[quote author=Judge Jules link=topic=40525.msg1182845#msg1182845 date=1285490819]
[quote author=localny link=topic=40525.msg1182759#msg1182759 date=1285448557]
For those who want more time for Hodgson, can you say why?
Liverpool Way? Could turn good? Just want to hear the logic, in case I'm knee jerking again
[/quote]
It feels weird to be taking up that challenge as I didn't want Roy appointed in the first place. However, here goes:
1. We've been here before. Kenny's time as player-manager started off in a VERY similar way, to the extent that the man himself gave at least one newspaper interview saying he'd go if the club wanted him to, and look how that turned out.
2. This few games into his first season, there is simply no way of making a sensible once-and-for-all judgment on how any manager will turn out.
3. Junking Roy now is bound to cost lots. He may well not have expected to be here that long anyway, but if his advisers are any good that'll be all the more reason to have beefed up the relevant clause(s) in his contract.
4. Adding to the general air of gloom and chaos around the club is the last thing we need, whether from the point of view of morale or from that of needing to keep the "product" attractive for potential buyers.
Let me be clear - I'm not arguing for the current situation to be ignored, or anything like it. Immediate improvement is required, and I'd be in favour of giving Roy an ultimatum (which I'd hope was set as a target for him when he was appointed anyway): top four by the end of this season or you're toast. Getting rid before then, though, runs the very real risk IMO of making things worse rather than better.
[/quote]
17.08.1985 2 - 0 Arsenal Anfield 1st Division Kenny's 1st game in charge
21.08.1985 2 - 2 Aston Villa Villa Park 1st Division
24.08.1985 0 - 1 Newcastle St James' Park 1st Division
26.08.1985 5 - 0 Ipswich Anfield 1st Division
31.08.1985 2 - 2 West Ham Upton Park 1st Division
03.09.1985 2 - 0 Nottm For Anfield 1st Division
15.08.2010 1 - 1 Arsenal Anfield Premier League Roys 1st Prem game in charge
23.08.2010 0 - 3 Man City City of Manchester. Premier League
29.08.2010 1 - 0 WBA Anfield Premier League
12.09.2010 0 - 0 Birmingham St Andrews Premier League
19.09.2010 2 - 3 Man Utd Old Trafford Premier League
25.09.2010 2 - 2 Sunderland Anfield Premier League
Can't see the 'VERY similar' really, Kenny team was an attacking creative team, he made clever substitutions and changed formation when needed.
Roy puts his head in hands so he can't see the mess on the field, and doesn't change anything unless a physio says 'you need to make a sub, player Xxxx is unable to continue'