• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Ratings.

Forums Unread posts
Status
Not open for further replies.
[quote author=ILD link=topic=42699.msg1216187#msg1216187 date=1289490427]
KHL, it is unfair to give Shelvey one and Poulsen six. It doesn't make sense.

Shelvey is only a kid and found it tough playing out of position. He played a lovely ball to Torres which probably should have led to a goal. Poulsen on the other hand is a 31 year old vastly experienced player coming on in his favoured position and didn't contribute at all. Summing everything up, it isn't fair for one individual to get a rating of one and the other receives a six and that is why people are baffled by it.

I don't think posters are biased towards Jonjo only because he is English. I'm Irish (and have no bias towards English players) and don't agree with your ratings in this instance.
[/quote]
You are probably right mate. And I've gladly ammended to a 2 and 5er. I do believe Poulsens introduction somehow shaped us up a bit whilst keeping a bit of possession too. Shelvey had a mare but he's young and there's no harm done. Just saying.
 
No Khl, the difference is, if an English player is crap, I'd have no problem in saying he's crap, where as you will still try to convince everyone the player in question is great.
 
[quote author=LadyRed link=topic=42699.msg1216194#msg1216194 date=1289491269]
No Khl, the difference is, if an English player is crap, I'd have no problem in saying he's crap, where as you will still try to convince everyone the player in question is great.
[/quote]
Not really.

Poulsen has been mostly crap ever since he's joined. I'm not trying to convince anyone about anything else.
 
To be fair I don't know why people persist with the Poulsen stuff as KHL has long since admitted defeat on it.

Agger is a different story obviously 😉 Was it something like "If he leaves I'll be livid as should any true Liverpool fan"?
 
[quote author=KHL link=topic=42699.msg1216193#msg1216193 date=1289491217]
[quote author=ILD link=topic=42699.msg1216187#msg1216187 date=1289490427]
KHL, it is unfair to give Shelvey one and Poulsen six. It doesn't make sense.

Shelvey is only a kid and found it tough playing out of position. He played a lovely ball to Torres which probably should have led to a goal. Poulsen on the other hand is a 31 year old vastly experienced player coming on in his favoured position and didn't contribute at all. Summing everything up, it isn't fair for one individual to get a rating of one and the other receives a six and that is why people are baffled by it.

I don't think posters are biased towards Jonjo only because he is English. I'm Irish (and have no bias towards English players) and don't agree with your ratings in this instance.
[/quote]
You are probably right mate. And I've gladly ammended to a 2 and 5er. I do believe Poulsens introduction somehow shaped us up a bit whilst keeping a bit of possession too. Shelvey had a mare but he's young and there's no harm done. Just saying.
[/quote]

Cool dude.
 
[quote author=SaintGeorge67 link=topic=42699.msg1216200#msg1216200 date=1289491859]
To be fair I don't know why people persist with the Poulsen stuff as KHL has long since admitted defeat on it.

Agger is a different story obviously 😉 Was it something like "If he leaves I'll be livid as should any true Liverpool fan"?
[/quote]

Yep, I think me and The Count posted something similiar in another thread last week. KHL doesn't deserve a kicking when a Dane has a bad game but at the same time he needs to tone down his 'love' for them.
 
[quote author=SaintGeorge67 link=topic=42699.msg1216200#msg1216200 date=1289491859]
To be fair I don't know why people persist with the Poulsen stuff as KHL has long since admitted defeat on it.

Agger is a different story obviously 😉 Was it something like "If he leaves I'll be livid as should any true Liverpool fan"?
[/quote]
Things have changed with regards to that as well.

If he keeps on beeing injured it reads:

"If he leaves I'll be relieved as should any true Liverpool fan".

Still hopeful he'll somehow come through all this as I think he's a top player and one who could take us forward as a team. When fit.
 
Many English fans are obviously biased towards English players. Ive seen posts on here where posters want more "British Steel" (lol) in our squad, and the media is no different.
That said, KHL's obsession with Danish players is OTT.
 
Right, OK, let's leave the KHL kicking alone shall we?

We've done it to death, and while I'm as guilty of it as anyone, I don't like bullying

*straight face*

I mean it, though
 
[quote author=Herr Onceared link=topic=42699.msg1216320#msg1216320 date=1289506511]
Khl - 5
ILD - 7
Brendan -6
Mark - 6
Bunnyman - 5
Spiderneil - 3
[/quote]
I'm a 3 at max. I'm all over the place most of the time.
 
[quote author=KHL link=topic=42699.msg1216339#msg1216339 date=1289509418]
[quote author=Herr Onceared link=topic=42699.msg1216320#msg1216320 date=1289506511]
Khl - 5
ILD - 7
Brendan -6
Mark - 6
Bunnyman - 5
Spiderneil - 3
[/quote]
I'm a 3 at max. I'm all over the place most of the time.
[/quote]

you got an extra two for modesty.
 
[quote author=Herr Onceared link=topic=42699.msg1216320#msg1216320 date=1289506511]
Khl - 5
ILD - 7
Brendan -6
Mark - 6
Bunnyman - 5
Spiderneil - 3
[/quote]

So much win.
 
[quote author=Herr Onceared link=topic=42699.msg1216320#msg1216320 date=1289506511]
Khl - 5
ILD - 7
Brendan -6
Mark - 6
Bunnyman - 5
Spiderneil - 3
[/quote]

If Spidey had held a high line he'd have scored a lot more
 
[quote author=Rosco link=topic=42699.msg1216348#msg1216348 date=1289510371]
[quote author=Herr Onceared link=topic=42699.msg1216320#msg1216320 date=1289506511]
Khl - 5
ILD - 7
Brendan -6
Mark - 6
Bunnyman - 5
Spiderneil - 3
[/quote]

If Spidey had held a high line he'd have scored a lot more
[/quote]

Posting improves with a high line.
 
[quote author=Brendan link=topic=42699.msg1216185#msg1216185 date=1289490219]
I have been a supporter of plenty of players that have 'split opinion' among Liverpool fans:

Alonso, Kuyt, Riise, Magic, Bellamy, Kewell, Garcia, even Babel.

So that's not accurate at all. In any way.

Try again. Or rather, don't.
[/quote]

Is Agger not in that list? I thought he was a player you liked.

Anyway all the players in that list are very good footballers. Except for Babel, i would gladly have every single one of those players in our squad right now.
 
Agger doesnt really split opinions, though.

I think everyone thinks he's a good CB, it's just that he gets so much hyperbolic praise from some quarters that anyone pointing out that A) he isn't THAT good and more importantly B) he's always broken, is always dismissed as having agenda.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom