Is @peterhague morphing into Brendan?
Shut up? I'm typing, not talking, you fucking twat.
Let me, as someone who's been somewhere between the two schools of thought all along on this, try and be more specific about what my queries are.
I agree that a lot of comments on Benteke here (and to some extent in the media) have really been no more than superficial kneejerks and that there's quite a lot more to his game than some have said. My concerns aren't about his individual skill set but about his ability to fit in with our overall style of play. Rodgers himself has described the approach he wants from his teams as "death by football", involving both the midfield and the front line buzzing around like angry wasps, using possession as quickly as poss.and closing it down equally quickly when the opposition has the ball. My hesitation over buying Benteke - whom I'll support if we sign him - centres on whether he will fit successfully into that pattern of play, with its huge demands on mobility. Perhaps he can, but (a) I'm not sure about that and (b) I'm not aware he's done so previously.
A point here - I think part of the reason we went for Firmino is that he's excellent at those runs in behind the defence. One thing Benteke may be able to do well is create space by occupying defenders, and those spaces may well be exploited by Firmino. So really, he'd be making the runs Coutinho needs, not Benteke.
Is Firmino not a potential up and comer like Suarez?
How come a lot of the respected journalists are using the phrase Liverpool are going to trigger his release clause. What does this actually mean.
This was reported by James Pearce 2 hours ago, surely all it entails Ian Ayre calling AV saying we will pay it and we would be given permission to speak to Benteke what takes so long?
I think a lot of people have forgotten about him already.
Jesus, how do you know we didn't try our best to sign him but he had no interest? People assuming all these players would jump at the chance to join us need to get their head out of the clouds.Fucking loser's attitude.
Fitting for what this club is becoming.
A point here - I think part of the reason we went for Firmino is that he's excellent at those runs in behind the defence. One thing Benteke may be able to do well is create space by occupying defenders, and those spaces may well be exploited by Firmino. So really, he'd be making the runs Coutinho needs, not Benteke.
I'd much rather Benteke than Dost. Dost IS a big slow lump.I'm not all against Benteke but I'd rather we'd look into signing Dost from Wolfsburg.
Ah the unmistakable wit of a post-pedantic intellectual.
Yep.. I just find it baffling, why we never learn from our mistakes..SO our two most expensive players of all time are Andy Carroll and Christian Benteke.
Not knocking Benteke really - but that's 70 odd million. This is why we're out of the top 4.
Look Peter, it isn't up to me to defend myself against the accusations that I'm simultaneously a post-pedantic intellectual, a dimwit, and pretentious. I'd obviously say that I think you're talking shite. I will say this though, in support of my original accusation. Normally when you meet people off the site they can surprise and confound your expectations. Posters who rubbed you up the wrong way on the site, or you barely acknowledged, turned out to be good lads. Without mentioning names, I've heard from people who have actually met with you that you really are a total dick. It isn't a persona. That's really you.
Look Peter, it isn't up to me to defend myself against the accusations that I'm simultaneously a post-pedantic intellectual, a dimwit, and pretentious. I'd obviously say that I think you're talking shite. I will say this though, in support of my original accusation. Normally when you meet people off the site they can surprise and confound your expectations. Posters who rubbed you up the wrong way on the site, or you barely acknowledged, turned out to be good lads. Without mentioning names, I've heard from people who have actually met with you that you really are a total dick. It isn't a persona. That's really you.
Yep.. I just find it baffling, why we never learn from our mistakes..
I wouldn't necessarily make a point of telling you that, but you called me a prick so that's my excuse.