[quote author=LarryHagman link=topic=33839.msg879130#msg879130 date=1243730747]
[quote author=ibromurph link=topic=33839.msg878924#msg878924 date=1243700215]
FA cup is just a glorified Carling cup nowadays. Unless it's part of a double or treble for the top 4, it's just a trophy for the lower teams to have their moment in The Lying Rag. That said, it does also allow you to save face from jibes of a "trophyless" season.
[/quote]
Don't agree with that whatsover, sounds like you don't live in England.
This thread might be 6 pages of slagging the Cup off but that's only because we're not in it.
[/quote]
I do live in England.. i was born here.. but i'll let that dig slide.
For me, when I was younger, the FA cup was a wonderful tournament, steeped in history. But over the last few years it's lost its 'mystique/magic'.
Perhaps it's due to the fact that the semi finals are now played at Wembley.
Perhaps it's because the final hasn't been contested by two 'big' clubs for a few years now.
Perhaps it's due to the arrival of foreign coaches like Benitez/Mourinho who have helped English clubs do so well in the CL (that the FA cup has taken a back seat).
But for some reason, apart from a 'nice' day out at Wembley and a little bit of silverware to say "well, we won something", the FA cup doesn't really mean much to me, personally. It's doesn't really say anything.
If you win the league.. you're the best in England.
If you win the CL.. you're best (or at least, one of the) in Europe.
If you win the FA cup.. well, it was a nice day out, I suppose.
Obviously, given the choice of the FA cup and nothing, you'd pick the FA cup everytime. Silverware is silverware and it keeps the trophy cabinet from catching dust.
But if given the choice of challenging for the Premiership (i.e. if someone said we'd be 3pts off the top with 5 games left and out of the FA cup) or in the FA cup final (against West Brom) and 10 points off the top with 5 games left, I think i'd go for the former.
Maybe it's just the high expectation, maybe it's arrogance, but I only care about us winning the league or the CL (the FA cup is just part of a double or treble, for me).