• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

The not so Official January Transfer Rumour Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
It is not Markovic, why would we pay that much money and then make him watch an academy match? it's some other kid nobody has ever heard of unfortunately
 
I can't believe I'm saying this, but one of the first things I thought was that we've probably got enough teenagers in the first team right now.

Still... interesting link and if he's as good as his supposed reputation suggests then it'll be quite a coup for us.
 
I can't believe I'm saying this, but one of the first things I thought was that we've probably got enough teenagers in the first team right now.

Yes and no.

We've got enough experience (or we should have anyway) with Gerrard, Lucas, Skrtel, Agger, Reina, etc - Similar to Ross, I don’t see the point in adding anymore 28 year olds to that, because what are they going to give us beyond a big wage bill? We’re not going to win anything for a while, so why not rebuild and get games into these younger players so that in hopefully 2-3 years time we’ve developed them to a point where we can properly challenge for things again?
 
Well for a start I had Suso in mind who is an attacking midfielder that plays centrally / on the wing much like Markovic. I think there is only so many teenagers you can give the appropriate level of faith and playing time to really mature. I'm not suggesting we shouldn't go out and buy the best talent we can find. Of course we should but it needs to be well thought through.

As for this idea of buying young so we can do well in a few time, I think it's a great theory, but how well it plays out in practice I'm not so sure. I think you have to be exceptionally lucky to a) have all your players hit their peak at the right time and b) keep a hold of your more talented players when you're shit. Spurs have done pretty well at moving themselves up over the last 5-6 years but they've had to buy and sell fairly frequently over the course of that time.
 
Vlad - something feels wrong about this - why are none if the big teams going near him.

Fair enough - if the transfer fee is reasonable and his wages are reasonable - and he's got the desire, then it could be great.

Something, just doesn't seem right - be it injury, attitude, desire or financials.

It almost has a whiff of the Acquilani's about it.

I might just be being overly cautious.
Spurs have reportedly been sniffing around, unsurprisingly , there are one or two twatters now saying United have made contact, but who knows.

regards
 
Well for a start I had Suso in mind who is an attacking midfielder that plays centrally / on the wing much like Markovic. I think there is only so many teenagers you can give the appropriate level of faith and playing time to really mature. I'm not suggesting we shouldn't go out and buy the best talent we can find. Of course we should but it needs to be well thought through.

As for this idea of buying young so we can do well in a few time, I think it's a great theory, but how well it plays out in practice I'm not so sure. I think you have to be exceptionally lucky to a) have all your players hit their peak at the right time and b) keep a hold of your more talented players when you're shit. Spurs have done pretty well at moving themselves up over the last 5-6 years but they've had to buy and sell fairly frequently over the course of that time.

All that's just a fancy way of saying that you've got a massive hard-on for Suso and don't want anyone else to come in and steal his thunder isn't it?
 
Ha! It's sadly a little more boring than that... I'm trying to be 'sensible'.

I hear you.

Regarding your other point about not trusting the 'buy young' policy so much. Well I hear that too, but if the alternative is what we've been doing for the last 5+ years of buying players at their peak or a fucking premium and getting nowhere, then I'm all for giving the former a go.

I know it's being selective, but give me the likes of Sturridge for 12M ahead of Downing/Keane/Whomever for 20M every day of the week. Even if Sturridge is shite, we'll get most of our money back. We can't say that for the Downing's.
 
Yes and no.

We've got enough experience (or we should have anyway) with Gerrard, Lucas, Skrtel, Agger, Reina, etc - Similar to Ross, I don’t see the point in adding anymore 28 year olds to that, because what are they going to give us beyond a big wage bill? We’re not going to win anything for a while, so why not rebuild and get games into these younger players so that in hopefully 2-3 years time we’ve developed them to a point where we can properly challenge for things again?


all well and good but what if these young guys aren't good enough ? What if we give them 2 or 3 yrs of playing time and then realise they're shite ..what do we do then ? And how many of them are really that good ? Sterling maybe and even then i don't reckon he'll be half as good as hoped .
 
all well and good but what if these young guys aren't good enough ? What if we give them 2 or 3 yrs of playing time and then realise they're shite ..what do we do then ? And how many of them are really that good ? Sterling maybe and even then i don't reckon he'll be half as good as hoped .

That's worst case scenario and that could happen, yes. Alternatively we could continue with the strategy we've had for the last half dozen years of spending over the top on 28 year old and then failing to off-load them cos they're on shithot wages, are old, shit and no one wants them. Which has us in 8th-10th position.
 
That's worst case scenario and that could happen, yes. Alternatively we could continue with the strategy we've had for the last half dozen years of spending over the top on 28 year old and then failing to off-load them cos they're on shithot wages, are old, shit and no one wants them. Which has us in 8th-10th position.


The best policy and balance is most likely somewhere in the middle . The big mistake we made wasn't buying players over 26,27 ...it was buying shite players full stop .
And young players who don't make it here don't really keep any value . Rightly or wrongly they are seen by the football world as having failed so nobody wants to pay for them. Look at Henderson for example .
 
Buy young or old, as long as they're not Henderson, Carroll, Aquilani, Cheyrou (young), or Downing, Keane, Adam, Cole, Poulsen (old), etc.
IE not complete and utter shite.
 

So you're saying there's a chance?

jim+carrey.jpg
 
Guillem Balague@GuillemBalague
I have been told 2day a great friend of mine will get his dream come true! U will all be talking about it later. What a clever replacement.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom