I really don't want to crash this thread, but this notion that I hate Carra is just not true.
Despite what you all think, I too think it's a bit sad that he'll call it quits.
To me it's like a chain being broken. The last link between the Liverpool of old and new will suddenly disappear. The last guy who played with Barnes, Rush etc.
Someone in this thread said something about wanting 23 year old Carra back.
No, never.
Right/Left back Carra is one of the reasons why I'm not his biggest fan.
But I did rate 26-30 year old Carra and I've also said that during that time he was one of the best defenders in the premiership. I wouldn't say top 3 like Ryan, though.
So overall my feelings about Carra are mixed but I don't hate the guy.