That's what they all say.
That's a real shame. He's a huge loss despite what some think.
Do you still think this ?
Absolutely this. The guy has been a constant in our team. Also there should be concern over Hendersons injury record and we kno Gini. Buying someone who is capable of his role is not easy.Do people actually think we would be better off without him? The only midfielder in the squad who can stay fit for 3 consecutive months and capable of playing multiple positions.No doubt we need new blood in midfield but I'd be much happier if it was Milner and Ox that made way and Gini in 12 months transitioned to the midfield utility role that Milner currently has.
Do people actually think we would be better off without him? The only midfielder in the squad who can stay fit for 3 consecutive months and capable of playing multiple positions.No doubt we need new blood in midfield but I'd be much happier if it was Milner and Ox that made way and Gini in 12 months transitioned to the midfield utility role that Milner currently has.
Yep to the last bit. In the next season or two it looks like we need to build a new spine and he's not gonna be here for that unless he takes on the Milner roleIt's not a case of whether we're better without him but whether his contract demands make it worthwhile to bring him back.
He's a good player who is on the decline. The difficulty is he's only ever as good as the team that he plays in.
Do you still think this ?
I've done this before. The maths is quite clear. Why on earth an extra year on the contract we've offered makes such a difference I'm not sure (which is the sticking point, he wants a 4 not 3 year contract), I've not seen anything which says the wages we are offering are not up to expectations. He's going for free this Summer. The salary for an extra year (say £6.5M @ 125,000 per week) will be more than covered if we sell him for a fee after 1,2,3 years and if he stays for the full 4 then he'll have been worth the extra year.Yeah.
He’s an important player for us. If for no other reason than the fact that he can be relied upon.
I’m not so sure his decline is going to be a steep one. He strikes me as someone who can maintain his level for a while yet.
That being said, I wouldn’t hand him a massive four year contract at this juncture.
We went ahead with Thiago and Henderson is clearly gonna be here for a while yet. We don’t want three midfielders into their 30s on massive deals particularly given the overall state of the squad.
Don't think Curtis is a replacement for Gini. Curtis is probably best suited as the 3rd CM - competing with Keita and Ox (and maybe Thiago as well) for that role.I would prefer to keep him for another season, but not lock in for 3-4 seasons. In Curtis we have a perfect CM replacement, and I feel the squad can cope without him bar another season with five CBs getting injured.
Don't think Curtis is a replacement for Gini. Curtis is probably best suited as the 3rd CM - competing with Keita and Ox (and maybe Thiago as well) for that role.
Gini does a huge of amount of pressing and defensive work as the 2nd CM, which would need to be replaced if he leaves, especially given how ever-present he is. A big part of why we've struggled this season is the lack of physicality in midfield this year - most of that has been to do with Henderson and Fabinho being forced to drop into defence of course. But if Gini leaves, he needs replacing with a player in a similar mould. Probably one of Bissouma, Neuhaus or Boubacar Kamara.