[quote author=keniget link=topic=38017.msg1018186#msg1018186 date=1261253843]
[quote author=LadyRed link=topic=38017.msg1018167#msg1018167 date=1261252912]
He messed up by not selling Ronaldinho and Eto'o when he should have, they ended up costing him his job
[/quote]
Perhaps so (although Guardiola tried his best to sell Eto'o as well and that failure worked well in his favour). I think the end was when Ten Cate left - at least if he was the disciplinarian as was suggested.
Speaking of Guardiola, what would people think of appointing him?
I know it sounds far fetched but unless something has changed over the last month, his contract ends after this season and he, along with everyone else, is waiting to see what comes of the presidential elections. It's hard to see him walking away from Barca but who knows... it could happen and if it does, we might represent an interesting challenge.
It's a little hard to judge Guardiola though. The hard work was done by Laporta, Tixi Bergistain, Rijkaard and Ten Cate before he got there - he just breathed life into a world class team in a bit of a rut. He's done that fantastically well of course - and you could argue that we need the same doing to our team, only there is a lot more work to do.
In terms of style, I'd say he shares more than people might think with Rafa. Both value 'mentality' and fitness above all else, defending from the front and tactical organization. The beautiful football the team plays, I think comes more from the players they have - the team as a whole is a lot more functional now than during Rijkaard's time. Now we're seeing players like Keita get a lot of game time and of course Ibra up front, wonderfully talented as he is, is a different, more physical, proposition to the pace of Eto'o.
Anyways, if nothing else Ryan would be happy as 'ol Pep is quite stylish.
[/quote]
I'd prefer Rijkaard for the reasons you outlined above. He pretty much built the Barca team.
As for Pep Guardiola, I think he's a fine example of taking a chance on a young upcoming manager.
Whenever a name is mentioned as a possible successor for Rafa, you'll get some on here saying "well, what has he won? he hasn't won a CL.. or a league title.. ergo, Rafa is better". Guardiola (and Wenger when he first came) have shown that you don't have to have won major trophies, or have managed big sides, to qualify as a candidate for managerial positions at top clubs.