[quote author=Judge Jules link=topic=43933.msg1293761#msg1293761 date=1299100058]
[quote author=Avvy link=topic=43933.msg1293721#msg1293721 date=1299094165]
Comparisons are always made between him and Shankly; but if you ask me he has more in common with Paisley.
Both are brilliant, and both could be ruthless.
The difference is that Paisley (and Shanks) usually got people on his side by being honest and decent; but that scumbag probably thought he could get further by being a scumbag. He's used various tactics; but they all revolve around cajoling, threatening and bullying everyone and everything he could make use of. In some ways, he's been proven right, I guess.
He's been an incredibly successful manager; but it'll always stick at his craw that in a total of 9 years Paisley won 3 European Cups, 6 titles, 1 UEFA Cup and one or two FA Cups whilst it took him YEARS to win anything.
That's why he hates us so much.
It'll be a great day when that lump of shit (advance apologies to KHL) is finally out of football.
[/quote]
Good post. I mentioned Shanks in particular because Ferguson consciously modelled himself on the great man. If you haven't already read it, treat yourself to a copy of "If You're Second You Are Nothing", a fascinating and instructive comparison of Shanks and Ferguson's careers by Oliver Holt.
[/quote]
Thanks,Jules...not read it personally, but that was the book I was thinking about when you mentioned the Shanks reference.
I actually find the idea that he could be similar to Shankly very nauseating; both were Scots and very disciplined and successful.
But would Ferguson pick up a scarf kicked aside by a policeman and say 'don't do that, this is someone's life'...or tell Brian Reade that he didnt mind not getting honours because the people dishing out honours werent his people, because his people went to Anfield?
Not in a million years.
He could win 10 Champions Leagues, and he'll still never be thought of by the Mancs the way we think of Shankly.
Similar, but utterly different.
[quote author=Avvy link=topic=43933.msg1293721#msg1293721 date=1299094165]
Comparisons are always made between him and Shankly; but if you ask me he has more in common with Paisley.
Both are brilliant, and both could be ruthless.
The difference is that Paisley (and Shanks) usually got people on his side by being honest and decent; but that scumbag probably thought he could get further by being a scumbag. He's used various tactics; but they all revolve around cajoling, threatening and bullying everyone and everything he could make use of. In some ways, he's been proven right, I guess.
He's been an incredibly successful manager; but it'll always stick at his craw that in a total of 9 years Paisley won 3 European Cups, 6 titles, 1 UEFA Cup and one or two FA Cups whilst it took him YEARS to win anything.
That's why he hates us so much.
It'll be a great day when that lump of shit (advance apologies to KHL) is finally out of football.
[/quote]
Good post. I mentioned Shanks in particular because Ferguson consciously modelled himself on the great man. If you haven't already read it, treat yourself to a copy of "If You're Second You Are Nothing", a fascinating and instructive comparison of Shanks and Ferguson's careers by Oliver Holt.
[/quote]
Thanks,Jules...not read it personally, but that was the book I was thinking about when you mentioned the Shanks reference.
I actually find the idea that he could be similar to Shankly very nauseating; both were Scots and very disciplined and successful.
But would Ferguson pick up a scarf kicked aside by a policeman and say 'don't do that, this is someone's life'...or tell Brian Reade that he didnt mind not getting honours because the people dishing out honours werent his people, because his people went to Anfield?
Not in a million years.
He could win 10 Champions Leagues, and he'll still never be thought of by the Mancs the way we think of Shankly.
Similar, but utterly different.