[quote author=doctor_mac link=topic=44233.msg1290231#msg1290231 date=1298550214]
[quote author=Insignificance link=topic=44233.msg1290222#msg1290222 date=1298547667]
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=44233.msg1290181#msg1290181 date=1298536134]
Every year some club has a youth team that does really well. Most of them don't make it.
[/quote]
But it all depends a little how you run these teams. Why is Barcelona so succesful in bringing in own talent? Why were ajax top of the crop for a while? I believe that if the youth teams are used to create first teamers and not only to win the Youth cup there is a bigger chance to bring through first teamers. If you have an identified way of palying and the youngsters are bread into specific roles.... But in football you often change coaches and you often change strategy. And you often prefer to buy a player to fit a role, rather than create 5 youngsters for the same role...
[/quote]
This is true. In fact this is something that Rosco himself has been banging on about, the club having a fixed philosophy that it maintains irrespective of 1st team coach. This is likely not only to allow for us to be consistent at a 1st team level, but also perhaps, more consistent at developing talent.
[/quote]
It might be that it helps to have a DOFS if this is the way forward. I have no clue if Comolli is the right man... But if the DOFS has set his sight on a long term way of playing and can recruit First Team managers and youth team coaches which follows the strategy it could pay off better. But then again it is only changing the power to someone else and in the end we live of results, and will sooner or later be willing to pay us out of trouble if short term results are needed.
[quote author=Insignificance link=topic=44233.msg1290222#msg1290222 date=1298547667]
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=44233.msg1290181#msg1290181 date=1298536134]
Every year some club has a youth team that does really well. Most of them don't make it.
[/quote]
But it all depends a little how you run these teams. Why is Barcelona so succesful in bringing in own talent? Why were ajax top of the crop for a while? I believe that if the youth teams are used to create first teamers and not only to win the Youth cup there is a bigger chance to bring through first teamers. If you have an identified way of palying and the youngsters are bread into specific roles.... But in football you often change coaches and you often change strategy. And you often prefer to buy a player to fit a role, rather than create 5 youngsters for the same role...
[/quote]
This is true. In fact this is something that Rosco himself has been banging on about, the club having a fixed philosophy that it maintains irrespective of 1st team coach. This is likely not only to allow for us to be consistent at a 1st team level, but also perhaps, more consistent at developing talent.
[/quote]
It might be that it helps to have a DOFS if this is the way forward. I have no clue if Comolli is the right man... But if the DOFS has set his sight on a long term way of playing and can recruit First Team managers and youth team coaches which follows the strategy it could pay off better. But then again it is only changing the power to someone else and in the end we live of results, and will sooner or later be willing to pay us out of trouble if short term results are needed.