Football Shithousery - you know you love it !

[Red rose]

His head looks photoshopped on.

I guess there’s a chance it could be, all the reactions seem to fit …who knows these days 😀

 

[bluebell]

that isn’t offside

Why isn't it 20 yards offside?

 

[Beamrider]

Why isn't it 20 yards offside?

Player is behind the ball when it's played, so onside. Not interfering with play as not in the keeper's eye-line.
It SHOULD be offside, but it's not.

 

[bluebell]

Player is behind the ball when it's played, so onside. Not interfering with play as not in the keeper's eye-line.
It SHOULD be offside, but it's not.

He scores so how is he not interfering with play? He is goal hanging albeit unintentionally, a head of any opposition player and then scores. I thought when Rashford scored against us it was a farce, this is far worse.

 

[Red rose]

He scores so how is he not interfering with play? He is goal hanging albeit unintentionally, a head of any opposition player and then scores. I thought when Rashford scored against us it was a farce, this is far worse.

You reckon that makes it real true shithousery 😀

 

[Judge Jules]

He scores so how is he not interfering with play? He is goal hanging albeit unintentionally, a head of any opposition player and then scores. I thought when Rashford scored against us it was a farce, this is far worse.

The question whether or not he's offside is decided at the moment the ball is played. He scores long after the ball's been played.

 

[bluebell]

The question whether or not he's offside is decided at the moment the ball is played. He scores long after the ball's been played.

It fucking makes no sense. A) You have an injured player, so the winger should have kicked it out B) That injured player could obstruct play C) The player that was attending the injured player was in an offside position and scores thus interfering with play - he was goal hanging the very reason, off-side rule was introduced

 

[Red rose]

 

[tombrown]

It fucking makes no sense. A) You have an injured player, so the winger should have kicked it out B) That injured player could obstruct play C) The player that was attending the injured player was in an offside position and scores thus interfering with play - he was goal hanging the very reason, off-side rule was introduced

WTF are you on about. The ball was cut back from the goal line so he wasn't offside. The bit where you drew a circle around the player, he was running with the ball, unless you count passing to himself, there was no pass until he got to the goal line, at which point the goalscorer has behind him.

 

[StevieM]

WTF are you on about. The ball was cut back from the goal line so he wasn't offside. The bit where you drew a circle around the player, he was running with the ball, unless you count passing to himself, there was no pass until he got to the goal line, at which point the goalscorer has behind him.

Bluebell in getting it wrong shocker!!!

 

[rurikbird]

Surely, the offside line is drawn at the last touch of the ball by the teammate who makes the pass, not the first touch. The play should have been stopped, but otherwise it’s not offside.

 

[StevieM]

Surely, the offside line is drawn at the last touch of the ball by the teammate who makes the pass, not the first touch. The play should have been stopped, but otherwise it’s not offside.

correct.

 

[rurikbird]

Poor linesman didn’t want to ruin his moment.

 

[bluebell]

Bluebell in getting it wrong shocker!!!

I am right, the rules are wrong. I think we can leave the debate just there

 

[StevieM]

I am right, the rules are wrong. I think we can leave the debate just there

No - the rules are fine, you just made a mistake, said something stupid and can’t quite bring yourself to admit you were wrong.

The Ref could and should have stopped the game as a man was down injured - offside played no part in that entire sequence of play.

 

[Red rose]

 

[bluebell]

No - the rules are fine, you just made a mistake, said something stupid and can’t quite bring yourself to admit you were wrong.

The Ref could and should have stopped the game as a man was down injured - offside played no part in that entire sequence of play.

I have moved on knowing I am right.
You should not let this eat you up, and move on too, its not good for your high blood pressure

 

[Red rose]

 

[StevieM]

I have moved on knowing I am right.
You should not let this eat you up, and move on too, its not good for your high blood pressure

My BP’s fine and you being wrong isn’t eating me up at all - in-fact I’m happy for you and ignorance to continue - it’s entertaining.

 

[Atlas]

Dunno where it belongs.

But by God does it belong