• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

The Lions 2013

Brian Moore was on the radio this morning poo-pooing the idea that it could have been anything other than deliberate.

Apparently if found guilty he'll get at least a fortnight's ban, maybe longer depending on the seriousness with which the panel views the incident.
 
Dean Ryan:
Well, it's a win, and it cannot be emphasised enough that that is the be-all and end-all for something as brief and intense as a Lions Test series. Get the win. Any way you can.
But the Lions got away with that, no question. There is a lot to work on. You could see Brian O'Driscoll in the huddle at the end making just that point to the group. It is so much easier, though, to work on putting things right when you've just won. That's why we should pause before reading on, just to celebrate that fact…
Right, now on to next week's to-do list. There were huge parts of the game that the Lions got taken out of. Australia, as we knew they would be, were so smart at removing threats from the Lions' game.
Take the lineout. Australia marked up the areas that might have given the Lions something to work with. Ben Mowen lurked at the back, while Kane Douglas stood in the middle with James Horwill, who jumped backwards and forwards. And they left the front completely open. Sure enough, time and again, the Lions threw short; time and again, they were able to do nothing with the ball. Stats-wise, I don't think the Lions missed a lineout, and if they're short-sighted they might be pleased about that.
But this is where the Australians are so smart. They don't care about lineout stats, they don't care about scrum stats. What they care about is what you can deliver off the back of them. The Lions were 100% at the lineout, but they were virtually all to the front.
This not the kind of ball a Warren Gatland side likes. It means Mike Phillips is not able to get his running game going. Instead, it forces him to pass long. And then the Lions are operating behind the gainline, and with no Jamie Roberts to smash them back up over it they are immediately under pressure.
The uncommitted defenders at the tail of the Australia lineout are able to make straight for the Lions midfield. Then, if the Lions don't win that initial contest for the gainline – and the cards are stacked against them in this scenario – that race around the corner for the next phase is always in the defence's favour. This completely took Phillips out of the game. Mowen was able to mark him, and every time he tried to make a break the defence was on the front foot.
Occasionally, the Lions varied it by shortening the lineout, but this left them with a midfield stacked with forwards. I'm surprised they didn't drive it more, if throwing to the front was what they were intent on doing. They took all that front ball off the top. Then, when they did go long, they drove that. Also, they were very methodical – and slow – on their approach to the lineouts, whereas, on Australian ball, Horwill would just walk in and say "go".
Not that Australia had many lineouts, particularly in the first half, which is a tactic that I talked about in last week's column and one I really feel the Lions need to address. They just don't kick for touch. They prefer to feed the Australia back three with long box-kicks. And Australia's counter-attack is lethal.
Kurtley Beale's break towards the end of the first half came straight from such a kick, and Israel Folau's second try was worked a couple of phases after one. The Lions defence is unstructured when facing a counter‑attack like that, and no one seems to know who's marking who. That's a big concern for them.
Now, I'm surprised the Lions don't look for a different option, and I'm surprised they're worried about putting the Aussies into a lineout, where the defence is structured. And we saw what happened when Jonny Sexton sent up a high ball towards the end. Australia don't play with a sweeper and they weren't rock solid under the high ball. The Lions should look to contest more.
Just don't do it, necessarily, anywhere near Folau. George North and Folau – now, that's a heavyweight boxing contest. Unbelievable. We often say that Lions series are defined by exceptional moments. Well, North's try was one of those. And Folau's tries were defined by two people. Will Genia's speed of thought is so much further down the line than anyone else's. Folau, meanwhile, just looks like the next freak of nature who is 6ft 5in, sits on the wing and can do special things. It's becoming incredible. This bloke should be playing in the back row.
So, make no mistake. We're in a Test series here. The Lions should be very relieved to be one up.
How did they win it? Well, their scrum, for the first hour or so, was superior. More than that, though, Australia missed five kicks at goal. It is a problem for the Wallabies with no obvious solution, but the Lions cannot afford to rely on that particular advantage. There's much to address. At least they can do it with the momentum of a Test win behind them.
 
