[quote author=Ryan link=topic=45116.msg1322962#msg1322962 date=1303971535]
[quote author=LeTallecWiz link=topic=45116.msg1322951#msg1322951 date=1303969513]
[quote author=Ryan link=topic=45116.msg1322860#msg1322860 date=1303945908]
I've time for Xavi, Messi and that's it.
[/quote]
Villa? Iniesta? Pedro? All excellent players who play the game properly, though Pedro has had a poor year (compared to last year).
Lastly, I'm a big fun of Pique. He is an excellent defender, very underrated.
[/quote]
I addressed Pedro earlier. i can think of two times last night when he lay on the floor after fuck all contact, so he can fuck off.
Iniesta did plenty of woeful rolling around at the World Cup. Villa - I'll give you that one.
and Pique's not a great defender at all. He can pass and play no doubt, but there's no actual defending to do in that Barca team cos they keep the ball for 80% of the game and hump most teams by half a dozen anyway. Which is fortunate for him cos he's slow as cold hardened shite. He's in that Barca defence for his ability to pass out from the back more so than his actual defending. He wouldn't have got a look in at United in front of Rio and Vidic anyway.
[/quote]
Was one of those times the time Marcelo accidentally stamped on him? Didn't see him ask for a card or anything ... I don't remember him doing anything that bad in the World Cup bar that 'non-pass' to Torres.
I assume your feelings about Iniesta are similar to those on Suarez (who wasn't a saint during the world cup either)?
He's slow? I actually don't think his pace is that bad ... and most defenders wouldn't get a look in with Rio/Vidic ahead of them - that being said, he's not done 'that' bad since moving to Barca (he's won everything there is to win in club & int'l football in 4 years). I think he's far better than you give him credit for BUT your logic re: possession is 100% right, so until we see him play for a club other than Barca or Spain, it will be hard to actually tell who's 'really' right.
[quote author=LeTallecWiz link=topic=45116.msg1322951#msg1322951 date=1303969513]
[quote author=Ryan link=topic=45116.msg1322860#msg1322860 date=1303945908]
I've time for Xavi, Messi and that's it.
[/quote]
Villa? Iniesta? Pedro? All excellent players who play the game properly, though Pedro has had a poor year (compared to last year).
Lastly, I'm a big fun of Pique. He is an excellent defender, very underrated.
[/quote]
I addressed Pedro earlier. i can think of two times last night when he lay on the floor after fuck all contact, so he can fuck off.
Iniesta did plenty of woeful rolling around at the World Cup. Villa - I'll give you that one.
and Pique's not a great defender at all. He can pass and play no doubt, but there's no actual defending to do in that Barca team cos they keep the ball for 80% of the game and hump most teams by half a dozen anyway. Which is fortunate for him cos he's slow as cold hardened shite. He's in that Barca defence for his ability to pass out from the back more so than his actual defending. He wouldn't have got a look in at United in front of Rio and Vidic anyway.
[/quote]
Was one of those times the time Marcelo accidentally stamped on him? Didn't see him ask for a card or anything ... I don't remember him doing anything that bad in the World Cup bar that 'non-pass' to Torres.
I assume your feelings about Iniesta are similar to those on Suarez (who wasn't a saint during the world cup either)?
He's slow? I actually don't think his pace is that bad ... and most defenders wouldn't get a look in with Rio/Vidic ahead of them - that being said, he's not done 'that' bad since moving to Barca (he's won everything there is to win in club & int'l football in 4 years). I think he's far better than you give him credit for BUT your logic re: possession is 100% right, so until we see him play for a club other than Barca or Spain, it will be hard to actually tell who's 'really' right.