[quote author=Hansern link=topic=34454.msg905579#msg905579 date=1247571565]
Their back 5 aren't good enough. I'd go as fare and say that the defence is shite.
Zabaleta was horrible last season.
Nedum hasn't proved anything. Pace and power, but intelligence and technique like a squirrel
Kompany is decent. Just had surgery though and is out for a while.
Bridge is good, but no world beater. Didn't impress at all when he signed last january.
Given is horribly overrated imho. If City want to be a top club, then a new Gk is a must.
I'm also quite critical to De Jong, who I don't find good enough.
And how on earth are they going to keep everyone happy?? Their squad will be massive in the end.
[/quote]
Given is a decent enough keeper - he's certainly no worse than VDS was last season or Almunia / Lehmann at times for Arsenal.
I can't say I thought Zabaleta was great on the few occasions I saw him, but City fans seem to rate him very highly and he did well for them in midfield, where he played quite often in the second half of the season.
Bridge on the other hand, I've heard nothing but complaints about.
De Jong hasn't gotten much praise - heard he's pretty limited, but he's young and new to the league, so there is reason enough to wait before fully condemning him.
Their defence could certainly do with improving and it may still be addressed this summer, but if the rest of the team could go some ways to making up for it.