Poll Mignolet or Karius

[gkmacca]

Karius won't play again in the PL this season...or in the League Cup come to that.

You mean play the same keeper in every game??? That'll cause a melt down on here come the next cup game!

 

[Hansern]

Klopp: "I know how strong #Karius is, but he couldn't show it in the last few games. Judging him in this moment makes no sense." #LFC

If ming is starting ahead of him, his career here is done.

Its not though... He's a young lad.

Klopp: "I'm really happy with our goalkeeper situation. That's why we don't have to rush Loris, who is a very big, big goalkeeping talent"

Klopp on Karius: "Unfortunately, he couldn't show how strong in the last few games, but I saw no reason to push him through this situation"

Klopp: "LFC is a long-term project, we know we have to be successful as soon as possible too. I know how strong Loris Karius is."

 

[gkmacca]

Klopp: "I know how strong #Karius is, but he couldn't show it in the last few games. Judging him in this moment makes no sense." #LFC

If ming is starting ahead of him, his career here is done.

Let's not be too hasty. He's got one more chance. If he blows that, he IS finished, but you don't bring in a keeper and then bomb him back out that quickly.

 

[Modo]

Karius next game will probably be in the FA cup.

 

[the count]

Karius next game will probably be in the FA cup.

Or until Mignolet fucks up, whichever comes first.

 

[moron]

Hard this question - both are at the same level and because we controlled the game so much better today; Ming did not really have much to do did he ? - so I guess the test will come when we have one of those silly games where we decide to let it all go again - then we will see if the extra training for Ming has done him good.

 

[Modo]

Funny how Karius had more votes before the game.

 

[Hansern]

 

[Oncy]

Funny how Karius had more votes before the game.

He still does Modo.

 

[King Binny]

 

[Modo]

He still does Modo.

Wasn't when I last checked.

 

[Sheik Yerbouti]

Mignolet but he's not good enough to win you a title either.

 

[Judge Jules]

Mignolet, who IMO shouldn't have been dropped in the first place given the decent form he was in at the time.

I'm not convinced about our overall goalkeeping options either though. Wouldn't do it this January but IMO we do need to review the situation next summer.

 

[Brizzle]

Manninger

 

[Dirty Sanchez]

Hard this question - both are at the same level and because we controlled the game so much better today; Ming did not really have much to do did he ? - so I guess the test will come when we have one of those silly games where we decide to let it all go again - then we will see if the extra training for Ming has done him good.

@moron Mignolet made more saves in the Boro game than Karius has had to have made in the last umpteen games. (Yes hyperbole but not by much.) That shot Mig saved on the near post - my speculative sense is that Karius would have had trouble with that, and Boro would have been back in the game.
I voted for Mignolet right off the bat - sure, he's not the long term answer. But the question isn't about the long term. It's about Mignolet or Karius. And right now it should be Mignolet.

 

[jexykrodic]

Decision making on this one has become quite easy for Jurgen Klopp, simply go with the goalie at present and switch him out if he drops a clanger. Both keepers know where they stand, both know a poor performance and you get the hook. Natural selection. Easy. Happens with all other positions, why not goalie?

This is known as the least worst method. Simplify and clarify in all things.