[quote author=Wizardry link=topic=38437.msg1038468#msg1038468 date=1263965920]
[quote author=Spionkop69 link=topic=38437.msg1038242#msg1038242 date=1263934555]
[quote author=Avmenon link=topic=38437.msg1038020#msg1038020 date=1263913975]
[quote author=Spionkop69 link=topic=38437.msg1037469#msg1037469 date=1263848905]
[quote author=LadyRed link=topic=38437.msg1037222#msg1037222 date=1263831120]
[quote author=Rafa4PM link=topic=38437.msg1037215#msg1037215 date=1263830898]
No it's not the same at all Anita!
You said:
"the denial that he's done anything wrong born from the desire to desperately believe he's this wonderful manager which he isn't".
The fact is every single poster on here knows (and has regularly stated) that Rafa has made plenty of mistakes.
Of course posters who still think that Rafa is the right man to manage us will defend "many" of his actions that are being debated, especially when they have some very valid points.
You in your infinite wisdom may think that Rafa getting the boot is the obvious solution to all of our clubs problems, but believe it or not, not everyone else is so sure.
[/quote]
RPM, I can't *fathom* how people think he's the best man to carry on with the club in the state that it's in. Seriously, I can't. I can't ever remember things being so bad in my lifetime. Things are as bad as they've been for a long long time, and I don't understand how that isn't as unbearable to others as it is to me. The only way we have to turn things around is for Rafa to go.
[/quote]
Well Souness was less than 20 years ago so aren't you the lucky one. Or is it the spoilt one?
Wonderfully dismissive of anyone who doesn't share the same opinion as you too.
[/quote]
Well, I'm nearly as old, John... and I can remember darker days than these.
That seems to be a poor excuse to keep Rafa though.
If you think it's because he can dig us out of the shit-hole he helped fill in, then fair enough.
But if its because 'things could be worse', then I'm just more depressed than ever.
Because I also remember days far, far brighter than what we're living through now.
[/quote]
Where did I say this was a reason to keep Rafa?
[/quote]
You do, in general, take a liberal dose of angry pills when people suggest he should be gone Spion so perhaps your reputation precedes you.
The Souness years were, indeed, very dark. What followed the King's resignation was a horrible period because it was simultaneously the demise of a world power in domestic football and a very black stain against the name of a Kop Legend.
GH also ended in some dark days and plenty of people claimed that the club was about to disappear off the map of world and European football during his last two seasons. There were those who, with a marvelous demonstration of their ignorance, thought he'd taken the club further back than when he started.
The difference between these periods, though, is fairly clear.
1) When Kenny went there was a general recognition amongst many of us that we had to rebuild. Indeed there were plenty of us who felt that was why the King had gone - because he felt he was incapable of despatching from the club some of his mates and football buddies. That Souness didn't manage the rebuild is irrefutable and we certainly never looked capable of the title in those years but we also, to some extent, expected that pain as we walked through a very large shadow cast by a formerly great team.
2) In his last two seasons (or 1 and 3/4) GH really struggled with his commitment. That second last season, when we led the race and looked so assured, only to fall to pieces so badly was a huge blow to both the manager and the perception of the fans. Despite his statements to the contrary, Houllier reverted to his defensive approach with the strikers living off scraps and, ultimately, our failure to make top 4 that season was a shock that left us almost numb. The final season was a desperate struggle with Newcastle to make 4th - a battle we ultimately won. But at no stage during that season did we look likely to finish worse than 5th and always looked odds on for 4th.
This year Rafa is dealing with a more powerful Chelsea (although they were formidable in GH's last season) as well as a cashed up City. The Arse, mancs, Spurs, Brum and, arguably, Villa are no greater than the threats found back then. Yet this season we look very capable of fighting for 6th.
The last days of GH looked bleak but not this bleak. The performances during the reign of Souness were worse but expectedly so. The depressing part of this time is that, while there are genuine reasons why the manager should be excused for not launching a title challenge it's difficult to mount a credible argument as to why we are wedged between Brum and Fullham, eyeing off a mid table finish. City (who's next league fixture is at home to Portsmouth) and Spurs could really put a gap between us and 5th by the end of January.
[/quote]
Ah, perspectives.
Awaits other old farts to post.