Team for Tuesday:

R Kearney; S Maitland, M Tuilagi, B Barritt, S Zebo; O Farrell, C Murray; R Grant, R Hibbard, D Cole, R Gray, G Parling (capt), D Lydiate, S O'Brien, T Faletau.
Replacements: R Best, M Vunipola, M Stevens, I Evans, J Tipuric, B Youngs, B Twelvetrees, S Hogg.
 
Good, thought-provoking piece from Dean Ryan as per. I'm looking forward to seeing what he can do at Worcester Warriors next season.
 
Pens conceded:

Phillips - 2
BOD - 2
Corbisiero - 1
Vunipola - 1
Cole - 1
Davies - 1
Heaslip -1
Croft - 1
O'Connell - 1
 
Metres made:

North - 65
Cuthbert - 35
Halfpenny - 32
Corbisiero - 30
Sexton - 25
Davies - 22
Phillips - 21
O'Connell -20
 
More injury shenanigans from the Lions camp. Corbisiero appaz has a fracture. Tom Court, the Ireland prop who actually lives in Brisbane (??), has been called up as cover in case they can't get Corbisiero fit again, and will be on the bench for Tuesday's game.
 
1) Alex Corbisiero 7/10. did what he was selected for at scrum time. Busy around the pitch with one strong break and pass to Croft at the end of the 1st half. Will be happy with his Lions test debut
2) Tom Youngs 8/10. Strong around the park. Set piece throwing was a real bonus and played full of heart
3) Adam Jones 7/10. Scrum guru who dominated the set piece
4) Alun Wyn Jones 7/10. Physical, hard working and assertive. Impressive display.
5) Paul O'Connell 7/10. Worked hard around the ruck but not quite as dominant has he has been on tour
6) Tom Croft 7/10. Struggled to get in the game during the first half but better in the 2nd. O'Brien will want a good Tuesday performance
7) Sam Warburton (Capt) 8/10. Won the race to the breakdown which was no mean feat! Lead we'll in pressure game
8) Jamie Heaslip 7/10. Worked hard around breakdown and in defence.
9) Mike Phillips 6/10. Attacked fringes but marked out well by Aussies. Poor box kicks and needed to get ball away quicker. Genia won that battle today
10) Jonathan Sexton 7/10. Found it hard to launch backs because of lack of quick phase ball. Missed crucial tackle for Aussie 2nd try
11) George North 9/10. Sensational try and looked to have a second. Deadly in attack
12) Jonathan Davies 8/10. Strong carriers. Lovely left boot gave lions territory but little space in the backs
13) Brian O'Driscoll 7/10. Clearly frustrated at the early penalties against him. Continually got stuck in and had a lovely offload even if he didn’t sparkle as much as 12 years ago
14) Alex Cuthbert 8/10. Looked nervous, early drop but ran hard. Superb 2nd half finish
15) Leigh Halfpenny -8/10. Only blot to his copy book was his one missed kick
 
More injury shenanigans from the Lions camp. Corbisiero appaz has a fracture. Tom Court, the Ireland prop who actually lives in Brisbane (??), has been called up as cover in case they can't get Corbisiero fit again, and will be on the bench for Tuesday's game.

We could be in trouble in the scrum if Court gets anywhere near the test side. I'm surprised that Paul James hasn't been called up, he could be there with plenty of time to spare (for a spot on the test replacement bench)
 
More injury shenanigans from the Lions camp. Corbisiero appaz has a fracture. Tom Court, the Ireland prop who actually lives in Brisbane (??), has been called up as cover in case they can't get Corbisiero fit again, and will be on the bench for Tuesday's game.

Court is awful.

Gatland is making a joke of the jersey
 
AUSTRALIA

15 Berrick Barnes 3/10 What is it with him and head injuries? Before his latest he made little impression. One loose kick and a missed follow-up tackle helped North to his try. He looked what he is – short of match practice.

