForceFive
- Start date
- Latest activity Latest activity:
- Status
Doesn't matter a hoot how hard the push was. The rules say bugger all about that. Push, foul, end of. We've been poor but the decision was the right one.
Bluefume hahaha
So if I drop kick another player in the chest but I'm nowhere near the ball, that's OK too?
They don't seem to get that a foul in that phase of play rules out a goal, not just a foul on someone involved in the goal.
How they don't get it is fucking beyond me.
You have to be blind to believe that was the right decision. Or biased like fuck.
Absolutely horrendous call, our luck.
I guess another few man city fans just gave up on football
Doesn't matter.
Who is to say he wouldn't have dropped back to block it off the line?
Or, if the ref sees it in real time he blows up for a free kick to stop play & give the free kick.
Hence why the goal doesn't stand.
Ok. Shocking how many of you think that was good VAR?
Faintest of touches with no influence on play. Guess we’ll have to disagree here.
Faintest of touches with no influence on play. Guess we’ll have to disagree here.
Clear foul on Lovren. 2 hand push in the back. It was how Palace got the FK to begin with! And the push on Zaha was lighter.
Although I'm surprised VAR overturned the decision.
Could easily have let it stood and you'd have the pundits claiming it had no influence on the goal.
However if Lovren wasn't fouled, who knows, maybe he would have called for it and Fab would have left it instead of a desperate header that allowed their player to tap in.
Good call, although i'm very surprised VAR had the bottle to overrule it.
Although I'm surprised VAR overturned the decision.
Could easily have let it stood and you'd have the pundits claiming it had no influence on the goal.
However if Lovren wasn't fouled, who knows, maybe he would have called for it and Fab would have left it instead of a desperate header that allowed their player to tap in.
Good call, although i'm very surprised VAR had the bottle to overrule it.
If the referee sees it, he blows for a fee kick.
Simple.
No one has any way of knowing what Lovren does if he's not been FOULED & isn't lying on the floor, so no one knows if he prevents the goal or not.
We will if you (and others criticising the decision) continue to ignore the rules of football, Kristian. It DOES NOT MATTER TWO SHINY SH!TES how "faint" the touch was - totally irrelevant under the rules.
For all his qualities going forward for me TAA uses his hands way to often when defending... He has to learn, just like Lovren had to that defending well is not about winning ever ball or being first in every challenge
What? It's a foul.
Influence on play is a phrase taken from the offside rule, the fuck does it have to do with this case? They fouled our player, it could have happened on the halfway line and it still should stop play if it's a foul.
What has "influence on play" have to do with it. The rule book says pushing an opposition player is a foul, it says nothing about the need for the push to influence play
They got the FK from the same sort of "foul". A push from TAA on Zaha.
At least they're consistent. Ayew did the same on Lovren. Even though I thought it was still poor defending.
I think you’ll have to be rather generous to even call it a foul in the first place albeit he does invite such call as he uses his arms. This type of let’s check every other area of the pitch before calling it a goal-decisions wil ruin the game.
I am pro VAR but it shouldnt interfere in situations like this.
I am pro VAR but it shouldnt interfere in situations like this.
That is irrelevant isn’t it? I am talking about how VAR not should be used and their disallowed goal should be one page 1.
Hopefully we'll get a set piece goal or a worldie so we don't have to risk bringing Salah on today.
Mane, through on goal, wide.
Mane, through on goal, wide.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked