Gerrard sending off
- Thread starter Modo
- Start date
- Latest activity Latest activity:
- Status
I only saw it on a stream, but it didn't look that bad at all to me. Stupid, maybe, but borderline rather than stonewall as a red card.
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247757#msg1247757 date=1294587176]
Two footed challenge, could have really hurt Carrick. Clearly a red card.
Webb was wrong about the penalty but he got the Gerrard decision right.
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Bollocks.
Two footed challenge, could have really hurt Carrick. Clearly a red card.
Webb was wrong about the penalty but he got the Gerrard decision right.
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Bollocks.
definite yellow, harsh red ... Webb ended the game essentially with that call, and as he's got a track record with 'pro-Manc' decisions, I think we have a reason to be disappointed.
[quote author=FoxForceFive link=topic=43518.msg1247780#msg1247780 date=1294587579]
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247757#msg1247757 date=1294587176]
Two footed challenge, could have really hurt Carrick. Clearly a red card.
Webb was wrong about the penalty but he got the Gerrard decision right.
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Bollocks.
[/quote]
ditto, what a load of rubbish
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247757#msg1247757 date=1294587176]
Two footed challenge, could have really hurt Carrick. Clearly a red card.
Webb was wrong about the penalty but he got the Gerrard decision right.
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Bollocks.
[/quote]
ditto, what a load of rubbish
[quote author=LeTallecWiz link=topic=43518.msg1247782#msg1247782 date=1294587591]
definite yellow, harsh red ... Webb ended the game essentially with that call, and as he's got a track record with 'pro-Manc' decisions, I think we have a reason to be disappointed.
[/quote]
That's more like it.
Glad someone watched the game I did.
definite yellow, harsh red ... Webb ended the game essentially with that call, and as he's got a track record with 'pro-Manc' decisions, I think we have a reason to be disappointed.
[/quote]
That's more like it.
Glad someone watched the game I did.
[quote author=TheBunnyman link=topic=43518.msg1247764#msg1247764 date=1294587369]
I only saw it on a stream, but it didn't look that bad at all to me. Stupid, maybe, but borderline rather than stonewall as a red card.
[/quote]
My first reaction was it was a yellow. It looked worse on the replay but I still thought it was a yellow.
No doubt about the challenge being foolish; the only possible result was something negative.
I only saw it on a stream, but it didn't look that bad at all to me. Stupid, maybe, but borderline rather than stonewall as a red card.
[/quote]
My first reaction was it was a yellow. It looked worse on the replay but I still thought it was a yellow.
No doubt about the challenge being foolish; the only possible result was something negative.
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247757#msg1247757 date=1294587176]
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Whilst he's at it, maybe the rest of the team can apologise to Gerrard for playing like cunts all season.
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Whilst he's at it, maybe the rest of the team can apologise to Gerrard for playing like cunts all season.
[quote author=SaintGeorge67 link=topic=43518.msg1247802#msg1247802 date=1294587782]
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247757#msg1247757 date=1294587176]
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Whilst he's at it, maybe the rest of the team can apologise to Gerrard for playing like cunts all season.
[/quote]
Bingo. Well fucking said.
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247757#msg1247757 date=1294587176]
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Whilst he's at it, maybe the rest of the team can apologise to Gerrard for playing like cunts all season.
[/quote]
Bingo. Well fucking said.
Odd couple of threads to merge.
[quote author=Halmeister link=topic=43518.msg1247805#msg1247805 date=1294587837]
Odd couple of threads to merge.
[/quote]
Now I look like a twat, you can't escape me mods!
Odd couple of threads to merge.
[/quote]
Now I look like a twat, you can't escape me mods!
[quote author=FoxForceFive link=topic=43518.msg1247787#msg1247787 date=1294587674]
[quote author=LeTallecWiz link=topic=43518.msg1247782#msg1247782 date=1294587591]
definite yellow, harsh red ... Webb ended the game essentially with that call, and as he's got a track record with 'pro-Manc' decisions, I think we have a reason to be disappointed.
[/quote]
That's more like it.
Glad someone watched the game I did.
[/quote]
Yep it was a 50-50 ball, and i would have been disappointed if he didn't go in to win that ball. His boot was off the ground, and he deserved a yellow for that. Web is a shitbag. He won them the game...
But ya...whatever. Lets look at the positives and hope to thrash Everton. I hope Johnson plays on the right wing. Why didn't he play today?
[quote author=LeTallecWiz link=topic=43518.msg1247782#msg1247782 date=1294587591]
definite yellow, harsh red ... Webb ended the game essentially with that call, and as he's got a track record with 'pro-Manc' decisions, I think we have a reason to be disappointed.
[/quote]
That's more like it.
Glad someone watched the game I did.
[/quote]
Yep it was a 50-50 ball, and i would have been disappointed if he didn't go in to win that ball. His boot was off the ground, and he deserved a yellow for that. Web is a shitbag. He won them the game...
But ya...whatever. Lets look at the positives and hope to thrash Everton. I hope Johnson plays on the right wing. Why didn't he play today?
[quote author=SaintGeorge67 link=topic=43518.msg1247802#msg1247802 date=1294587782]
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247757#msg1247757 date=1294587176]
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Whilst he's at it, maybe the rest of the team can apologise to Gerrard for playing like cunts all season.
[/quote]
The team made me proud today. Worked their socks off.
You saw the look on Dalglish face when he saw the challenge on the monitor. He knew it was a red card.
He's the captain after all and today he not only disappointed me but he disappointed the new manager and the players who all were looking hungry today and ready to come from Manchester with a good result.
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247757#msg1247757 date=1294587176]
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Whilst he's at it, maybe the rest of the team can apologise to Gerrard for playing like cunts all season.
[/quote]
The team made me proud today. Worked their socks off.
You saw the look on Dalglish face when he saw the challenge on the monitor. He knew it was a red card.
He's the captain after all and today he not only disappointed me but he disappointed the new manager and the players who all were looking hungry today and ready to come from Manchester with a good result.
[quote author=m.l.l link=topic=43518.msg1247812#msg1247812 date=1294588084]
The rules say you can't go in two footed and you can't get off the ground, Gerrard did both, after looking at it a few times, it was the correct decision.
Anyone comparing Gerrard's tackle to Rafael's is just being silly, no comparison whatsoever.
[/quote]
This.
The rules say you can't go in two footed and you can't get off the ground, Gerrard did both, after looking at it a few times, it was the correct decision.
Anyone comparing Gerrard's tackle to Rafael's is just being silly, no comparison whatsoever.
[/quote]
This.
[quote author=Sunny link=topic=43518.msg1247800#msg1247800 date=1294587771]
Two footed off the ground is a red card. I thought it was a yellow at best at first but it was a red.
[/quote]
This. I cannot believe people are actually saying it wasn't a red. Two feet & off the ground is a red every day of the week.
Two footed off the ground is a red card. I thought it was a yellow at best at first but it was a red.
[/quote]
This. I cannot believe people are actually saying it wasn't a red. Two feet & off the ground is a red every day of the week.
Yes, technically a red I reckon but there could have been some leeway granted because gerrard didn't go right into the player but across him.
In a head to head, straight on tackle definitely. The direction from which both players came from, and the fact that the ball was there to be won, make it less dangerous. By the letter of the law it's a red.
I wouldn't have been surprised to see it given as a yellow, though. Nor was I surprised it was red.
I wouldn't have been surprised to see it given as a yellow, though. Nor was I surprised it was red.
[quote author=gene hughes link=topic=43518.msg1247837#msg1247837 date=1294588670]
Yes, technically a red I reckon but there could have been some leeway granted because gerrard didn't go right into the player but across him.
[/quote]
Leeway? With Webb?
hahahahahaha.
Gene is the comic genius of the site!
Yes, technically a red I reckon but there could have been some leeway granted because gerrard didn't go right into the player but across him.
[/quote]
Leeway? With Webb?
hahahahahaha.
Gene is the comic genius of the site!
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247818#msg1247818 date=1294588207]
[quote author=SaintGeorge67 link=topic=43518.msg1247802#msg1247802 date=1294587782]
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247757#msg1247757 date=1294587176]
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Whilst he's at it, maybe the rest of the team can apologise to Gerrard for playing like cunts all season.
[/quote]
The team made me proud today. Worked their socks off.
You saw the look on Dalglish face when he saw the challenge on the monitor. He knew it was a red card.
He's the captain after all and today he not only disappointed me but he disappointed the new manager and the players who all were looking hungry today and ready to come from Manchester with a good result.
