• You may have to login or register before you can post and view our exclusive members only forums.
    To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

The Fowler & Rush Question

Status
Not open for further replies.

StevieM

SCM's resident Beer Nazi, Wine Snob & Comic Geek
Honorary Member
So - if you could ask Robbie Fowler and Ian Rush any question, what would you ask?
 
Who is Liverpools greatest ever striker? No bullshit, just one name.

The King of course. Rushy was the best for goalscoring pure and simple, but for his all-round game it has to be Kenneth Mathieson Dalglish and I'm sure Rushy for one would endorse that.
 
The King of course. Rushy was the best for goalscoring pure and simple, but for his all-round game it has to be Kenneth Mathieson Dalglish and I'm sure Rushy for one would endorse that.

I was having this discusson with my Dad recently and he's watched all the greats play from the 1950's. Based on footballing ability only, he regards Suarez as the best player Liverpool have ever had and I find it hard to disagree.
 
I was having this discusson with my Dad recently and he's watched all the greats play from the 1950's. Based on footballing ability only, he regards Suarez as the best player Liverpool have ever had and I find it hard to disagree.

See now on technical ability maybe, but...

It's not hard for a player of his or Gerrards ability to shine in our current team/squad.

It's takes a footballing genius to consistently stand out in what was considered one of the best club sides in the world at the time - Kenny Dalglish, Graeme Souness, Alan Hansen did.

Not knocking Suarez's technical ability or skill though. I'd just rather have any one of those three today than Suarez cos they brought more to the team on it and did what needed to be done off it - shut their mouths.
 
See now on technical ability maybe, but...

It's not hard for a player of his or Gerrards ability to shine in our current team/squad.

It's takes a footballing genius to consistently stand out in what was considered one of the best club sides in the world at the time - Kenny Dalglish, Graeme Souness, Alan Hansen did.

Not knocking Suarez's technical ability or skill though. I'd just rather have any one of those three today than Suarez cos they brought more to the team on it and did what needed to be done off it - shut their mouths.
Souness?
 
Yep. In fact, think of Gerrard, but better!
Actually it wasn't all that relevant. Souey did fuck all wrong while he played for us. Kind of got to me the ' and did what needed to be done off it - shut their mouths.' bit. But that was after his initial managerial stint with us and shouldn't take anything away from what he did for us in the 80s.
 
Actually it wasn't all that relevant. Souey did fuck all wrong while he played for us. Kind of got to me the ' and did what needed to be done off it - shut their mouths.' bit. But that was after his initial managerial stint with us and shouldn't take anything away from what he did for us in the 80s.

Ok. I did mean when they were on the pitch.

Of course his management reign was different.....
 
big call. was he better than gerrard at gerrard's peak? I didn't see Souness play, but at his peak gerrard was the best player in the world (or there abouts).

Well I'm not doubting Gerrards prowess but whether he was best in the world at any time could have things to do with his rivals so I'm not using that as a barometer.

Souness had everything that Gerrard has. With one added bite. Controlled aggression. When Gerrard was younger he flew into tackles that were always going to get him in trouble. Souness knew when to impose himself on the game with his physicality.

He stood out in a team that was one of the greatest clubs sides of all time. I tell you what, I will do a deal. Souness was the best midfielder of his Liverpool generation and Gerrard is the best of his. Games changed and all that.

But seriously, Souness was a joy to watch, no matter what type of game he had to play - sleeves rolled up or the champagne Charlie midfielder or a mixture of both. Watch his performance against Roma in 1984. His hat trick in the European cup early rounds in 1981. The jaw breaker v Dinamo in 84 in the first leg and the revenge attacks he absorbed I. The second leg while we waltzed 4 goals past a team who were very, very good.

Souness was THAT fucking good.
 
Well I'm not doubting Gerrards prowess but whether he was best in the world at any time could have things to do with his rivals so I'm not using that as a barometer.

Souness had everything that Gerrard has. With one added bite. Controlled aggression. When Gerrard was younger he flew into tackles that were always going to get him in trouble. Souness knew when to impose himself on the game with his physicality.

He stood out in a team that was one of the greatest clubs sides of all time. I tell you what, I will do a deal. Souness was the best midfielder of his Liverpool generation and Gerrard is the best of his. Games changed and all that.

But seriously, Souness was a joy to watch, no matter what type of game he had to play - sleeves rolled up or the champagne Charlie midfielder or a mixture of both. Watch his performance against Roma in 1984. His hat trick in the European cup early rounds in 1981. The jaw breaker v Dinamo in 84 in the first leg and the revenge attacks he absorbed I. The second leg while we waltzed 4 goals past a team who were very, very good.

Souness was THAT fucking good.

ta. appreciate views from fans who saw us at our peak. it's difficult to imagine someone better than gerrard, but you put forward a good case!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom