Both teams spent big in the summer
People argue Rodgers should of been able to build upon the success of last season... he has failed with that.. not only in his transfer dealings, but he has been found out to be tactically inadequate on many occasions, unable to get his new signing to play or fit into his system..
With Van Gal, like Rodgers he has had signings that flunked... Di Maria and Falcao.. Like Rodgers he has had Horrendous Injuries to key players all season. Despite all that he took a team from 7th to 4th with a defense that was put together with a sticky back plaster, and a team on paper at times was worse than last season.. So I would say given the circumstances.. he did very well.. The target was Top 4.. he reached it....