• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Bye bye Jude

Status
Not open for further replies.
I do wonder if Moore, Ward et al had quit because Klopp insisted on buying Jude at the expense of others in seasons past, and Klopp is now realising his mistake.
 
There are two possible explanations for keeping those players and praising them so extravagantly. One is that Klopp's football insight has suddenly fallen off a cliff and he'd have made the same choices whatever the circs. The other is that he's been backed into a corner by an over-restrictive financial strategy and had to make the best of it, on the field in terms of squad selection and off it when making public statements. Given his record, I know which I think is the more credible.

See, this is why experience trumps knowledge always. Young uns are too eager to jump onto every clickbait bandwagon and believe every narrative that's being spun. Where as, the wiser, older ones, they observe and engage their brains first.
 
Klopp has clearly wanted to get rid of players, but valuations weren't met. You think he wanted ox and keita to still be here? Based on what?
 
  • Like
Reactions: mom
Reporter arseface: But will you be signing the new we need midfielders this window?

Klopp: "I have 8 midfielders!"
Lists names....
x
x
x

"Now you tell me which midfielder we need!"

That was a fuck up, and he has owned up to it.
I just cannot read this into some kind of maintaining squad harmony or player value context, even if it makes sense.
Sometimes things don't make sense.
 
Any truth to the journalist saying we bid £84m for him before pulling out?

If so that’s a laughable offer and situation. We forgo a couple of transfer windows worth of midfielders to make an offer that my Nan could tell you isn’t competitive.
 
Klopp has clearly wanted to get rid of players, but valuations weren't met. You think he wanted ox and keita to still be here? Based on what?
Well let's lower our fucking valuation, just get rid.
If we're a club that's strapped for cash and have to wheel and deal in the market, why the fuck are we letting players go for free?
Gini, Origi, Moreno, Can am I forgetting someone? Maybe Lallana too, who he kept around like a mascot.

And if you're able to sell Dele Alli, you're able to sell Ox. We even gave Ox a new contract, what the hell was that all about?
Klopp has no problem selling players he himself wasn't involved in buying.
But players he bought? I can't think of one who didn't actually want to leave himself.
Who is forcing Klopp to keep non-performing players?
 
Last edited:
Any truth to the journalist saying we bid £84m for him before pulling out?

If so that’s a laughable offer and situation. We forgo a couple of transfer windows worth of midfielders to make an offer that my Nan could tell you isn’t competitive.

That's like pulling out before getting it in.

Extremely responsible behaviour
 
Reporter arseface: But will you be signing the new we need midfielders this window?

Klopp: "I have 8 midfielders!"
Lists names....
x
x
x

"Now you tell me which midfielder we need!"

That was a fuck up, and he has owned up to it.
I just cannot read this into some kind of maintaining squad harmony or player value context, even if it makes sense.
Sometimes things don't make sense.

That is Klopp protecting his players in the press as i) if he sold Ox and Keita, there is no guarantee there will be money to replace them, (ii) and the midfielder he wanted was not available also. He knows that Ox is finished at the highest level. He is not Conte or Mourinho to run the roadroller on his players in the press. A big part of his ethos is community and working together and he is doing that.
 
Last edited:
We’ve always spent money we’ve earned in some shape or form. That is either transfers or wages. The money isn’t siphoned off somewhere else.
 
Well the money we spend is clearly not enough for a club that aims to compete at the top season in season out is it.
 
Spend more of our money.

This sustainable BS model will be highly regrettable once we fall further behind.
 
That is Klopp protecting his players in the press as i) if he sold Ox and Keita, there is no guarantee there will be money to replace them, (ii) and the midfielder he wanted was not available also. He knows that Ox is finished at the highest level. He is not Conte or Mourinho to run the roadroller on his players in the press. A big part of his ethos is community and working together and he is doing that.

I get that to a degree, but then he came back and said the press was right....
 
There are two possible explanations for keeping those players and praising them so extravagantly. One is that Klopp's football insight has suddenly fallen off a cliff and he'd have made the same choices whatever the circs. The other is that he's been backed into a corner by an over-restrictive financial strategy and had to make the best of it, on the field in terms of squad selection and off it when making public statements. Given his record, I know which I think is the more credible.

It all kind of makes sense now. The people leaving like Ward and co.

I can't help thinking that the lack of resources relative to the competition means that everyone has to work so hard - from backroom staff to players, to make up this gap with smarts, and perfect moves, and amazingness on the field, that eventually it falls apart.

Ditto. Would Klopp have signed his contract extension last April if he saw these coming? He obviously knew he will need to rejuvenate the squad and was up for the challenge. Won't be surprised if promises made weren't fulfilled - so, while he's "lucky" to be in the job after the season we have had, the same can probably be said of FSG/the club that he hasn't thrown his toys out of the pram ala Benitez/Conte.

The transfer deadline rush for centre back and midfielder suggested that restrictions were finally eased.

Dated Oct 2022 (after finishing 3 of the past 4 seasons with more than 90 pts):
"That (Champions League qualification) is always our goal at the beginning of the season, Hogan told SportBILD." -- reflective and fair from the way they manage our/their finance.

Untitled.jpg
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom