My natural instinct would be to agree that Melbourne went too far on their lockdown, but it is hard to completely sure, as surely it would depend on what the downside of it was? In terms of a lot less people getting ill with coronavirus then it has worked, but I don't know what the damage to the economy is, what unemployment is now like it Australia, what impact it is had on mental health etc etc.
That’s all going to depend on specific individuals.
There hasn’t been a negative economic impact to me personally.
The Melbourne lockdown will have undoubtedly helped protect other states from having to lockdown - so they’ve been able to minimise the economic impact nationally - and going into summer we look like we’re in much better shape than we could have been.
You can see that with the development of a 2 speed economy - unemployment figures are not as bad as first feared - outside of Victoria.
I think the majority view here is that, the lockdown was a necessary evil that may have gone on a little too long.
In terms of its overall harshness - a point that I think often gets missed, while people are talking about rights, etc, is that lockdowns need to be simple, easy to understand and open to as little interpretation as possible - which sometimes means they probably can be a little to harsh.
You tell everyone that everyone has to wear a mask at all times outside - it’s probably overkill but it’s clear and concise.
You tell everyone they aren’t allowed out for more than an hour to travel more than 5kms for anything but 4 very specific reasons - again it’s overkill, restrictive, difficult - but clear, concise, effective.
We had clear targets that were to be reached to ease off.
I compare all this to the UK - I thought the rule of 6 (or whatever it was, was confusing), mask wearing rules inconsistent, there appears to be no clear targets for when restrictions are lifted, regional lockdowns variable in their application, etc
It’ll mean, loss of jobs and likely negative economic growth for a few years - but it could have been much worse.