I'd be less worried about his height and more worried about his tendency to throw the ball into mad coverage. But he knew he had to force things at A&M because their defence was non-existent, and he made strides between his two seasons. Generally, he is really accurate, has great feet, and his ability to throw off the wrong side is impressive. He'll have to tone it down in the league as he'll be punished for the slightest mistake (both on and off the pitch). I dunno. He's a risk, but the protection the QBs get now, it's not like he's entering the pros ten years ago when he'd get killed. The height isn't as much of an issue anymore. Ask Russell Wilson.
If a team wants a more typically 'pro-ready' QB, then Bridgewater and Bortles will will be the first names off the board. I don't know whether Hundley is going pro. I sort of hope he stays at UCLA another year, although maybe he'll look at Matt Barkley and get the fuck out while his stock is pretty high.
Spot on for me, height barely matters. I think the most overlooked thing in Manziel is that he's arguably the best pure passer in college at the moment, he has very impressive arm strength and accuracy both in the pocket and while scrambling.
The main concern is his tendency to try and fit the ball into tiny windows, but more often I would say that's due to confidence more than naivete. He's pulled off so many incredible plays and hit tiny targets that the chance is often worth taking. Most of his turnovers have been either into the end zone, or while deep into opposition territory, so I would say he understands risk and reward with those types of passes to some extent, he's not really costing field position after all, and needs to take some risks given how poor our defence has been.
I'm looking at this season's draft class, which is highly touted, and I think Manziel should be the 2nd QB off the board, after Bridgewater. I haven't seen a ton of Bridgewater, but I don't think he's as much of a surefire success as people make him out to be. I feel a bit that his ceiling is capped, but his high floor could be very attractive to some teams that desperately need production.
Bortles didn't look all that special against an average Baylor defence, but I can see him climbing up the boards(a bit like Weeden a few years back), but amounting in very little. He should go to the NFL and ride his draft stock though, should give a healthy payday. I wouldn't be surprised to see a team draft a top QB and McCarron though, a bit like the Redskins did with RGIII and Cousins, but it's a matter of how much interest there is. I mean, Christian Ponder was a high pick a few years back...
Hundley though seems like a poor man's Manziel, he was very inaccurate in his bowl game. People seem to be really sold on his athleticism and potential, but that seems a bit flawed looking for a QB. Historically we've seen that a quarterback who's athletic is a huge asset, but an athlete playing QB can be a liability. For this reason, I think Derek Carr would be a better pick.
One note about Jake Matthews is that while he's considered the top lineman available in this year's draft, I'm not convinced he'll pan out well. Last season our line was incredible, but this season it's been very average, and there's been too many times Matthews has struggled. Lots of memorable false starts, and holding penalties. Nowhere near as well as Joeckel did last season.