[quote author=keniget link=topic=44931.msg1363175#msg1363175 date=1310378111]
[quote author=FoxForceFive link=topic=44931.msg1363160#msg1363160 date=1310376815]
No, I'm pretty sure Mark explained each one & why they were not really an option.
Of course, as Jules correctly points out, we cant know for sure as it's the management & scouts job, but I'd be fucking amazed if they sat down, looked at a list of 10 players, decided who the best was, & said; "Ah, actually, I reckon he wants CL footy, so we'll ignore him, & him, & him, whose 4th on the list? Downing? Yeah, let's sign him without bothering the rest, I'm sure he'll come here."
I have enough faith in the management, not to blindly say I'll agree with every signing, but that I believe they will do their upmost to make sure there isn't a better option we're missing out on & that the player they're investing in is the best option we can get.
[/quote]
So we know very little about what happens behind the scenes but Mark knew enough to explain why each and every one was not an option?
What was that I was saying about having your cake and eating it?
A lot of people in this thread have made arguments against Downing and I've seen the likes of Mark agreeing with a lot of those points and yet there is this aggressive stance that being unhappy with this signing suddenly means you're deluded or simple enough to be swayed by a foreign name.
As for putting all our faith in management, Rafa planned an entire transfer strategy around Keane and Barry. The management aren't infallible and sometimes the fans opinions are actually worth something... at least in the context of a forum debate.
[/quote]
I think you're over playing the aggression card from your opposition on this topic Keni, do you not think the likes of Molby (with due respect, repeating his tirades over and over) and even Ross to an extent have been equally insistent with their opinions? I don't think there has been much aggression from either side tbf, just passionate opinion on the pros and cons, it's been a good debate. Assuming he's signing, it's down to the player now to prove the points either way.