14 Israel Folau 8/10 Quieter in second half but difficult to remember him making a mistake and impossible to forget his good moments, which were from another planet – or maybe sport. Two brilliant tries and aerial dominance throughout.

13 Adam Ashley-Cooper 5/10 Has always been a hard worker, physical, aggressive and disruptive. Plenty of that, but not so much in the way of his pumping arms and legs on those charges he so loves. Yet another injured back by the end.

12 Christian Leali'ifano N/A Big tackle right at the start on Jonathan Davies. Too big, because it knocked him clean out. His game lasted 50 seconds. What have Australian backs done to upset the gods so? Freakish list of injuries last season and now this.

11 Digby Ioane 5/10 Couldn't really get going in his first game back from injury. Often on the shoulder, often charging into the heart of the midfield, rarely making any significant headway. Will be better for the run-out.

10 James O'Connor 2/10 Horrible game for him, really. Looked like a fish out of water at fly-half. Missed tackles and kicks, ran up alleys and spilled balls. Get him back out wide, where he is so lethal and where he ended up here.

9 Will Genia 9/10 Rarely can there have been so influential a performance on a losing side. Physical under the high ball and at close quarters, touched with genius when in space. Totally outplayed his opposite number. And everyone else, in fact.

1 Benn Robinson 6/10 A real trundler, this one. He rumbled through gaps, more than a lot of the backs did. Had more trouble holding on to it, though, once stopped. And the scrum was not a great success early on.

2 Stephen Moore 6/10 There at the heart of things when the Australia scrum stared down the demons and won a seemingly match-winning penalty. Carried and tackled relentlessly. One poor pass and one overthrow cost him a mark.

3 Ben Alexander 5/10 He and his prop mate combined well together in the loose on a couple of occasions. He is a great support player. But the Lions had the upper hand in the scrum while he was on, which is his first duty.

4 Kane Douglas 6/10 Very physical at close quarters, he was among the leading tacklers. He won a crucial turn-over in the second half and was authoritative at the restart. Doesn't contribute much at line-out, though.

5 James Horwill capt 6/10 Australia's only ball-winner at the lineout – and some of them required some taking. Otherwise he was as hard-working as any captain should be, but not often punishing. Helped steady scrum after early wobbles.

6 Ben Mowen 7/10 What a shift he put in. He had Mike Phillips in his pocket for long stretches of the game and saw him off. He carried from start to finish. Australia do not want for athletic back-row forwards.

7 Michael Hooper 5/10 Had plenty to do playing in the centre after the injury count piled up and actually became more prominent. Perhaps it's the nature of the position. On the side of the scrum he was quiet, even looked a little slight.

8 Wycliff Palu 5/10 Very quiet in the first half, almost not there at all. He improved markedly in the second, carrying repeatedly, if not damagingly and doing much to stop the Lions' runners round the fringe.

REPLACEMENTS

Pat McCabe (Leali'ifano 1) Selfless stint of tackling and carrying. Australia's injury curse continues. 6 Kurtley Beale (Barnes 39) The story was so nearly perfect for him. Australia looked a different proposition when he was on. 7 Liam Gill (McCabe 47); Sekope Kepu (Alexander 58); Rob Simmons (Douglas 69); James Slipper (Robinson 75); Nick Phipps (Ashley-Cooper 77).


LIONS

15 Leigh Halfpenny 7/10 In the end the main point of difference between the two teams was the accuracy of this man, and most of his rating points are for that. He did miss a hard one, and the world gasped, which tells its own tale.

14 Alex Cuthbert 4/10 Looked a bit lost for large parts of this one. His evening was redeemed by his try, but if the referee, Chris Pollock, was unkind to the tourists another might have disallowed that try for blocking.

13 Brian O'Driscoll 6/10 Struggled with the ref's idea of what was what at the breakdown early on, but he looked as classy as ever as the game wore on. Fine hands, little breaks, little chips and tackling. Lots of it.

12 Jonathan Davies 6/10 Had a superb opening half-hour or so. His carry put the first of the Australians off the field, his tough tackling shook them up and he managed to rip the ball off a prop. Quieter after that, though.

