• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Adam Lallana

Status
Not open for further replies.
Confusing thread this. I thought at first that the reference to Carvalho was the rumoured 24m for William Carvalho when he hasn't really done much.

It has instead been confused with Ricardo Carvalho (who cost a bit less than that) and jumped on as an excuse for an argument.

Back to the song

 
Ah, so you aren't reading anything I write again.

Probably because I'm right, but let's just gloss over that. That's what you do best it seems.

I read the rest and felt patronised that some snotty little kid is telling me what i know and dont know about the game tbh.

A lot of stuff you write isn't worth reading, especially on this subject, try and deflect and spin away from the whole point of this debate all you like but you were basing Hendersons value on Isco's value to Real Madrid, frankly its a load of bollocks and flawed beyond belief.

You're just crying because you dont like being told your blithering and flawed logic is wrong, its not like im the only one with that opinion either, im just one of the few that will come out and say it, just like when you came out with that embarrasingly clueless post about all Southamptons players being very average, you have been simmering about that ever since and presumably want to get back at me, i guess this is the attempted attack.

You say i dont know this or that and im masquerading as someone with a valid opinion but you are describing yourself there, you really are, thats more than a bit tragic.

Another quite tragic thing is you saying 'oh i wanted Benatia last season', along with the hint of desperation in that sort of comment it sounds like you are trying to convince yourself rather than anyone else that you have some sort of clue.

Again you say i have no argument/s but i have, i just like to get to the point without all the fannying around unlike yourself, i always make a point of replying to people who quote/reply to my posts, as much as possible anyway and most definately see other points of view and am capable of admitting im wrong, again unlike yourself there on the last part.

You make out i overrate our players, maybe i do with some (dont we all?) but not with Hendo here, hes developed into a massive player for us and i recognise and appreciate that, you also make out because i want Lallana in a red shirt next season that im not interested in foreign players which again is a load of crap, im interested in class players especially the ones that will improve us now wherever they are from, if Lallana doesn't work out and we blow our load on Moura, Rakitic or Reus, someone of that calibre then that would be fine by me, the only agenda i have is wanting the best for Liverpool FC.

You carry on throwing that mud and talking bollocks though.
 
Walcott is worth twice what they paid for him, easily.
16M wouldn't get you Henderson now.

But you've saved the best for last; "I don't think Carvalho ever paid back the price tag".

Ricardo Carvalho? We're talking about the same player here right.

The Ricardo Carvalho that played for Chelsea?

You're saying he wasn't worth Chelsea's money? One of the best defenders to play in England in the last 10 years? Same guy?

I just need to be clear that that's the complete arsejuice that you're putting out there. Cos it may well be a banning offence it's that fucking dreadful an opinion.

Oh god, he's off again on the self righteous, I'll shout louder so my view is better vein of things!

my friend, I disagree, Henderson has had one great season, but he doesn't really score much and doesn't really assist much. He'll get better next year, and I love the lad. He was key to our engine functioning, so maybe 18M you'd get for him, because of his age and resale value, at this point. Maybe 20M. If he has a good season again and progresses, we can chat. But one season isn't enough. maybe even a good world cup would change that.

Walcott I find underwhelming. He has glimmers, but 24M? really? Would we pay that for him? No I didn't think so. Carvalho I've likely unappreciated here, but I'm not sure I ever think 24M for a defender is worthwhile. Ok, with the 8M they got back, I can see the case.

but the others are a little over the top, like yourself!
 
I read the rest and felt patronised that some snotty little kid is telling me what i know and dont know about the game tbh.

A lot of stuff you write isn't worth reading, especially on this subject, try and deflect and spin away from the whole point of this debate all you like but you were basing Hendersons value on Isco's value to Real Madrid, frankly its a load of bollocks and flawed beyond belief.

You're just crying because you dont like being told your blithering and flawed logic is wrong, its not like im the only one with that opinion either, im just one of the few that will come out and say it, just like when you came out with that embarrasingly clueless post about all Southamptons players being very average, you have been simmering about that ever since and presumably want to get back at me, i guess this is the attempted attack.

You say i dont know this or that and im masquerading as someone with a valid opinion but you are describing yourself there, you really are, thats more than a bit tragic.

Another quite tragic thing is you saying 'oh i wanted Benatia last season', along with the hint of desperation in that sort of comment it sounds like you are trying to convince yourself rather than anyone else that you have some sort of clue.

Again you say i have no argument/s but i have, i just like to get to the point without all the fannying around unlike yourself, i always make a point of replying to people who quote/reply to my posts, as much as possible anyway and most definately see other points of view and am capable of admitting im wrong, again unlike yourself there on the last part.

You make out i overrate our players, maybe i do with some (dont we all?) but not with Hendo here, hes developed into a massive player for us and i recognise and appreciate that, you also make out because i want Lallana in a red shirt next season that im not interested in foreign players which again is a load of crap, im interested in class players especially the ones that will improve us now wherever they are from, if Lallana doesn't work out and we blow our load on Moura, Rakitic or Reus, someone of that calibre then that would be fine by me, the only agenda i have is wanting the best for Liverpool FC.

You carry on throwing that mud and talking bollocks though.


Why is comparing the two flawed beyond belief? I'd say refusing to compare the two is a far more flawed approach to evaluating players.

I can't tell if you're a fantastic troll, or a complete moron. You keep harping on the same few points of argument, all centered around the idea that I must not know what I'm talking about, because I disagree with you on the quality of Southampton players.

Either way though, I explained exactly why your reasoning was flawed, and you again said the exact goddamn thing. I've explained exactly why your interpretation of my comparison of the two players was wrong, and again you just repeated your talking point.

You keep telling me my logic is flawed, I am a farce, I know nothing, etc etc. But you have done absolutely nothing to prove any of that outside of champion intangibles that will supposedly rise above the rest. And you don't even get to the point as you say, you just avoid the point and criticize my standpoint on the basis that I must know nothing, with no reasoning whatsoever.

The day you spout something that isn't just an ethnocentric cliche will be a day to behold. But until then, you're just another post I scroll past hereonout.
 
@BenSmithBBC: #LFC still in talks for Adam Lallana and Dejan Lovren also made an enquiry for Sevilla full back Alberto Moreno.
 
Why is comparing the two flawed beyond belief? I'd say refusing to compare the two is a far more flawed approach to evaluating players.

I can't tell if you're a fantastic troll, or a complete moron. You keep harping on the same few points of argument, all centered around the idea that I must not know what I'm talking about, because I disagree with you on the quality of Southampton players.

Either way though, I explained exactly why your reasoning was flawed, and you again said the exact goddamn thing. I've explained exactly why your interpretation of my comparison of the two players was wrong, and again you just repeated your talking point.

You keep telling me my logic is flawed, I am a farce, I know nothing, etc etc. But you have done absolutely nothing to prove any of that outside of champion intangibles that will supposedly rise above the rest. And you don't even get to the point as you say, you just avoid the point and criticize my standpoint on the basis that I must know nothing, with no reasoning whatsoever.

The day you spout something that isn't just an ethnocentric cliche will be a day to behold. But until then, you're just another post I scroll past hereonout.

You tragic bastard, lol, man up and take a bit of critcism on the chin, if i knew you were going to cry and whine like a little bitch i would have let your bullshit slide and spared the forum this pitiful show.

Btw you're a fucking hypocrite as well, in the Lambert thread saying positive things about him, why would you be happy in any way that a player you called very average a few months ago signing for Liverpool? no-one wants very average players playing for Liverpool, no-one that has half a clue anyway.

Thats the thing with people like you that talk shit, they have to have good memories to cover their arses otherwise people will pick up on it.

Go on then, spin yourself out of that one like the bullshit artist you are.
 
I've seen this sort of thing on those antique shows. The bloke chooses a mirror and a snuff box for about £200. Then he adds a glove stretcher and the dealer suddenly agrees to drop the price for all three. So Lambert is the mirror and Lallana is the snuff box. We just need a glove stretcher and we'll get them all for about £35m.
 
Apparently southampton want 30m. Seriously its time to walk away. When shaw and lovren leaves lallana wont want to stay and will try to force their hand.
 
£30 million? Do one. That's serious quality territory, and as good as he is, he ain't worth that. 25 at a push is all I'd pay.
 
Oh and his playing style, its really elegant isn't it?

The fact that he can run with his weaker foot and then switch it back to his right, and then back onto his left.

He really is made for our system...
 
In the poll I voted for 22.5M as the cut-off price. I could accept £25M at a push, but anything more and they should just kill the deal and move on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom