It is supposed to be about statistics, sabermetrics and in-depth analysis. When Fenway Sports Group became owners of Liverpool, their idea was to use a Moneyball approach to transfer dealings.
Given it had been hugely successful in baseball, principal owner John W Henry drafted in Damien Comolli to become Liverpool’s Director of Football and the intention was – and still is – to recruit players who tick particular boxes.
They must be young and talented. If they are ever moved on, they must have a re-sale value. They also have to have outstanding disciplinary and fitness records, while their OPTA stats must stand up to the closest scrutiny.
Look at the vast majority of the players Liverpool have signed during the past 12 months and you will see how they fit into the categories. For instance, it is worth pointing out that Liverpool hardly lose players to soft tissue or muscular injuries now and the squad rarely fall foul of referees.
This, neatly, brings us to Craig Bellamy. He should not fit the mode for the Liverpool player of 2012. For a start, he is 32. He has suffered with serious knee problems in the past and endured spats with referees and opponents alike.
But of all the players Liverpool have brought to the club in the past 12 months, only Luis Suarez has made a bigger impact. It is said the best things in life are free and Messrs Henry, Comolli and Kenny Dalglish would agree that the free transfer capture of Bellamy was an inspired piece of business.
So good was his relentless performance against Manchester City on Wednesday night that even is former team-mates Joe Hart and Micah Richards – who, remember, were on the brink of elimination from the Carling Cup – acknowledged Bellamy, as he left the field to a deafening ovation.
He, clearly, was the difference as Liverpool powered into their first major final for six years and it was intriguing to hear the comparison Steven Gerrard made in the aftermath, when asked to sum up Bellamy’s contribution.
‘Craig has been superb since he’s come in,’ Gerrard enthused. ‘He’s a fantastic professional who works really hard. He was a menace all night – that’s what type of player he is. He’s in your face, he runs in behind, he doesn’t let you settle on the ball.
‘I’m sure if he carries on, he can have the (same) impact at this club that Gary McAllister did.’
It is often said McAllister was the reason Liverpool landed an unprecedented Cup treble in 2001 following his arrival on a Bosman from Leeds. He wasn’t. Gerard Houllier had assembled a terrific squad that was packed with talent.
What McAllister did, though, was provide experience and he had the happy knack of scoring goals on the run-in that season at the most crucial times, like his penalty in the UEFA Cup semi-final against Barcelona or an astonishing injury-time free-kick to settle a derby at Goodison Park.
With his heroics against City, Bellamy has put himself on to a similar plain. Dalglish brought the Wales striker back on a deadline day last August to provide an impact but even he could not have envisaged the move turning out so well.
Well-liked by his team-mates – when Bellamy breezed through the doors of Melwood once again, it was if he had never been away – and loved by The Kop, this is how he anticipated it would have gone first time around, following his £6million arrival from Blackburn in 2006.
Of course, he only lasted 12 months back then and suffered the indignity of being left out of the squad for the Champions League final against AC Milan in Athens, even though his pace would have troubled the Italians back four.
No matter. He is making up for lost time and it could be said he has never looked happier at any stage in his career than he does at this moment.
‘Craig played wonderfully,’ said Dirk Kuyt, reflecting on Bellamy’s turbo-charged display against City. ‘He scored a great goal. But it’s not just been about this one game. For the last couple of months, he has played really well. He is a great help for this club.’
And no amount of statistics are needed to prove that point.