11 George North 8/10 Scored one of the great Lions tries, leaving a trail of defenders behind him. Then nearly in again, but foiled by his opposite number, who otherwise had the measure of him. Left trailing for Australia's first try.

10 Jonathan Sexton 7/10 Really grew into it. Seems to enjoy life without the responsibility of goalkicking. He couldn't lay a finger on Folau for his second try, but the variety of his play-making kept Aussie heads turning and the scoreboard ticking.

9 Mike Phillips 4/10 Out-played by his opposite man, but then wasn't everyone? He couldn't get his dynamic game round the fringes going, bar one break from deep in the first half, and his kicking was loose. Penalised in second half, then off.

1 Alex Corbisiero 6/10 Got through a lot of carrying and played his part in the Lions' more successful scrum combination. He looks fresh and mean, but was handed off by Folau for his try and lost ball a couple of times.

2 Tom Youngs 7/10 Excellent game. He burrows away at the heart of a defence with his relentless carrying and surely no hooker tackles more. His throwing at the lineout was clean and another part of the good scrum.

3 Adam Jones 5/10 His first duty is to push in the scrum, and on those occasions he was given a chance to he did so decisively. Otherwise, got among the Australians and made a proper nuisance of himself.

4 Alun Wyn Jones 6/10 Big point of reference. He seems to have the centre of gravity of a much shorter man, which translates into some effective carrying. Took a bit of lineout ball and was boss of the restarts.

5 Paul O'Connell 6/10 That bald head was never far away. He worked hard, and then with the Lions rocking he conceded a penalty. Normally lose a point for that, but this was one of those strategically appropriate ones.

6 Tom Croft 6/10 The Lions' principal target at the lineout and he didn't let them down. He mixed it enough round the fringes, as some seem to fear he won't, and was so often in support, as we all know he will.

7 Sam Warburton 5/10 Still to convince that he is at the front of the most competitive queue in the squad, on form alone. But he captains well and really is a most polite fellow. Not that the ref was particularly nice back.

8 Jamie Heaslip 6/10 Fine game at base of scrum and generally tidying up other people's messes. A night of hard work, rather than the hair-ruffling gallops for which we might know him better. He has class – but his heart is all there, too.

REPLACEMENTS

Mako Vunipola (for Alex Corbisiero 52) Dan Cole (for Adam Jones 52) Ben Youngs (for Mike Phillips 62) Richard Hibbard (for Tom Youngs 65) Geoff Parling (for Alun Wyn Jones 71) Dan Lydiate (for Tom Croft 73)
 
defo deliberate - it's the sudden movement of the leg which says it all, if he had lost balance, as he says, the movement would have been more gradual.
 
Whoever made the decision said something along the lines of he was off balance and didn't actually see AWJ because of other bodies on top.

And it doesn't really stack up
 
That was deliberate, he should have been banned. But he's fairly rubbish anyway, so it's no biggy.

Aussies would have won if Quade Cooper had played.

Lions backs no great shakes. Winger (not North) and stand off aren't up to much. Neither is O'Driscoll either these days.

Deans is staring down the barrel.
 
The criteria for selecting replacements now seems to be simply whose flight will be the cheapest. I'm not bothered whether we replace him - we've plenty of second rows out there already.
 
A warrant has been issued for the arrest of the Wallabies winger Digby Ioane after he failed to appear in a Melbourne court on an assault charge.
Ioane, 27, is facing a charge of unlawful assault after he allegedly attacked a man in the Melbourne suburb of Prahran on 9 March.
A warrant was issued when Ioane did not appear in the Melbourne Magistrates Court on Monday.
Ioane plays for the Queensland Reds in the Super Rugby competition and was part of the Australia team that narrowly lost the first Test to the British and Irish Lions on Saturday night.
 
That won't help them. Pity it wasn't Folau though.

Apparently George Smith is one of the additions to the squad this week.
 
Back
Top Bottom