[/quote]
I can't agree with that. He went in to play the ball and was a split second from winning it. He was unlucky. I think the red card was the correct call (letter of the law and all that bollocks), but it's not as if he was having a sulky game and put in a horrible challenge because he was pissed oof.
[quote author=SaintGeorge67 link=topic=43518.msg1247802#msg1247802 date=1294587782]
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247757#msg1247757 date=1294587176]
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Whilst he's at it, maybe the rest of the team can apologise to Gerrard for playing like cunts all season.
[/quote]
The team made me proud today. Worked their socks off.
You saw the look on Dalglish face when he saw the challenge on the monitor. He knew it was a red card.
He's the captain after all and today he not only disappointed me but he disappointed the new manager and the players who all were looking hungry today and ready to come from Manchester with a good result.
[/quote]
I can't agree with that. He went in to play the ball and was a split second from winning it. He was unlucky. I think the red card was the correct call (letter of the law and all that bollocks), but it's not as if he was having a sulky game and put in a horrible challenge because he was pissed oof.
[quote author=m.l.l link=topic=43518.msg1247812#msg1247812 date=1294588084]
The rules say you can't go in two footed and you can't get off the ground, Gerrard did both, after looking at it a few times, it was the correct decision.
Anyone comparing Gerrard's tackle to Rafael's is just being silly, no comparison whatsoever.
[/quote]
If that's what the rules say, then Rafael should have been penalised, whether you compare the two tackles or not. You can't have it black & white for one and shades of grey for the other.
The rules say you can't go in two footed and you can't get off the ground, Gerrard did both, after looking at it a few times, it was the correct decision.
Anyone comparing Gerrard's tackle to Rafael's is just being silly, no comparison whatsoever.
[/quote]
If that's what the rules say, then Rafael should have been penalised, whether you compare the two tackles or not. You can't have it black & white for one and shades of grey for the other.
[quote author=GOD_23 link=topic=43518.msg1247859#msg1247859 date=1294589787]
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247818#msg1247818 date=1294588207]
[quote author=SaintGeorge67 link=topic=43518.msg1247802#msg1247802 date=1294587782]
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247757#msg1247757 date=1294587176]
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Whilst he's at it, maybe the rest of the team can apologise to Gerrard for playing like cunts all season.
[/quote]
The team made me proud today. Worked their socks off.
You saw the look on Dalglish face when he saw the challenge on the monitor. He knew it was a red card.
He's the captain after all and today he not only disappointed me but he disappointed the new manager and the players who all were looking hungry today and ready to come from Manchester with a good result.
[/quote]
I can't agree with that. He went in to play the ball and was a split second from winning it. He was unlucky. I think the red card was the correct call (letter of the law and all that bollocks), but it's not as if he was having a sulky game and put in a horrible challenge because he was pissed oof.
[/quote]
Yeah it was unlucky but did he really need to win the ball like that in the middle of the pitch.
This isn't the first time we've seen Gerrard do that.
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247818#msg1247818 date=1294588207]
[quote author=SaintGeorge67 link=topic=43518.msg1247802#msg1247802 date=1294587782]
[quote author=Modo link=topic=43518.msg1247757#msg1247757 date=1294587176]
Gerrard owes his teammates an apology.
[/quote]
Whilst he's at it, maybe the rest of the team can apologise to Gerrard for playing like cunts all season.
[/quote]
The team made me proud today. Worked their socks off.
You saw the look on Dalglish face when he saw the challenge on the monitor. He knew it was a red card.
He's the captain after all and today he not only disappointed me but he disappointed the new manager and the players who all were looking hungry today and ready to come from Manchester with a good result.
[/quote]
I can't agree with that. He went in to play the ball and was a split second from winning it. He was unlucky. I think the red card was the correct call (letter of the law and all that bollocks), but it's not as if he was having a sulky game and put in a horrible challenge because he was pissed oof.
[/quote]
Yeah it was unlucky but did he really need to win the ball like that in the middle of the pitch.
This isn't the first time we've seen Gerrard do that.
S
Squiggles
Guest
[quote author=gene hughes link=topic=43518.msg1247837#msg1247837 date=1294588670]
Yes, technically a red I reckon but there could have been some leeway granted because gerrard didn't go right into the player but across him.
[/quote]
That sums it up nicely.
Yes, technically a red I reckon but there could have been some leeway granted because gerrard didn't go right into the player but across him.
[/quote]
That sums it up nicely.
- Status